4 ms·
Some customers don't want a refund. They want Joyent to perform its half of the contract.
by jacques_chester 14y ago
Some customers don't want a refund. They want Joyent to perform its half of the contract.
- mikeash 14y agoYes, but slavery is illegal.
- jacques_chester 14y agoWhere do you get the idea that asking someone to uphold their end of a contract is equivalent to owning a human being?
- mikeash 14y agoAsking them to do it is fine, but you can't obligate them to do it. A contract can never force you to perform work, because that is slavery. It can force you to perform work or suffer some kind of penalty. In this case, I think the appropriate penalty is a full refund for all of the affected customers.
- jacques_chester 14y agoAre you a lawyer? I'm not, though I studied law for a while. What you say may be true of common law. But I suspect the doctrines of equity may have other ideas. The return of funds is not the same as lifetime hosting. Those clients want specific performance and equity may yet grant it to them.
- mikeash 14y agoNo, I'm not. And yes, the clients want specific performance, but do they have the right to get it? Seems like at most, the clients would be entitled to a refund plus whatever damages they could show (e.g. the cost of switching to a different service, plus any losses they take from other arrangements they made based on the promise of lifetime service). Could a court really order Joyent to keep providing this service against their will? Seems like restitution would be it.
- jacques_chester 14y agoSome people don't want damages or restitution. They want specific performance of the contract. In this case they may be in a position to get it. We're not discussing labour laws here, the slavery argument doesn't apply. This looks to me like straight up contract + equity. > Could a court really order Joyent to keep providing this service against their will? That's what an order for specific performance is for. I've emailed a self-described law nerd of my acquaintance. She geeks out on equity law, so this sort of case is right up her alley. I'll be interested to see what she thinks. Of course ... IANAL, TINLA.
- mikeash 14y agoPlease let me know what your law friend has to say, would really be interested in the reply.
- jacques_chester 14y agoI'm hoping to reap delicious internet points by posting it to HN when she gets the time to write it up on her blog. Keep an eye on http://skepticlawyer.com.au http://skepticlawyer.com.au.