3 ms·
AI is fundamentally learning the entire conditional probability distribution of our collective knowledge; but sampling it over and over is not going to fundamen
by ijustlovemath 1y ago
AI is fundamentally learning the entire conditional probability distribution of our collective knowledge; but sampling it over and over is not going to fundamentally enhance it, except to, perhaps, reinforce a mean, or surface places we have insufficiently sampled. For me, even the deep research agents aren't the best when it comes to surfacing truth, because the nuance of that is lost on the distribution.
I think that if we're realistic with ourselves, AI will become exponentially more expensive to train, but without additional high quality data (not you, synthetic data), we're back to 1980s era AI (expert systems), just with enhanced fossil fuel usage to keep up with the TPUs. What's old is new again, I suppose!
I sincerely hope to be proven wrong, of course, but I think recent AI innovation has stagnated in terms of new things it can do. It's a great tool, when you use it to leverage that distribution (eg, semantic search), but it might not fundamentally be the approach to AGI (unless your goal is to replicate what we can, but less spikey)
- MoonGhost 1y agoIt's not as simple as stochastic parrot. Starting with definitions and axioms all theorems can be invented and proved. That's in theory, without having theorems in the training set. That's thinking models should be able to do without additional training and data. In other words way forward seems to be to put models in loops. Which includes internal 'thinking' and external feedback. Make them use generated and acquired new data. Lossy compress the data periodically. And we have another race of algorithms.
- GTP 1y ago> Starting with definitions and axioms all theorems can be invented and proved This was the premise of symbolic AI, but this approach seems to have been abandoned now.
- gryfft 1y agoIt doesn't have to be AGI to have a major economic impact. It just has to beat enough extant CAPTCHA implementations.
- LPisGood 1y agoWe can already do that today