2 ms·
I see the difficulty of communications as the X factor here which is not so unknown. Our telescopes are not good enough to see a civilization like ours even on
by PaulHoule 2y ago
I see the difficulty of communications as the X factor here which is not so unknown. Our telescopes are not good enough to see a civilization like ours even on Alpha Centauri. It’s thought now we could observe a civilization like ours around a single star if we launch a probe past 500 au to the Sun’s gravitational lens. NASA wishes they could do that but it looks out of reach for now.
A ‘type ii’ civilization which could disassemble terrestrial planets could point a big-ass laser at us which we could see but maybe they don’t all (or ever) get that big. And they have to be motivated to do it.
If you want to visit another star you have to stop at the destination which is almost as hard as getting to speed but if you want to communicate a message which cannot be misunderstood you could bomb a planet with relativistic speed projectiles. Now maybe the average type ii civilization would not do that but maybe the fear that another one could so that might motivate a preemptive attack. It adds up to it being risky to attempt contact so why try?
Consider this message
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arecibo_message https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arecibo_message
to a star cluster 25,000 light years away. Even if somebody in that 300,000 star cluster has a telescope pointed in the right direction and the right time we could be long gone by the time they get a message back to us or maybe we forgot we sent it or now most of us live on another star…
- rbanffy 2y agoWe wouldn't be able to see, but radio detection is definitely possible. A type II civilization would possibly leave technosignatures we could detect with optical telescopes as well.