4 ms·
I think the problem with captchas is that they are too complicated even for humans. Its frustrating as hell to have to retype that crap 20 times before you get
by vaksel 18y ago
I think the problem with captchas is that they are too complicated even for humans. Its frustrating as hell to have to retype that crap 20 times before you get logged in.
Why can't the whole solution get simplified? A captcha that asks a user some real world question in clear text. Have one admin enter a set of questions, answers and links once a day from top Google News. And then have the widget match it to answers provided. Include a 30 second wait time after each failed attempt to hinder the bots.
I mean captchas get cracked left and right, because they are just a matching system...all you need to do is analyze the letters and retype them. By making it a question from News or Wikipedia, you'd improve the world by a) eliminating bot spam b) teaching people some new information c) and even promoting artificial intelligence research
As an admin I'd see this go as this:
[Enter Question]
[Enter Answer]
[Enter Hint Url]
Hell you can even monetize it by charging 1/100th of a penny per login attempt or make a partnership deal with a newspaper to get paid in exchange for using their stories
- ryanwaggoner 18y agoThis solution is interesting, but it fails on two counts: 1. You're making the process even more of a pain in the ass, not less, increasing the likelihood that real users will abandon the registration. 2. This doesn't protect at all from the human captcha-cracking farms.