7 ms·
Ask HN: I have three good ideas. Help me choose idea 1, 2, or 3.
Hi guys,
I have three good ideas, each of which I'd be capable of creating. But they're all significant investments of my time, and I really need help deciding which one is better.
My goals are: a business that will provide me with a reasonable income, in an interesting problem space, that will grow quickly allowing me to become self employed.
Having made a decision I can work much more quickly on the best idea.
________________________________________
Idea 1. Decent Performance Tools for Linux
Problem: Performance data on Linux is distributed in many places, obfuscated, and very poorly documented.
Idea: This started out as a better version of the unix top command that I mentioned on Hacker News at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=405361. I'd like to expand on this to offer a full suite of performance analysis tools - eg, an visual strace analyser, allowing you to:
* highlight errors
* focus on just what happened to a particular file
* fold 'the looking through every folder in ld.co.conf' into a neat summary of whether a library was found or not
* allow context for each recorded system call, eg, what each system call argument means, what package owns files being operated on, etc.
Pros:
* Its an area few people have explored, that I'm interested in.
Cons:
* I haven't figured out a decent way to monetize this. The community is used to free tools. Perhaps a Ghostscript style setup, where older releases are Open Sourced after a year, but the latest features require a subscription?
* Unix people often blindly prefer the way that Unix implements anything by default over alternatives - selling to them could be frustrating.
____________________________________
Idea 2. Overseas Buying Agent
Problem: When you travel, you can often find particular clothing brands are cheaper overseas. Converse is cheap in the US, but expensive everywhere else. Hugo Boss is cheap in Germany, but expensive in the UK. Australian Swimwear labels are cheap in Australia, but expensive in the US. Agent Provocateur is available in the UK, but sometimes not available at all overseas. Prada is cheap in Italy. But you can't travel all the time.
Idea: A web based overseas buying service. Full service, deliberately targeted at the fashion market, not a re-posting service. Users would log in, provide some instructions, and have a human agent purchase whatever they need in another country. The agent would open the package, insert a card, send the now 'as new' (but second hand) goods onto the user.
Pros: As an Australia -> UK expat, I have good contacts in Australia, the UK, Germany and the US. The business could be quite fun. My wife is in the fashion industry.
Cons: Potential for legal hassles, even though the goods are now second hand. Can I rely on my close friends to work, even if they're being paid?
_____________________________________
Idea 3. Security Analysis Tool
Problem: Large business need to check server's compliance to a known standard (eg, ISO security standards) and produce a report stating the compliance results. Have noticed in my last two day jobs that the solutions to do this are incredibly poor - unpackaged software, which don't comply with modern operating systems (eg, the Linux definition files are for Solaris circa 1992), far too many false positives, and no proper guidelines to actually fixing the servers.
Pros: I know businesses want these tools. They're easy to program. The competition is both technically poor, and poor to look at (making it hard to sell).
Cons: I'd be competing with some very large software companies.
- markessien 18y agoThe second idea is a cutthroat business. The competition will be fierce and they will be as agile as you are. Number 3 sounds reasonable, but have a way of reaching your customer before jumping in. You absolutely cannot rely on friends. If your business depends on that, forget it.
- vivekamn 18y agoRegarding 3): Selling to enterprises for a startup is a bitch. We recently a closed an order with ask.com for our product and the the second item in the very first slide in their go/no go meeting was 'What if Radaptive goes bankrupt'.
- nailer 18y agoSo what do you think? Are they all OK? All terrible? One stand our more than the others? Thanks for any and all feedback.
- jhancock 18y agoI like Idea 3 in terms of "you can makes money here". Your "con" on it is genuine but if you can make a product that saves time, you can compete. The first idea seems like a nice project but its risky as to if it will ever pay the bills. It is about time for the linux world to grow into paid software utils. I certainly wouldn't mind paying for such a tool. The second idea is too large a market to find and educate. Good service though, I'd like to have access to it if you chose this one.
- fallentimes 18y agoWhich one would you enjoy working on the most?
- nailer 18y agoI'd enjoy all of them in different ways. 1 scratches a personal itch of mine. 2 I enjoy because it involves (traditional) creative industries. 3 I'd enjoy because I know that 'enterprise' software is so bad it's almost fraudulent, specifically in this area, and I'd enjoy eating these guys lunch.