4 ms·
The markets do not dictate the fact that we can't afford to just all sit around and be total hippies. It's the universe and ecosystem we live in. The natural st
by jerf 14y ago
The markets do not dictate the fact that we can't afford to just all sit around and be total hippies. It's the universe and ecosystem we live in. The natural state of being is such that if you just sit around and play in the stereotypical sense of the term, you will die. If you can just sit and do nothing, yet still be watered, fed, clothed, sheltered, and medically cared for, it is because someone is working for you to have those things. They don't just spontaneously burst into being. It isn't capitalism creating this reality, it's entropy and evolution.
Despite superficial appearances, we are not rich enough to just let everyone do as they please. Efficiency and profit aren't "just" evil things, they are the lifeblood that allows people to do something other than work. You decry them, yet without them, you have no foundation to stand on to create the world you say you want. Be careful, lest you get what you are asking for.
It is the capitalist system that has created enough wealth to allow you to become detached enough from this reality to even begin to think these thoughts. It is a rare anomaly in human history, not our natural state of being.
- ricardobeat 14y agoThere is no "natural state of being" that we know of. Yours is just a prejudiced view of the ones "you have to sustain". We do have the resources to provide a basic life for everyone (exactly what happens in nordic countries as posted elsewhere). Most people will want to do something with their lifes instead of sitting around, simply because it's boring not to. There's a long, long road between everyone having food & shelter to the whole humanity fucking around. This reductionism is absurd.
- ctdonath 14y agoMost people will want to do something with their lifes instead of sitting around, simply because it's boring not to. Empirical evidence is not in your favor. Staring at a TV is quite satisfying to a distressingly large fraction of society.
- osdf 14y agoCould you be more specific with respect to 'empirical evidence'? In Germany, according to the Federal Statistical Office (https://www.destatis.de https://www.destatis.de), more hours are spent for unpaid work (100 billion hours) than for paid work (60 billion hours) (as of 2009). This gap seems to keep increasing. Also in Germany, numerous (sorry, can't find a citation right now) polls showed that about 80% of the people still want (and will) work more or less fulltime with a BIG. Funny enough, also about 80% of the people think that with a BIG the _other_ people won't continue to do so and instead become (or are already) lazy.
- ctdonath 14y agoSnip/edit: major mis-parsing of a key point. Suffice to say, countries don't last when ever more people rely on relative fewer producers. Greece and Spain tried and went too far: they just ran out of other people's money. Much of Europe is heading the same direction. Every communist country grids to a halt, with socialists tending the same. There is a glorious time of high living on other people's efforts, but greed and weariness win out.
- osdf 14y agoSorry, didn't see that the 'BIG' was mentioned in a different thread. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income_guarantee
- osdf 14y agoSo, you are saying that the majority (or, too many? how much is 'too many') of people in Greece and Spain are lazy? I don't understand 'pick up the tab', but the 'dwindling actual [german] workforce' will also become soon lazy? Why is the german workforce dwindling? Because of some 'lazyness' that's catching german workers? And then these workers will cease doing unpaid work (which e.g. encompasses stuff like running theater groups, looking after the elderlies, ...)? Of course they'll do, because now they have to work on underpaid jobs to 'prove their worth' to society and get enough food on the table for their families. It is widespread thinking here in Germany that those on welfare are 'keeping the welfare coming in and acquiring luxuries; they don't seem particularly motivated to work'. It is 'supported' by numerous shows (for whom? for those on welfare?) on TV. It is on the other hand clearly refuted by a huge range of studies from various disciplines (economics, social studies).
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- anamax 14y ago> We do have the resources to provide a basic life for everyone "We"? Why should I work so you don't have to? Seriously - why should I forgo a nicer car so someone else can "find themselves"? Of course, that makes me "greedy".