3 ms·
On several of Tyler Cowen's recent podcasts, he has said essentially "there are really only two countries that have AI, China and the USA. Does this mean that o
by mooreds 2y ago
On several of Tyler Cowen's recent podcasts, he has said essentially "there are really only two countries that have AI, China and the USA. Does this mean that other countries (like Peru) won't really have a functioning, powerful government when AI runs everything".
See https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/chris-dixon/ https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/chris-dixon/
> As you know, not many countries have serious AI companies, and even those in Europe may or may not last. They’re not obviously mega profitable. Let’s say you’re the government of Peru, and you can turn over your education system to some foreign, maybe American, AIs. You can turn over how your treasury is managed to the AIs. You can turn over your national defense to the AIs. None of these are Peruvian companies most likely. In the final analysis, are we even left with the government of Peru? Or has it, in some sense, been pseudo privatized to the companies that are running the structures, and indeed to the AI itself?
Interesting to have OpenAI offer up AI infra so other countries are not at quite as large a disadvantage. Also really good for their business.
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> when AI runs everything You can't be seriously considering fancy autocomplete word guessers are replacing governments when Musk can't even get Grok to stop telling Twitter users what a moron he is.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoFancy autocomplete is, today, killing people in at least two wars. We must stop dismissing the technical nightmare now at our doorstep.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- apwell23 2y agollms are killing ppl ? care to share any references ?
- selfhoster11 2y agoAnthropic is allowing the US government to use their services. This includes various intelligence organisations and their data analysis they presumably use to target strikes.
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> fancy autocomplete word guessers are replacing governments UK has had them in government since 2022, or maybe since Brexit/ Teresa May with her nickname Maybot. The decline in quality of governance has been so severe, that I’d wager you would not see a difference. Both sides of the isle seem to be full of unintelligent or inexperienced people that do not believe in anything or have a vision
- dzhiurgis 2y ago> Musk can't even get Grok to stop telling Twitter users what a moron he is what an oxymoron. this is testament how good grok is.
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoTouché.
- simonw 2y agoMistral mean France (and through it Europe) do have at least one very solid contender.
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> You can turn over your national defense to the AIs. None of these are Peruvian companies most likely. In the final analysis, are we even left with the government of Peru? Folks, this has already been happening for decades, western consultancies and think tanks have been pushing for privatisation and outsourcing to American firms and as a result many governments, like UK, have been hollowed. In many cases they haven’t got a grip and the country is running on autopilot. As the consultancies replace employees with AI, the outcome you talk about will be achieved, in about 5 years. No far fetched future required
- soared 2y agoIMO that analysis is shortsighted when looking at other technologies. Peru’s government would grind to a halt with say, windows/osx, excel, chrome, email etc. They are all tools that enable work. I don’t see AI being categorically different. In this hypothetical world where AI runs the treasury, is the US now in a massively better position to make treasury related decisions? Maybe? Does the US gov have a remote chance of abiding by these decisions? Etc. I can see Peru being disadvantaged if they don’t use AI, but if they contract out and set up their own stuff that they didn’t actually build - how’s that really worse? I feel like they let the US spend hundreds of billions in development costs and can now reap the rewards.
- selfhoster11 2y agoBy and large, those technologies do not come with an always-on umbilical that leads out of the borders of those countries. It is relatively easy to build out capacity, unlike with AI that requires extremely specialised hardware in vast quantities.
- 47282847 2y ago> They are all tools that enable work. I don’t see AI being categorically different. You don’t see the difference between a self-contained product, and a foreign subscription service with no influence over what it is delivering and the privacy and data sovereignty implications? Let alone the vast array of subtle manipulation possibilities in responses?