3 ms·
> Pakistan is not economically strong enough to participate in a war, and India is not interested Proxy war between U.S. and China. We’re moving the naval asse
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Pakistan is not economically strong enough to participate in a war, and India is not interested
Proxy war between U.S. and China. We’re moving the naval assets that were bombing the Houthis. India seizing Pakistan-administered Kashmir cuts Islamabad off from China.
- sandspar 2y agoThe Pakistan-India conflict is orthogonal to America and China's.
- slt2021 2y agoIt is useful for the US to isolate China from Iranian oil resources. Currently Iranian oil can go via Pakistan to China. Thats how Us operates: exploits old conflicts for its own immediate benefit, like it did with Ukr-Rus war. If some people die on both side it is acceptable for the Us, because these are not Us citizens dying
- maxglute 2y agoCPEC isn't viable energy coordidor yet - no completed oil/gas infra from Iran to Pak to PRC. Which only leaves trucks, and the roads not designed to support 5000+ trucks per day for Irans 1m barrels per day.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Thats how Us operates: exploits old conflicts for its own immediate benefit, like it did with Ukr-Rus war. This is realpolitik 101, and every powerful society does it. Like, India didn't help sever Bangladesh f/k/a East Pakistan from Islamabad because it was being nice. (I'm not saying every society exploits every old conflict. Just that if you need to do something, you start with extant fault lines. Like, if you're going to war with Nazi Germany you don't sideline the Soviets and British because that's mean or whatnot.) Also, the problem with Pakistan isn't that its ports could be used to import oil. It's that the ports are being configured for Chinese blue-water operations.
- slt2021 2y agoI can understand seizing opportunities in situations like this, however I cannot support instigating and creating these situations in the first place. https://m.economictimes.com/news/defence/pakistans-defence-minister-admits-support-for-terror-groups-says-did-this-dirty-work-for-us/amp_articleshow/120608504.cms https://m.economictimes.com/news/defence/pakistans-defence-m...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> cannot support instigating and creating these situations in the first place With all due respect, what you and I support isn’t super relevant to what will happen over the coming weeks.
- lazyeye 2y agoIt doesn't matter what it is, or where it's happening in the world, some people will always make it about the US. Always. It's tiresome.
- shadowgovt 2y agoThe US is the third largest country on the planet with the second largest nuclear arsenal and controls the currency that other countries denominate their international debt in. There's very little that happens in the world that does not touch or get touched by the United States. The USA doesn't have much choice in this.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Pakistan-India conflict is orthogonal to America and China's India is negotiating trade deals and weapons purchases with the West. (Historically, Moscow was its security source.) Pakistan got some F-16s in 2022, but otherwise has been deepending ties with Beijing. It's wild to suggest America's cold war with China is orthogonal to this conflict.
- sandspar 2y agoAsk a random Indian in India whether he'd be willing to die for the US. The US and China have interests in the area, so maybe I shouldn't have said the word "orthogonal". But the original commenter said a conflict between India and Pakistan would be a "US-China proxy war". Come on. India and Pakistan have enough reasons to hate each other. They don't need America or China's goading. And neither India nor Pakistan would accept their conflict being characterized as a US-China war.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Ask a random Indian in India whether he'd be willing to die for the US Not how proxy wars work. > India and Pakistan have enough reasons to hate each other. They don't need America or China's goading Not how proxy wars work. The backers enable. The proxies fight. > neither India nor Pakistan would accept their conflict being characterized as a US-China war This is how proxy wars work. They literally don’t if the proxies realise they’re fighting a foreign war on their homeland.
- sandspar 2y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI'm really not claiming anything that requires more than a cursory review of the history of proxy wars. Or, like, talking to someone who lives in a country we've recently proxy warred. The people fighting in the wars we proxied were fighting for a domestic cause. Outside powers then glommed onto that dispute. Nobody thought they were dying for the superpowers' ends; they were fighting a local civil war or rebellion or reconquest.
- postingawayonhn 2y agoThe US isn't interested in picking sides. Historically it has tried to be friendly with both (though that hasn't always been easy).
- smt88 2y agoNothing about historical US foreign policy can tell us what the current regime wants or will do.
- happyopossum 2y agoGood. HN is full of posts about stupid crap the US govt has done in the past.
- cosmicgadget 2y agoDon't underestimate the stupidity of this administration. History could pale in comparison.
- smt88 2y ago"No the stupid crap of the past" != "smart" There are countless ways to be stupid and destructive, especially when you're actively trying to destroy your own country's institutions.
- tonyhart7 2y ago"US isn't interested in picking sides" but you dont want any of them to ally with russia or chinnese, ignoring problem also "problematic"
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> US isn't interested in picking sides. Historically it has tried to be friendly with both Sure, but one side offers clear benefits over the "ally from hell." (Islamabad, at the very least, has clearly picked a side.) Also, I'm not arguing what I think will happen. I'm arguing how this could escalate. And the only way I see it doing so is (a) someone bombs the wrong thing or (b) Beijing or Washington see an opportunity to win chips.