9 ms·
Well, they did have a comment: http://www2.amnesty.org.uk/blogs/press-release-me-let-me-go/assange-hypocrite-over-ecuador http://www2.amnesty.org.uk/blogs/press
by _delirium 14y ago
Well, they did have a comment: http://www2.amnesty.org.uk/blogs/press-release-me-let-me-go/assange-hypocrite-over-ecuador http://www2.amnesty.org.uk/blogs/press-release-me-let-me-go/...
- toyg 14y agoYeah, that was a month ago, when it was all fun and games. Now the Metropolitan Police is banging at the door of a foreign embassy to get hold of a suspect, and the time for jokes is all but gone. Now it's not about who's the best-looking media-darling, it's about principles and long-standing conventions in international relations. They would look fabulous by coming out swinging, saying "we can't stand the man, but the asylum principle is inviolable and not worth losing just to score a cheap point, so let him go to Ecuador if they want him." But no, silence. Had it happened in China or some godforsaken African hellhole, we wouldn't hear the end of it. It happens in London, chips are down, and now we're failing HARD at world peace. It make me very sad.
- objclxt 14y agoYou do know the UK has its hands tied here? The European Union requires member states to respond to EU Arrest Warrants. Sweden issued one, the UK must respond to it. Failing to appropriately enforce such a warrant would be a very serious matter.
- anthonyb 14y agoAmnesty International != The UK government
- toyg 14y agoRespecting a minor treaty on european police procedures is not worth jeopardising the Vienna Convention -- which is the cornerstone of any such treaty in the first place. European rules can and will be broken whenever national governments see fit, often without real consequences. You should know by now, after years of haggling on broken treaties about economy, national budgets etc. Besides, the UK government could simply broker an agreement between Sweden and Ecuador, where Sweden renounces the warrant in exchange for something else. Obviously, they are not even trying. This is what Amnesty should complain about, and loudly. So no, the UK government has not had its hands tied. Craig Murray states that Foreign Office civil servants rightly opposed the decision to pressure the embassy, and were overruled by William Hague. This is because they know what they're doing, whereas Hague is just the last of a long list of amateurish Tory hacks.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoIn terms of the asylum principal, this move actually undermines it somewhat. It's intended for politically motivated charges, not simple criminal ones such as the one faced by Assange. There may be a risk of an extradition request from the US but that can't override the fact that there is a serious crime that needs to be properly investigated and that Assange appears to have questions to answer. And it's not as if he's being sent to somewhere with a shitty human rights record or a dodgy judicial system. It's Sweden. Even if he doesn't trust them as a member of the Council of Europe they're signatory to the European Convention on Human Rights so he has the right of appeal all the way up to the European Court of Human Rights. I honestly can't think of too many places I'd rather be if I wanted my rights respected. It's certainly way above Ecuador on my list.
- Retric 14y agoAssange is facing politically motivated charges in the US that may include the death penalty.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoThen he'll be fine in Sweden, the Swede's won't extradite anyone who will face the death penalty. See here: http://www.sweden.gov.se/content/1/c6/01/54/35/77809ec6.pdf http://www.sweden.gov.se/content/1/c6/01/54/35/77809ec6.pdf. Page 3, Section 12, Point 3. Worth noting that this is the text of the "THE EXTRADITION FOR CRIMINAL OFFENCES ACT (1957:668)", rather than some statement of government position and therefore is binding in Swedish law. The government simply couldn't send him to the US without suitable assurances.
- KimbaLion 14y agoLet's post this again for the cheap seats shall we! So renditioning for torture: http://www.hrw.org/news/2006/11/09/sweden-violated-torture-b.. http://www.hrw.org/news/2006/11/09/sweden-violated-torture-b.... And life imprisonment in somewhere like GITMO (a la Bradley Manning) is just fine I suppose! Oh yes, I'm sure if you were Assange you'd feel SO much better now! Wake the fuck up! Law as written bears NO resemblance to what happens in practice (when it doesn't suit the Powers That Be), and that is just a very small part of what Assange is fighting against. Goddamn it gets tiring having to persuade/enlighten people who don't even realise Assange and Wikileaks are highting THEIR BATTLE for them! Show some bloody gratitude and at least educate yourself about the realities of this sordid world we live in. I think its the LEAST you can do to say thanks to people who ARE actually putting their life on the line for these principles.
- gaius 14y agoHe's not a suspect. He really did breach the terms of his bail. Regardless of any other allegations, he IS guilty of that.
- vidarh 14y agoThat is immaterial. He breached his bail conditions in order to be able to apply for political asylum. By this argument any dictatorship could avoid dealing with pesky asylum issues by simply forbidding its citizens to apply for asylum, so that they'd all be criminals when they do.
- slurgfest 14y agoYou are not 'failing HARD at world peace' until you are at war, or making others go to war. Peace does not mean 'total lack of controversy or dispute'.
- bluedanieru 14y agoIsn't London that city that has fucking surface-to-air missiles on top of residential buildings?
- mc32 14y agoWhen Bo, XiLai's police chief in ChongQing sought asylum from a US counsulate, the counsulate recognized the issue was less simple political and more a political AND criminal matter and sent Wang, LiJung on his way back into the hands of the Chinese authorities. Basically, even if the US thought there was a political/persecutorial aspect to this, they recognized the gravity of the situation (that there were overriding factors) and in the spirit of maintaining relations, decided to send Wang, LiJung out on the street. Had the US not handed him back to China, China would have made things very difficult for the US, in other areas, as they are wont to do. This illustrates, that asylum and Vienna conventions and such are respected to a good degree, but there comes a time when most actors recognize that there can be extreme extenuating circumstances which make it impractical to be strictly principled in cases resemble local disputes. In this case, Ecuador is willing to burn bridges as it were --on the other hand, it's convenient for them. It gains them some cred in their circles and have nothing to lose (immediately, commerce wise). I mean, it's not as though they are the paragon of freedom in LatAm.
- twelvechairs 14y agoThis is really weak. Nelson Mandela gratefully accepted support from Libya and Cuba in the ANC's struggles against apartheid... Does that make him a hypocrite? Amnesty would never say that in an official blog post...
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoMandela wasn't accused of rape last time I checked. I think there's a somewhat different level of self interest involved.
- webreac 14y agoRefusing to put a condom is quite different from rape is all the countries except Sweden.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y ago"Rape - On 17 August 2010, in the home of the injured party [SW] in Enköping, Assange deliberately consummated sexual intercourse with her by improperly exploiting that she, due to sleep, was in a helpless state. It is an aggravating circumstance that Assange, who was aware that it was the expressed wish of the injured party and a prerequisite of sexual intercourse that a condom be used, still consummated unprotected sexual intercourse with her. The sexual act was designed to violate the injured party’s sexual integrity." See the highlighted section. She was asleep. That's almost certainly going to be rape in the UK, the US, Australia or pretty much anywhere else you'd count as civilised.
- foobarqux 14y agoThere is evidence that she actually claimed she was "half-asleep".
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoIf only there was some mechanism for putting all the facts in front of a group of people who could work through them and decide whether he really did it or not... I agree, it's not clear cut. That's why we have due process, and that's all I want to see.