3 ms·
> I don't think grep ignoring .gitignore files is "a bug". I don't either? Like... wat. Lol. > Where we strongly disagree is that I believe aliases should be
by burntsushi 1y ago
> I don't think grep ignoring .gitignore files is "a bug".
I don't either? Like... wat. Lol.
> Where we strongly disagree is that I believe aliases should be used to add functionality, where you believe that it should be used to remove functionality.
Not universally, not at all! There's plenty of other stuff in ripgrep that you need to opt into that isn't enabled by default (like trimming long lines). There's also counter examples in GNU grep itself. For example, you have to opt out of GNU grep's default mode of replacing NUL bytes with newline terminators via the `-a/--text` flag (which is not part of POSIX).
Instead what I try to do is look at the pros and cons of specific behaviors on their own. I'm also willing to take risks. We already have lots of standard grep tools to choose from. ripgrep takes a different approach and tons of users appreciate that behavior.
> We're never going to see eye-to-eye on this issue so there's no reason to rehash it.
Oh I'm happy not to rehash it. But I will defend my name and seek to clarify claims about stuff I've built. So if you don't want to rehash it, then don't. I won't seek you specifically out.
> I don't want to start another fight (so not linking the last).
To be clear, I would link it if I knew what you were referring to. I linked our other interaction by doing a web search for `site:news.ycombinator.com "burntsushi" "godelski"`.
> If it wasn't clear, I don't ;)
OK, so you don't use ripgrep. But you're complaining about it on a public forum. Calling me rude. Calling me creepy. And then whinging about not wanting to rehash things. I mean c'mon buddy. Totally cool to complain even if you don't use it, but don't get all shocked pikachu when I chime in to clarify things you've said.
- godelski 1y ago> Calling me creepy I didn't call you creepy. I said it was creepy that you appears seemingly out of nowhere is a very unexpected place. I'm only giving this distinction because this category of error has happened a few times.
- 63stack 1y ago"I didn't call you creepy, I called your behavior creepy". This is just rhetorics.
- godelski 1y agoWhere did you come from? Yes, it is creepy when someone randomly appears just after you allude to them. It is also creepy when someone appears out of nowhere to make their same point. Neither of you were participating in this thread and appeared deep in a conversation. Yeah, that sure seems like unlikely circumstances to me and thus creepy.
- 63stack 1y agoThis is a public forum read by millions of people
- burntsushi 1y agoThat's a fair clarification. Then you can change what I said to, "calling what I'm doing creepy." I don't think much else changes. My points certainly don't change.