3 ms·
Why do we need another connector? This is a FU to existing apple dock device owners and an FU to ETSI (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETSI http://en.wikipedia.org
by sschueller 14y ago
Why do we need another connector? This is a FU to existing apple dock device owners and an FU to ETSI (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETSI http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETSI).
It's like Sony with Memory Stick, minidisc, betamax, blueray (the exception) etc.
- roc 14y agoIf "we" are "people who buy Apple products", then "we" want Apple to design their own connectors because their tightly controlled accessory ecosystem has resulted in convenient and dependable third party products. Not unlike the situation with apps from their apps store. Not everyone gets to throw anything they want in there - and that does have its downsides. But it also has its benefits. Benefits that "we" have voted for, with our dollars, time and again. Now, if "we" are "consumers in general", "we" can simply choose not to buy Apple products if we don't like them. "We" are free to find someone else who adheres to standards and see what an ecosystem of standards-based products looks like. And surely "we" know by now that Apple is going to make its own connectors whenever it likes. So this is no real surprise.
- willyt 14y agoI don't know about Memory stick, i've never used one but Minidisc and betamax were a better design than the things they were competing against but they didn't catch on or where quickly superseded by newer generation technology. This dock connector is a better design than microUSB and the existing dock connector. As to ETSI, MicroUSB is pretty flimsy, why not have a better design?
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoI've heard that the MicroUSB connector was designed to be flimsy so that if anything wore out it would be the cheap replaceable cable rather than the expensive device. From this blog article it would appear this new design does this backwards: "The solid parts are stronger because they’re solid. The flexible parts are weaker because they can move. Because the flexible parts are weaker, you want to make sure they are recessed so they can be protected."
- Gring 14y agoIt's probably several things: - USB plugs are not double sided, leading to confusion when plugging them in, and often resulting in material fatigue because people force to plug them in the wrong way (iPhones are plugged in much more often than - say - a USB mouse that stays connected most of the time). - USB plugs are either a host or slave, not both. On an iPhone, the dock connector needs be both: slave (when connected to a PC) or host (when a USB camera is connected through the camera connection kit). - expected functionality through form factor: this plug will provide audio in + out, video in + out, playback controls etc. Normal USB plugs don't guarantee that functionality. Some cars have a generic USB plug to connect to generic USB storage devices to play MP3s from - now those owners might expect the next iPhone to be compatible with them - but these cars with the generic USB plugs might not understand audio over USB. Other cars in the future might contain your proposed next generation iPhone USB plug, leading people to expect that they can connect any USB device and transfer audio over it.
- icebraining 14y agoThe second point is not true, USB OTG (on-the-go) supports both.
- cliang 14y agoWhy can't the circuit be smart enough to detect the orientation of how the plug is inserted without the need to double the number of pins? Manufacturers are looking to cut costs wherever they can and given the choice between whether to make these things easier to handle for consumer or making them buy a new cable that wears out faster, I'm sadly going with them leaning towards the latter.