4 ms·
What this article doesn't account for is the proposition that many, many historic armies did war bow volley fire, and we've never heard about it because they al
by tptacek 2y ago
What this article doesn't account for is the proposition that many, many historic armies did war bow volley fire, and we've never heard about it because they all got wiped out because it's such a bad idea.
- eviks 2y agoNot really, first, being wiped out doesn't mean literally everyone dying, but also it doesn't prevent the winning side from recording the victory and its cause
- acjohnson55 2y agoPerhaps oral traditions survive from soldiers sold into slavery from lost battles. Like somehow, the folly of volley fire made it into the name of some food dish. Or maybe they would have simply massacred any army so dumb as to try it.
- eviks 2y agoI don't understand the need to come up with some fancy niche (slavery, oral, food name) when you have the more common approach: as is usual, part of the army ran away, and it included people of all ranks, from soldiers to generals, and they recorded it in all the same ways all the other events for recorded in the same sources (including training guides) Then you continue to ignore the other elephant - the soldiers and everyone else who won battles also record history avoiding the slavery/food route And again, "massacre" doesn't mean 100%
- int_19h 2y agoOccam's Razor.
- permo-w 2y agoto me Occam's Razor is a fairly unsound thinking strategy, particularly in scenarios like this
- rocqua 2y agoI'd almost expect that to be so remarkable as to merit writing it down.
- tshaddox 2y agoA response which could be given just as easily to any claim of the form “X never occurred in human history.”
- Ekaros 2y agoI would expect victors to write down how amazingly stupid their opponents were and why that gives them god given right to now lord over them and their subjects...
- permo-w 2y agoyou may expect that, but my assumption would be that in most cases condescension and pettiness would fail to trump disinterest and dismissal