3 ms·
> Deteriorating conditions for the working class are the main driver of our push toward authoritarian government I don’t buy this anymore. The evidence is for
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Deteriorating conditions for the working class are the main driver of our push toward authoritarian government
I don’t buy this anymore. The evidence is for a simpler hypothesis: 20 to 30% of Americans are stupid. They vote against their own economic interests, which doesn’t make sense if wealth is the problem. My personal hypothesis is lead exposure. But further empowering that segment with wealth strikes me as counterproductive.
- arrosenberg 2y agoDoesn't explain it at all. The biggest swing from 2020 to 2024 was people under 45 voting for Trump at a much higher rate, mostly driven by men. Anyone under 45 was born at least 5 years after lead gas was banned in cars. They're mad because they don’t see a path to the future they were promised. Calling them stupid is patronizing and counterproductive, even if true.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI’m not saying all Trump voters are stupid. Just that there is a stupid subset that are not rationally motivated. It’s productive to call this out, because I think it requires reworking our political system to deal with their threat. Fortunately, MAGA seems eager to set the precedents we’ll need in the future. (It’s also not patronising because I don’t care what they do as much as that they don’t cause problems for other people. That’s defensive more than patronising.)
- tekknik 2y agoI propose another hypothesis, those that haven’t learned of the desire for real change instead of stagnant leadership will continue to make the same mistake each election cycle. Learn to read the signs instead of calling people stupid for not agreeing with you, and then following it up with an attempt to force their alignment.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago[dead]
- s1artibartfast 2y agoAre you using rationally motivated synonymously with economically motivated? There there's a lot more that motivates voters besides economics. My hypothesis is that it is simply broad spectrum culture war. Mass communication and global human mobility have simply raised the stakes or control over social Commons. The same time due to related factors, there is low agreement on shared social rules, vales, and priorities. In the sense that good fences make good neighbors, there is no clear fence today. There is no trust in institutional norms to provide protection, so every battle for power seems existential. I find it hard to argue with this. Real politik and the rule of the jungle have always been in effect. It is just less dramatic when there is consensus on the rules and limitations.