5 ms·
An Alabama landline that keeps ringing
- timcobb 2y agoIt's probably voip :/
- GuB-42 2y agoSo what? Do you mean it is not analog and latency is higher as a result? Then yes, it matters. I hate latency in voice calls, I already went into arguments because of that. I remember in a remote work meeting, we had a frantic discussion, with some disagreements and strong opinions, but it was productive and purely technical, nothing personal. But then someone angrily told me "stop interrupting me!", the thing is, I wasn't, and then, I realized that the latency was messing with us. Because of the latency, from her point of view, I interrupted her, and from mine, she interrupted me. That's when I realized how much it mattered, we simply can't have a normal conversation with high latency. Either we deliberately take turns, as if it was a traditional 2-way radio communication, or we may get these awkward situations, neither feel natural. High latency can be as little as 100ms (corresponding to about 30m of distance in real life).
- toast0 2y ago> Do you mean it is not analog and latency is higher as a result? Digital teleophony doesn't imply significant latency. PRI calling (T1/ISDN) is digital, but the sampling delay is minimal, and it's sent one sample at a time, so there's no packetization delay. VoIP tends to run a codec with sampling/encoding delays, and tends to be at least 20ms packetization, and then you have a jitter buffer and probably input and output buffering too.
- tcoff91 2y agoThe main problem is packet switching instead of circuit switching. Internet sucks for voice
- lxgr 2y agoAlmost all my calls these days are via OTT VoIP (FaceTime, WhatsApp, Zoom etc.), and I really can't say I notice much of a qualitative difference to old PCM lines – if anything, the opposite is the case; wideband voice makes longer phone calls much more bearable. And that's over unprioritized 5G/LTE and Wi-Fi. Properly prioritized VoIP, such as the one used in VoLTE and NGN networks, should have even better jitter and latency characteristics.
- toast0 2y agoI mean.... when was the last time you made a call that was full analog/PRI? Did you notice that cell phones had higher latency than landlines? 30-40 ms latency is probably the lower bound on a VoIP call [1]; most calls will be a lot more. But you might not notice it if that's all you have access to, or if all of your calls are long distance that it would never be good anyway. On long distance, you probably have a better transmission delay now over internet than you would have had over telephone networks, as cable routes have improved and routing is often more direct; that will probably offset some of the packetization delay. [1] You can do better, but it involves having great connectivity and sending lots of very small packets, and mainstream calling isn't willing to send 200 packets per second of 5 ms of samples when most people don't notice/complain about the latency when sending 50 packets per second with 20 ms of samples.
- lxgr 2y ago> when was the last time you made a call that was full analog/PRI? Probably 15-20 years ago? That would have most likely been over DECT, though, which adds 10 or so ms by itself (our wired landline phone was in a slightly awkward location :) > Did you notice that cell phones had higher latency than landlines? Compared to landlines, the most noticeable aspect of GSM wasn't the latency (unless the person on the other line was right next to me, in which case there was an echo), but rather the absolute potato quality compared to both G.711 landlines and modern VoIP codecs. > mainstream calling isn't willing to send 200 packets per second of 5 ms of samples Yeah, that would probably be too much overhead for most applications. But now you got me wondering: Do video calls have lower latency audio (assuming the codec can do better than 20ms in the first place), given that there's probably much more data available to send at any given time?
- myself248 2y agoIt still bothers me. Analog and TDM voice was magical and we didn't appreciate it until it was gone. VoIP was so much cheaper, the latency became the norm, and people who've never known anything different simply have no idea what was lost. It used to be that if you had two landlines in a large room, you could call one from the other, and your voice would go into one phone, electrically go across town into the switch, back out the other line, and out the other phone, before the soundwaves traveled the length of the room. It was _so_ good.
- mncharity 2y ago> interrupting [... timing ...] turns There's an old linguistics tale, AFAIR fuzzily, of Inuit kids going off to boarding school, and upon return, having lost interest in hearing from adults. The kids believe the adults have little to say to them. ... Because the kids' conversational turn-taking invitation pauses had shortened, and were going unrecognized. > as if it was a traditional 2-way radio communication If there was a low-latency side-channel for the end-points to coordinate, they might provide mic clicks and carrier noise for awareness? Like an electric car playing engine rumble.
- timcobb 2y ago> So what? It's not a microphone in a reciever oscillating a copper line. In my opinion, if it's voip it's not a "landline".
- lxgr 2y agoThere almost certainly still is one – from the handset or headset to the VoIP desk phone :)
- GuB-42 2y agoFor me, if it is a line and it goes through the land (i.e. by wire/fiber), then it is a landline. As opposed to signals going through the air, i.e. by radio. Except in very special cases, like emergency phones in ships, it is never a direct connection, there are at least amplifiers in the middle. So between a direct connection from the microphone to the speaker at the other end and VoIP, where do you draw the line? (pun not intended)
- rightbyte 2y agoYe latency is a major headache. You can't gave normal conversations. I think it is mainly a property of overloaded servers and background noise cancelling etc. I didn't have these problens when running Ventrilo or old p2p Skype.
- choonway 2y agohow far is the deep learning stack close to replacing them?
- slyfox125 2y agoBy definition, it will never replace "them."
- rafram 2y agoThey were already “replaced” by the internet decades ago, but people keep calling. As the article explains, there are still people in the US without access to the internet or knowledge of how to use it, as well as a lot of people who just want to talk to a human being. You can call 1-800-CHATGPT if you want, but there’s clearly still a place for this service.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- LadyCailin 2y agoHaha, I’m on such another plane of technology these days, my initial reaction upon reading the headline was that there was some persistent seismic event near the border of Mississippi xD
- charcircuit 2y agoYou could hook up one of the voice based LLMs to do this instead of the students.
- greenie_beans 2y agoyes let's remove every social bond we have and replace it with a computer
- Normal_gaussian 2y agoThe value, it would seem, comes from it being precisely not that.
- charcircuit 2y agoBeing precisely not a mobile app. I am saying that they can expose this functionality through the phone system like they are currently doing.
- cubefox 2y agoProblem with voice based LLMs is that they don't know when it's their turn to talk.
- slyfox125 2y agoThe point of it all is the human connection - not the answers.
- charcircuit 2y agoThe AI can provide both the human connection and the answers.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jdiff 2y agoIt is a severe reach to say that AI can provide human connection. At best, it can provide the illusion, for some. And for those people, I'm not going to say that that's not valuable or legitimate for them. But it's pushing it one step too far to imply that that's a good idea for everyone.
- trollbridge 2y ago800-GOOG-411 was planned to do a similar thing; the difference is that was online for 3 years and unceremoniously shut down, versus this one which is still in operation 72 years later.
- Etheryte 2y agoThe true Google way, someone got a promotion and then the product dies.
- kaonwarb 2y agoGoogle has squandered so much good will over the years. This is a good example: expenses wouldn't even be a rounding error, and it could have given so many average folks a positive experience with the company.
- BMc2020 2y agoI'm still using 2 RSS readers (Inoreader and TheOldReader) that I switched to after Google Reader shut down.
- crossroadsguy 2y agoAha! Minor blast from the past. I just realised my a/c might still be alive on there and there it was. I think I logged in after 3 or 4 years. Old Reader. I think I had deleted my a/c on Ino Reader. I used to follow couple of niche Hindi blogs and they shut down years ago; some Engish language as well (from all over the world). Most of them were anon. I kept coming back for years but they were gone. That's what killed the RSS/blogs for me, not the demise of Google Reader. It stopped being the place I knew in my own individual/idiosyncratic way. I suspect something similar would happen to podcasts for me, maybe sooner than I am hoping for. And podcast player apps.
- bigthymer 2y agoIt probably would have turned into a customer service line for all of their products they notoriously fail to adequately support.
- ryukoposting 2y agoWhat a heartbreaking way to end that article... but, what a way to make the message stick.
- divbzero 2y agoI was wondering if that missing period was intentional…
- kcatskcolbdi 2y agoThis is such a lovely read! I might even call the line later today.
- delichon 2y agoSomewhere someone is probably still working as an elevator operator too. Like when I was a kid I had a job shoveling coal into a boiler. And someone is still manufacturing buggy whips. The future is unevenly distributed. Call Bunny Watson and ask her, she'll confirm.
- potato3732842 2y agoThere's probably some high bureaucracy workplace somewhere where only certain people are allowed to use the freight elevator but it needs to be used by others so much they just station someone who can use it there.
- bombcar 2y agoThere are still elevators that you need to be certified to use like mine elevators, and other form of commercial/construction devices so you could certainly see an elevator operator existing in one of those places.
- blamazon 2y agoI know of an elevator that is also a ticketed access point to a stadium so the elevator operator also scans tickets and gives out wristbands. Very nice for wheeled accessibility.
- FroshKiller 2y agoI visited a shopping mall in India in 2019 that still employed elevator operators.
- theobeers 2y agoAs recently as five years ago, the Fine Arts Building on Michigan Ave. in Chicago employed elevator operators. It probably still does.
- skinner927 2y agoThey’re being replaced. https://wgntv.com/news/cover-story/fine-arts-building-manual-otis-elevator/ https://wgntv.com/news/cover-story/fine-arts-building-manual...
- dabluecaboose 2y agoWhat a fun surprise to hear about the Foy info desk on HN! When I went to student orientation at Auburn, they made a point to call the desk as a demonstration and ask how many M&Ms would fit into Jordan-Hare Stadium. The answer was provided in under a minute. Back in the early 2010s when I was going to Auburn, the smartphone internet was still pretty young. It wasn't uncommon to call the Foy info desk to settle an argument. Really makes me want to swing back to Auburn for a visit. War damn Eagle!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- masto 2y agoI remember RPI had something like this in the 1990s. I can't remember what it was called though. But I do remember how impressed everyone was: if you call this phone number, they can answer ANY question! I believe those of us who were around from then to now experienced peak information. We went from having to look things up in libraries to being able to find anything with a Google search. We're on the downward slope now. Business models have changed, spamvertisers are winning the war against search, and generative AI slop is already the dominant source of "content", ensuring the genie can never be put back. This is not an anti-AI rant, it is just an acknowledgement that like so many things, we were foolish to think that access to information was just going to keep getting better. I did not expect that in my lifetime, I would see the best it was ever going to be. Maybe in the future, calling a trained human for help will be the only way to sort through the mountain of infogarbage to find something. Or we'll have to go back to the library.
- graemep 2y agoSadly, I agree with you. More optimistically, I hope doubt about know whether you are dealing with a real person or an LLM will encourage people to be more social offline.
- bee_rider 2y agoI remember “learning to use the library” was a thing growing up in the 90’s. It was funny because we’d come far along enough with the internet stuff that even the adults teaching this basically knew it was going to be a very niche skill. But still, something that every educated person was supposed to know how to do.
- ryukafalz 2y agoThat's still an important skill! You might think that everything that can be digitized has been and is easily available online, but that's not the case. Especially so for more obscure books and publications that are mostly relevant to your local area. When I moved to my current town and visited their library, I very quickly found some books written about the local area for which not much info existed online. It's a great way to spend some time if you're into that kind of thing!
- RebeccaTheDev 2y agoWhat a fun surprise to see this on HN! I had the opportunity to work the Foy Desk a few times during my undergrad at Auburn in the early 2000s - mostly as a volunteer while the regular workers would be in meetings. At the time we had a multi-page list of common questions and answers, the Internet (as it was then), as well as access to university computer systems for things like class schedule lookups. The most common questions I got then were from other students, most around when a certain class started or where it was located. This is was the early 2000s and, while a lot of this was available via OASIS (the Auburn student system) for any student, many either didn't have the computer savvy to use it or ... didn't have a computer at home at all! The most unusual call I took was from a student who was lost in Haley Center (the largest building on Auburn's campus - at the time, not sure about now as I haven't been back in decades - and somewhat difficult to navigate if you aren't familiar with its layout). The poor kid sounded absolutely panicked. I actually had to pull up a map and walk the him turn-by-turn until he found the main hallway again. As an aside, it's neat to see a few other Auburn alums on here. WDE!
- dabluecaboose 2y agoWar damn! Talking about being lost in the Haley center gave me flashbacks to freshman year. I still have dreams sometimes of trying to find the stairwell/elevator bank and the layout keeps changing like the backrooms.
- RebeccaTheDev 2y agoWDE! Ugh, yeah, some of those hallways especially in 1st and 4th quadrants where there aren't very many classrooms and not many people can have a very, very liminal space feel to them. I can totally understand how he got lost in there. Literally nothing about that building makes any sense unless you stand on your head until you almost pass out. :D
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoBut do you remember how many bricks there are in Haley Center?
- 2y ago
- karaterobot 2y agoI worked a reference desk around the turn of the century. Your public library probably still has one, though I think they may be pooled across different areas now, I'm not sure.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ForOldHack 2y agoI have called them,simply, twice only to thank them for their work.
- Mistletoe 2y agoWe got an old landline big red phone and we had it for quite a while using Magic Jack. It was a fun anachronism to have and use and give out to friends as a number we will always hear if it rings. I'm going to get it again when we move in a few weeks to a new house. As my friend Nick described it when we got rid of it- "It feels like the world lost a bit of whimsy". The world we live in needs whimsy. The Red Phone https://www.amazon.com/Desk-Telephone-2500-Analog-Phone/dp/B0BKZDZ63C https://www.amazon.com/Desk-Telephone-2500-Analog-Phone/dp/B...
- ipython 2y agoWe still have one and our younger kids use it to call their friends. We refuse to provide them “smart” phones - at least for now.
- nunez 2y agoThis is amazing. Feels similar to college radio: still more incredible than it should be for a "dying" medium.
- Vaslo 2y agoI feel like a lot of schools had this kind of number to ask questions, including my undergrad. Though I don’t think they go back 70 years. A popular question was “how many severed heads can fit into our stadium” and a couple of kids reasoned it out.
- dheera 2y agoGot accosted by a popup when I entered the site so I bounced. Tip: If you want users to read your content, don't cover it up. https://i.imgur.com/uTmqaox.png https://i.imgur.com/uTmqaox.png
- saagarjha 2y agoYour loss.
- dheera 2y agoNot really. I bounce from almost every website that gives me some GDPR, newsletter, or whatever popup. "Click to read full article?" F that, you should have pre-expanded it for me. I'm doing fine, I already have enough information overload from places that are willing to distribute it to me. Goddamn, arXiv is my favorite website now, PDFs don't pop up any of that shit.
- brudgers 2y agoJames E. Foy Information Desk Jim “Dean Foy” Foy was a wonderful human being. I got to know him a little through Rotary in the last years of his life because I had an off and on honor of chauffeuring him to and from meetings in the Grand Caravan. Even got to bring my boy along on the days he didn’t have school. He was an Auburn University legend — the Foy Information Desk was created when they remodeled Foy Hall. [1] Anyway, ironically Jim graduated from Tuscaloosa despite his Auburn being his familial allegiance. The Boll Weevil drove his parents out of Eufala and to Tuscaloosa for work and so he went to college there. During the war he flew Corsairs and told me and the boy about bailing out and hanging from a tree as we drove home from a meeting. He’d been Club president in 1953 and had 100% attendance for about 60 years. And always led the Club in a War Eagle before home football games until he couldn’t. I am truly blessed to have spent time with Jim and more blessed that my boy now man did. [1] At the time, the plan was to rename the building, but Google streetview shows that didn’t happen and now even the street is named for Jim. Yeah he was that big a deal.
- todd_moses 2y agoI went to Auburn just as the internet was beginning. When the internet was only available on Sun Workstations in the basement of the math building using the Mosaic web browser. Calling Foy was our Google.
- AbstractH24 2y agoThe NY Public Library used to have similar service. Been few years since I tried it. I’m actually curious if anyone knows how they’ve adapted it for a LLM-era
- deadbabe 2y agoThis kind of gave me the vibes of an SCP: a mysterious eternal phone number you could call and get answers to anything —anything— except perhaps about the phone line itself.
- fumeux_fume 2y agoThis reminds me of the 1957 movie Desk Set. Katherine Hepburn works at a reference desk like Foy Desk that’s under threat of automation.
- cafard 2y agoVery sweet.