7 ms·
I can't remember another time when a country used the diplomatic immunity of their embassy to harbor a fugitive from rape charges. We're in fairly uncharted ter
by philwelch 14y ago
I can't remember another time when a country used the diplomatic immunity of their embassy to harbor a fugitive from rape charges. We're in fairly uncharted territory.
- droithomme 14y ago"Rape charges" Phil, do either of the women, Anna Ardin or Sofia Wilén say the sex was rape?
- rickmb 14y agoThere are no charges yet either. We're deep into "if you repeat it often enough people will believe it's true" territory.
- philwelch 14y ago> The other alleged victim claims that she...woke up later in the night to find Assange having sex with her, without her consent and without a condom. Emphasis added. Source: http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2010/12/the_perils_of_charging_rape.html http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2010/12/the_p... Please note that "having sex with [someone] without [their] consent" is the definition of rape.
- droithomme 14y agoHere are some facts: 1. Neither woman has stated Assange raped her. 2. Assange has not been charged with rape. Here are some lies: 1. The women state that Assange raped them. 2. Assange has been charged with rape. Here is the transcript of the interview referenced in the Naomi Wolf attack article that you have cited. http://www.democracynow.org/seo/2010/12/20/naomi_wolf_vs_jaclyn_friedman_a#transcript http://www.democracynow.org/seo/2010/12/20/naomi_wolf_vs_jac...
- philwelch 14y agoFine. The truth is, it doesn't really matter. I would be ecstatic for the Swedish criminal justice system to carefully consider all the evidence and come to a fair outcome for everyone involved. My concern is that Julian Assange is obstructing this process out of either paranoid delusion or regular evasiveness, and his political supporters are all too eager to support his actions.
- mindcrime 14y agoFair point. It just struck me that this seems a bit unprecedented.
- Flow 14y agoHe isn't charged AFAIK.
- ashleyblackmore 14y agoThey "just want to have a chat."
- bluesnowmonkey 14y agoIt would be more to the point to say that they are harboring him from espionage charges. We don't have an international incident every time somebody refuses to wear a condom.
- mkramlich 14y ago> We don't have an international incident every time somebody refuses to wear a condom. bingo. that's why, in part, this is clearly about something other than the alleged sex incidents. it's pretty obviously about Wikileaks, trying to impede/stop/punish it and him.
- objclxt 14y agoThat's nonsense. You only have to look at Roman Polanski, who fled rape charges to a foreign jurisdiction and the amount of press generated over that. The women accusing Assange have a fundamental human right to due process. It is extremely unusual for someone to deny that process by fleeing into a foreign embassy. Wikileaks adds to the press, but it is noteworthy regardless of that.
- vidarh 14y agoIt is worth pointing out that the women in question did not go to the police to file a complaint. Nor have charges been taken out (there is an arrest warrant for questioning on suspicion). This case was pursued by the prosecutor at the instigation of Swedish police, after a previous prosecutor had initially closed the case stating that there was no indication anything illegal had taken place. The women in question does not under Swedish law legally have any say in whether or not the case is pursued or not - if a prosecutor believes a crime has taken place, it is their duty to pursue the case in the interest of the state, not on behalf of the women. (What does make this case stink, though, is that one of the women in question at one point prior to the case against Assange published a blog post about leveraging this exact method to "legally" take revenge against a lover who she found had was involved with someone else)
- 14y ago
- mkramlich 14y agothere are no rape charges. rape != sexual assault. and one could argue that "sex without a condom" with a naked woman already in bed with you by her own will is not rape, certainly. also there are no charges. merely an accusation. and they merely want to "question" him, which of course they could do easily without forcing him to go to Sweden. The whole thing is a pretty blatant sham, a masquerade for some other goal of theirs.
- philwelch 14y ago> and one could argue that "sex without a condom" with a naked woman already in bed with you by her own will is not rape, certainly If one was a misogynist who thought women lost their basic human rights as soon as their clothes were off, one could certainly argue that.
- mkramlich 14y agoif one were a rude asshole, one would make the comment you just made
- philwelch 14y agoThe notion that once a woman is naked and in someone's bed, they have the right to do whatever they want to her regardless of her consent is pure misogyny. It outright justifies rape. I'm not going to give you a pass on making comments like that out of politeness. Ideas like that need to be called out for what they are.
- mkramlich 14y ago> The notion that once a woman is naked and in someone's bed, they have the right to do whatever they want to her regardless of her consent I never said that. Quote me where I said that. You can't. > It outright justifies rape. I never said that. Quote me where I said that. Again, you can't. I'm very careful with my wording. You are probably falling into the trap of getting emotional about something that wasn't said, something that lives only in your own mind. Unfortunately this is one of those topics that never fails to draw people out who commit that kind of mistake. Also, I'd love to meet you sometime for a friendly coffee somewhere. Always good to meet fellow HN'ers, and as a bonus we can clear up any misunderstandings.