10 ms·
Your car, tracked: the rapid rise of license plate readers
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoIt never ceases to amaze me how much privacy people expect to have when they are out in public.
- Zikes 14y agoI don't expect privacy, just a reasonable degree of anonymity.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoFair enough. To prevent problems, only Cronin and Hutton can add plates to the hot list. Each time a plate is run for historical data by either an officer or requested by an outside agency, the requester has to inform the chief by e-mail. Requests are tallied in an annual report for the town council. The system parses license plates and matches them against a hot list. If a match is made, then a human gets notified. Some database somewhere knows the cars that have come and gone. But there is nothing to indicate that each license plate that gets captured is matched up to a person. The screen shot they have only shows the basic info captured from the camera. So unless your plate is on the hot list or someone with the authority requests to pull historical data about your plate number this does seem like a reasonable degree of anonymity. It would be nice if this was regulated a bit. Data should get purged in a reasonable time frame. Solid auditing for data retrieval requests.
- Karunamon 14y agoBut you are not anonymous in public, at least not to the authorities. You never have been.
- mc32 14y agoJapan was able to track their last two AUM fugitives via CC-TVs in Train stations and thos on public utility poles (yes, it seems Japan still has a significant amount of local transmission wires above ground). The difference being facial rather than number plate recognition. In addition to big-crime solving such as AUM, they are also able to solve weird crimes like a couple who was disposing of their trash in highway rest-stops[1]. So it's two faceted, at least. On the one hand it facilitates crime-solving with fewer resources, on the other hand one loses one's anonymity in the big city (in smaller cities where everyone knows of everyone, this may be a lesser point). Exchange/forfeit privacy for money/fees/taxes. Google, Facebook would seem to point to people preferring convenience/paying fewer (taxes) than having anonymity. On the other hand, with Google and FB, you have a choice. Here it's either everyone opts in or opts out. [1] http://www.asahi.com/national/update/1209/OSK201112090099.html http://www.asahi.com/national/update/1209/OSK201112090099.ht...
- skorgu 14y agoIn case I'm not the only baffled by what an AUM is I think it's the group that carried out the sarin gas attacks on the Tokyo subway: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aum_Shinrikyo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aum_Shinrikyo
- epoxyhockey 14y agoIt's the automation of privacy-invading technologies that gets me. I feel more and more like I'm being governed by computers and machines, not humans. I think that society is accustomed to a certain kind of slack when it comes to authority. We can get away with things sometimes. We can make mistakes and not come home with a ticket or citation every time. With all of these automated enforcement measures, we're all going to end up with rap sheets a mile long. There will be no such thing as someone having a clean record.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoAlternatively, we as a society will pay more attention to what we are doing and stop doing things that we used to get away with. Sure I speed. Nearly everyone does. But just because there was no cop to see me and ticket me doesn't automagically make it legal. It just means I got away with it. If the stretch of highway I regularly commute on had speed cameras installed... it would not take too many tickets before that stretch of highway started to flow at the posted speed. People get pissed when a law that is largely unenforced starts to get enforced more strictly. So naturally they will want to strike down any new tech that assists in that stricter enforcement. I'm not sure how cops gave out speeding tickets before radar guns but I'll bet that tech dramatically increased their ability to enforce it. Not many people are up in arms about those these days.
- lutorm 14y agoit would not take too many tickets before that stretch of highway started to flow at the posted speed Actually, it would have to flow quite a bit below the posted speed to be sure you didn't accidentally go above and get a ticket. An officer would probably decide that that was not a serious enough violation to warrant a ticket, but an automated system has no such discretion. I haven't seen any statistics on whether automated speed enforcement actually lowers the accident rate. It seems perfectly plausible to me that it would be counterproductive, because getting rid of the small number of seriously unsafe speeders would be counterbalanced by the fact that people in general will be much more paranoid about their speed and direct more attention to that to the detriment of paying attention to more important things like what's happening down the road.
- systematical 14y agoUgh... shit like this makes me want to wear a tin foil hat, but then I realize how much work that would be so I remain a lazy tracked american.
- rhizome 14y agoThat's a nonstarter. The NSA started putting back-doors into aluminum back around the time of the Roswell Incident.
- sliverstorm 14y agoProbably a remote shutdown exploit by now, too.
- NyxWulf 14y agoI knew it! Roughly a year ago I was driving home from work at night. My registration was expired by a few days, and I drove past an officer in a parking lot. As I was passing him, I knew my plate was expired, so I was looking at his plate to see if I would be able to determine from that distance if the plates were expired. So I was scrutinizing his plates to see how much detail I could see. I have better than 20/20 eyesight, and I knew there was no way I could see that level of detail at the distance he was at. So imagine my surprise when he comes after me immediately and pulls me over. More out of curiosity than anything I asked him how he knew my plate was expired, his response was "I have really good eyes". I've thought back on that experience over the last year, and I knew the technology for reading a license plate wasn't hard, but I didn't know how widespread the use was. After reading this piece and seeing the picture of those cameras, which are mounted in that area, I'd bet they are using it to give expired registration tickets too.
- mc32 14y agoNot sure how registration works where you are, in Calif (and other states) the yearly registration sticker is color coded by year. So, while they may have sought to read the "month" sticker, they might have just looked for the color of the tag as an indicator.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoI want to say that each month also has a unique color. So the two color combo can easily be translated to the month/year your tag expires. A friend of mine drove for a long time using stickers he had peeled off of other cars. As long as he kept is driving legal, he would pass the "color checks". However, once he did something that gave a LEO cause to run his plate... clearly he was busted for it. Kind of interesting when you think that these cameras would have caught him straight away. Another scenario, when people have paid for their registration but for one reason or another have forgotten to place the sticker on their plate. Those people would not get hit with these camera since their plate would not come back as expired. They would still fail the "color check" which usually can be explained to the LEO. If not, it is usually just a fix-it ticket.
- andyfleming 14y agoIt'll be interesting to see how this industry will adapt as cars become more automated.
- mc32 14y agoThat's a good point. As cars become more automated and perhaps evolve into a fleet of roving cars one "hires", or even the personal ones, I can see where a driver or passenger has to be "authenticated" as they are let in. In addition, the automobiles would be in constant communication about any state with a central office. Something to this effect would obviate the need for external cameras, as one might assume this level of automation would allow for the autonomous vehicle to know if it was able to drive/ambulate legally or not (i.e., I'm not in compliance, do you wish to override, you can override 5 times before having to take it into a shop to have it re-registered and validated and authorized to carry people, etc.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoAs a passenger, why would you have to authenticate? You don't have to do this for taxis. At the most, you'd just have to prove up-front you could pay, and/or put a deposit down against damage to the interior. If automated vehicles become common enough, the tracking issue might solve itself, as you'd be making micro-payments to a service, traveling anonymously, instead of owning your own vehicle.
- mc32 14y agoI was thinking that in the scenario where there is a roving fleet of non-chauffeured cars for hire, one would auth (or identify oneself) so that it was known who to charge back in a non-repudiable way. As a side-effect, it could be enhanced to check to see if the person did't have any outstanding warrants, leans, etc. against them. The system could, if allowed be programmed in such way, to take the person in, if it was certain/verifiable the person was "wanted" by the authorities. It sounds very dystopian, but it could happen, if the circumstances are right.
- brc 14y agoOn a stretch of highway near where I live, they have installed 'average speed' cameras. These are cameras roughly 20 miles apart, and they read your plate as you drive through, then read it again when you leave. If your time between the two cameras is too short, you get a speeding ticket in the mail. The worst part about it is that, in order to make it effective, they closed several highway exits so that people couldn't short-cut the system by taking an exit before the second camera. While I don't like excessive speeding, I think this is just revenue farming rather than a public safety initiative, and all the assurances about the data being safe just don't wash with me.
- warmwaffles 14y agoIn Texas for now, speed camera's or any automated system is against the law. This is due to the same credo that a weapon safety is a mechanical device that can and will fail.
- lutorm 14y agoHow do they identify the driver?
- Wingman4l7 14y agoThat's just it -- they can't. Better not let someone else drive your car; if it's registered under your name, you're responsible for the fine! EDIT: I stand corrected; apparently, this is not the case in AU, and may not be the case in certain states in the US. That's the last time I don't fact-check my posts... =P
- lutorm 14y agoHow does that even nearly meet the "guilty beyond reasonable doubt" criterion? I don't see how that could ever hold up in court.
- viggity 14y agoin Iowa, the tickets they issue are civil citations, not criminal citations. Therefore, you have no right to confront your accuser and there is a lower criterion for guilt. Also, if you want to contest it to an administrative judge, it'll cost you an EXTRA $80
- theDaveB 14y agoPolice in the UK have had these devices in their cars for a long time. I have spent time with the police watching how it works and it's pretty impressive. While sitting in the police car, a bus was travelling towards us and you should of seen the way the camera/software was scanning all the different numbers on the bus before it found the number plate. In the UK the police download a copy of a database before they leave the station and the software accesses that locally to determine if the vehicle should be pulled over. They check things like insurance, mot, tax and if the registered owner of the vehicle has a valid driving license. Apparently they first started using them in London in fixed points around the city watching for known terrerist vehicles entering the city. Dave
- beagle3 14y agoThink of a "crowd sourced" tracking system. Most people these days have phones that are capable of taking pictures, OCRing, GPSing and uploading this data in real time. It wouldn't be hard to build a system based on volunteers that maps most cars most of the time. And with facial recognition, mapping people as well. And it's not even illegal. Speaking of which -- anyone know a good open source ocr that can run reasonably on a mobile phone?
- Wingman4l7 14y agoHere's the surprisingly thorough Wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recognition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recognit...
- Wingman4l7 14y agoThe article mentions potentially using LPRs to catch illegal immigrants -- how? Wouldn't this fall under the umbrella of just catching unregistered vehicles? You need a driver's license to register a car, and you need a birth certificate to get a driver's license.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoPure FUD. If you click through to the CNN article, you'll see that the ICE has asked companies to help them figure out a way to do it. It is largely based on the idea that they will compile a list of license plates that can be associated with "at-large, convicted criminal aliens". I'm not sure why they need to throw the word "alien" in there when just being able to capture "at-large, convicted criminals" is reason enough. It shouldn't really matter that they were aliens. I'm guessing it is to garner some bias against such a system since specifically targeting illegal aliens seems to be a constant hot button.
- sfjailbird 14y agoI wonder how long before they just put mandatory tracking chips in cars, rather than monkey patching it with expensive OCR machines on the road and in patrols vehicles.
- otoburb 14y agoProbably not too long, especially if they offered insurance premium discounts for willing early-adopter participants.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoI'm a little surprised there aren't already insurance premium discounts for installing a "black box" to record accident data. EDIT: Apparently there already are, both in the US and elsewhere -- see below comments. Next time I'll Google this before posting, I promise! =D
- sfjailbird 14y agoInsurance companies offer this in some countries.
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoI'm in a driving study right now that installed a black box (plus a couple of cameras) in my car, to see how people drive. The study took care to make sure that the recorded footage and sensor data can't be accessed during any incident; it's encrypted, they resist requests from the police, etc. In a related note, I can't cross US borders until the driving study is over; the border police are Not Amused at being recorded, and the researchers really discourage trying to cross a US border in the car that the gear is installed in.
- maxerickson 14y agoThere are already discount programs for people willing to install monitors in their cars (Progressive Snapshop, among others).
- 14y ago
- ricardobeat 14y agoIn a few months RFID chips will start to be installed in all vehicles in Brazil, reaching 100% of the fleet in 2014. It seems like a much more reliable way to track cars and will hopefully bring enhancements in traffic control. The transit authorities also say it will "help fight vehicle theft" but I can't imagine how, since a tag on the windscreen it's pretty easy to remove... We've also had plate scanning in highway patrol checkpoints for many years, they will probably be shut down in the next year or so. Any reason this is not being considered in the US?