4 ms·
When you see headlines (or hear podcasters) talk about dopamine and other neurotransmitters, remember that neurotransmitters are merely signaling molecules. Th
by Aurornis 2y ago
When you see headlines (or hear podcasters) talk about dopamine and other neurotransmitters, remember that neurotransmitters are merely signaling molecules.
The correct way to interpret this study is that dopamine is part of the signaling chain involved in fear extinction. The specific details of where, how, and when that dopamine moves through the brain are important.
The wrong way to interpret these studies is to think of dopamine as a "level" within the brain that goes up and down. Resist the urge to assume that taking a dopamine-modulating drug will result in this specific outcome.
Dopamine response within the brain is very complicated and region dependent. When encoding aversive stimuli (things you learn to avoid) there is evidence that dopamine signaling decreases in some brain areas while it increases in others: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S235215462400127X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S235215462...
That's just the tip of the iceberg. Don't fall for the trap of thinking that dopamine does just one or two things in the brain.
- wizzwizz4 2y ago(The "brains are computers" analogy needs to die, but) it's a bit like saying "hard drive activity increases when a file is being secure-erased". Yes, but also, no.
- sieabahlpark 2y ago[dead]
- dboreham 2y agoNeurotransmitters are just "global variables" to the GPU. What the variable does or means is trained. Probably trained in the context of "I/O" signals. E.g. if the chemical also speeds up heart rate or breathing then that becomes part of the training data set. So Dopamine can potentially "do" different things in different examples of the same animal, if environmental training data is sufficiently different.
- Aurornis 2y ago> Neurotransmitters are just "global variables" to the GPU. No, neurotransmitters are very local. Dopamine exists all throughout your body, including your bloodstream. The dopamine in one location is uncoupled from the dopamine in another location. The dopamine in your bloodstream can't get into your brain. Dopamine within the brain doesn't spill over into entirely different regions of the brain.
- shemtay 2y agois it not true though that activity/threshholds of dopamine synapses can be globally or semi-globally up and down regulated?
- loa_in_ 2y agoNot true. Down/up regulation happens in areas where (sometimes called) psychoactive substances and/or regulatory nervous signals reach. Substances that cross blood brain barrier still might not reach areas due to lowered blood flow or tissue damage.
- pepa65 2y agoAnd dopamine cannot cross the blood-brain barrier.
- dayvigo 2y agoNo, activity and expression are always local. Exclusively. There are no global levers.
- immibis 2y agoI'm pretty sure there are things that affect the brain globally... nutrient availability? Oxygen availability? Sledgehammers?
- Aurornis 2y agoIt is not true. It’s unfortunate that so many podcasters have leaned into the myths about being able to manipulate dopamine as some global up/down thing you can adjust by following certain protocols. Andrew Huberman is among the worst at this because he has enough education that he should know better. I think he’s too enamored with the traffic and clicks he gets when he talks about dopamine, so he’s willing to stretch the truth or even break it completely if it will make for engaging podcast content. Some of the studies he cites over and over again about dopamine don’t even say what he claims. Huberman is a joke among people who actually know the science, but he became a hero to people who thought he was just a nice guy sharing free knowledge with them.
- keybored 2y agoTurned out that people learning about <scientific thing existing> just lead to them making a fetish out of it, like it’s discrete switch in their brain that gets bumped when they eat a donut. I wonder what even the point is.
- bravetraveler 2y agoI wonder what even the point is. To either sell junk or believe '$problems' are one purchase/dance/act away from resolution, matter of perspective. Folks want things, others want to take advantage. Not to be completely dismissive, placebo/mysticism/whatever can work
- gsf_emergency 2y agoHowever. >Not to be completely dismissive A whole series of essays based on the above, dismissing <deep learning>, <venture capital>, <LLM>, <blockchain>, <compute-based consumer platforms>, Remains to be written! dopaminergic take: who doesn't want to take on journeys of discovery fuelled by other people's (even entire GDPs-worth of?) time and money :)? just have to hope that the details turn out to be much more interesting (wit-sharpening) than the premise, heh
- procaryote 2y agoWe should figure out which chemical makes them behave like that and make pills against it!
- aaroninsf 2y agoYou're 100% right, and, I can say that my own experience is that correlating my own exposure to stimuli I have found fear-inducing, while on dopamine-modulating drugs, has proven highly efficacious in overcoming those fears. No A/B, results may vary, etc., but personally I have had life-changing results.
- aaroninsf 2y agoIf one were to assume—which I recognize we certainly can't—that there was in fact some sort of causality here, one interpretation would be that some specific drugs operate on relevant aspects of (or modulate the behavior of) the stipulated systems in a manner consistent with the desired outcome, which allows for a neat summary in casual language, regardless of the complicated specific internal mechanisms.
- wyan 2y agoWhat types of dopamine-modulating drugs are we talking about, if it's ok to ask?
- Aurornis 2y agoWithout details it’s impossible to know what you’re talking about, but it should be noted that the early phases of using stimulants or abuse-pattern usage (e.g. doubling doses before doing something, or even taking cocaine or other recreational drugs) is well-known to be associated with a heightened sense of confidence. This doesn’t work forever (tolerance) and other people will experience the opposite effect with heightened anxiety. If you want an example of why it’s not a blanket true statement or an easy solution for fear extinction, consider that stimulant use at excess dosages or abuse-pattern usage frequently ends in paranoia, where users are in such deep fear that they start sensing danger everywhere.
- agumonkey 2y agoI assume that some process also evaluate the memory patterns associated with a stimuli/concept and then adjust the signals emitted after exposure ? I'm very very interested in this topic (I have some issues on that front) so if anyone knows books about neurology regarding trauma. Feel free to suggest me books or articles. Thanks