3 ms·
> those instinctual "decide which way to swerve in a split-second" scenarios that come up maybe once every 10-20 years The correct answer is almost always to h
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> those instinctual "decide which way to swerve in a split-second" scenarios that come up maybe once every 10-20 years
The correct answer is almost always to hit the brakes. Not to swerve. And Waymo will hit the brakes earlier than you or me.
- ecshafer 2y agoI would be interested to see waymo adapt to the snow and ice, where “hit the breaks” Is the wrong answer, and the correct is to drop the car into neutral. I believe waymo will figure this out in time, nut SF and Phoenix are idealized driving conditions.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> snow and ice, where “hit the breaks” Is the wrong answer, and the correct is to drop the car into neutral This is only true with 2WD and no automatic stability control, and if you’re going down a slope. For every other case, ABs will out perform in snow and gentle braking will evenly distribute traction force with stability control doing microsecond evaluations.
- jeffbee 2y agoIt is also the case that Waymo will be dramatically better than all humans in ice because it is going to take the aviation approach and stay in the depot, rather than fooling itself into believing it is competent at driving on ice.
- bluGill 2y agoYou still need to be in neutral as the ABS/stability control doesn't control the engine. 2wd makes no real difference other than rear wheel drive tends to be the most susceptible to this issue, but any wheel can lose traction.
- jeffbee 2y ago> stability control doesn't control the engine Stability control is tied to power in all modern systems.
- 83 2y agoI spend about 5 months every year driving in snow and ice - this is the first I'm hearing about dropping it into neutral. Can you elaborate on when that would be appropriate? Obviously you shouldn't be slamming on the brakes, but they do work fine in snow and ice. I don't see how rolling into things while not in gear is an improvement?
- indigodaddy 2y agoI think it's often about when you're on rural single lane roads and perfectly bad ice/snow/slush conditions where you need to keep your speed very low, and sometimes even very moderate braking can cause your vehicle to veer off the road and into a snow bank, not necessarily the need to avoid something in front of you
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThey mean go into neutral and lightly brake. In a 2WD car, the braking force applies more strongly to the non-powered wheels. Since those were traditionally the back wheels, this meant when going down a hill the front wheels would have more traction. Those are also your steering wheels, which means them locking up is bad. Again, this is the sort of advice that is germane in highly restricted environments which become folk knowledge and later mis applied by humans in ways that reduce safety. (You also only get into this scenario when your stopping distance is shorter than your reaction time and perception length. Something automated drivers can manage better than humans.)
- creaturemachine 2y agoI remember being taught the neutral trick for emergency braking back in the 90's, and it had nothing to do with traction in poor conditions. It was simply to remove any engine power that might extend your braking distance. It's definitely bad advice in any modern car.
- bluGill 2y agoWhen you let off the throttle your wheels start driving the engine and slowing you down. In snow/ice that engine breaking alone can be more braking force than is safe and so you go into a skid. Shifting to neutral removes engine braking and allows for more controlled slowing down.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIf hit the brakes is the wrong answer, you are driving too fast.
- SchemaLoad 2y agoAlmost all of these tricky situations are avoided by slowing down and giving more space around hazards.
- Aloisius 2y agoThe correct answer is to not drive so fast (or at all) in conditions where braking might lead to a skid. I'd expect an autonomous vehicle to be rather better at this given they can hook directly into the electronic stability control system in a vehicle and constantly monitor temperature (and ideally measure upcoming road temperature). Also, shifting into neutral is really only a thing for old vehicles without ABS/ESC. In modern vehicles, you let your foot off the gas slowly.
- ecshafer 2y agoI am in upstate new york, unless the situation is extremely bad, just dont drive isnt a valid answer for 5 months a year.
- whimsicalism 2y ago? just brake and rely on the abs
- indigodaddy 2y agoI disagree. High percentage of these scenarios are at speeds and scenarios where hitting the brake would not prevent a collision and a quick swerve is the only option to not collide. Obviously your quick swerve could cause another collision so I guess it's which decision on average causes the least harm/death? I agree though that most people's extinct would be to brake. Mine never has been though.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> quick swerve could cause another collision so I guess it's which decision on average causes the least harm/death? I agree though that most people's extinct would be to brake If it’s 1989 and you don’t have ABS, yes. Otherwise, swerving is a gamble [1]. If you don’t have time to stop, you physically don’t have time to evaluate and choose a right or left swerve. You’re trading the certainty of a head-on collision with whatever is in front of you against the uncertainty of what’s to the right or left, compounded with all the fun that comes with a side/tumbling collision and increased risk of not hitting a car. [1] https://peterhancock.ucf.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/2012/03/Hancock_de_Ridder_Behavioral-response-in-accident-likely-situations_2003.pdf https://peterhancock.ucf.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/12/201...
- bluGill 2y agoIf you cannot brake you are following too close. I know everyone else does it (except 3/4ths of semis!), but you can be the one who maintains a long following distance and thus can stop in time. Every time setup the long following distance 5 cars jump into the gap - but then the gap remains as no more do.
- umbra07 2y agowhat about when there's an idiot slightly ahead and in the next lane who decides to randomly swerve into my lane? do you also maintain a long following distance when there's a car right next to you in the next lane? I try to, because I don't want to stay in someone's blind spot, but sometimes it's not really possible to fall back.
- TulliusCicero 2y agoThere was a notable case recently where the Waymo did swerve, to avoid someone who had fallen off a scooter into their lane (video here): https://www.reddit.com/r/waymo/comments/1hfvb5o/waymo_visualization_of_avoiding_a_scooter_accident/ https://www.reddit.com/r/waymo/comments/1hfvb5o/waymo_visual... Hard to say for certain, but it looks like just braking probably wouldn't have avoided the collision.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoI’d argue that’s more straightforward collision avoidance than a swerve since the rider was to the side when Waymo turned. As such, there wasn’t a choice between braking and swerving. One had to do both, and there was no real optionality as to whether to swerve right or left.