3 ms·
Sweet! Half the bandwidth, double the copyright infringement. I still remember the days when downloading movies was only practical because someone had compress
by peterwwillis 14y ago
Sweet! Half the bandwidth, double the copyright infringement.
I still remember the days when downloading movies was only practical because someone had compressed them down to two 150-megabyte videos. When I got my first 'high quality' 580-megabyte copy of The Matrix, I was thrilled.
Encoding used to be an art form. Now people just use whatever codec they want with default settings to get that 50GB Blu-ray movie down to a couple gigabytes and call it a day.
- bradwestness 14y agoYeah, I'm mostly curious how this codec stacks up against WebM/VP8 or whatever other free codecs are out there. It'd be nice to see something take off that's less encumbered by licensing issues.
- protomyth 14y agoAt this point, you are talking hardware acceleration is a must because of mobile (and it seems encoding on this one). Chip makers are fairly experienced with licensing, and a bit scarred of the unknown. MPEG-LA is a known.
- 0x09 14y agoEvery generational codec announcement from MPEG manages to attain "50% improvement", so it really remains to be seen. It certainly is a more advanced codec than H.264, which itself is already rather better than VP8 in its present form. Regarding the other thing, MPEG is running two tracks for a royalty-free spec based on existing patent-free tech and on grants from H.264 patent holders (respectively) which they say they will decide on sometime this year. An option like that from MPEG might not take off but can't hurt.
- josephlord 14y agoI think that you probably get 50% at the generation introduction and another 50% over 10 years as the encoders are improved (and more hardware is thrown at the problem). Double track on licensing makes some sense for a profile that can be served or provided free but I expect the efficiency benefits would mean that for commercial uses you would pay. That would mean that most hardware will support both so really I think most decodes will support both. Maybe people will use the non free for mobile.
- jfb 14y agoH.264 is already superior to VP8. I see no reason to suspect that this situation will change. EDIT: I mean to say, H.264 implementations (particularly x264) are way, way, way out in front of VP8, so even as the H.264 standard is better, the actual facts on the ground are even more so. The only reason to use VP8 (and let me be clear: I think this is a perfectly legitimate reason) is political.
- Splines 14y agoI'm glad it's so easy today. "Back in the day" you had to rely on all sorts of oddball codecs to get something to play. It's the reason why VLC was (and still is) so loved - it could play anything. Using a standard means that I can take a video I encoded with an off-the-shelf tool and play it on any device.
- napillo 14y agoYou obviously haven't seen the latest YIFY rips.
- aidenn0 14y agoI remember those days; vivo was state of the art, then either realplayer g2 or MS-MPEG4 .asf files. Eventually someone hacked the MS-MPEG4 codec to allow using in .avi files (it was artificially restricted to be only in .asf files). Then someone (vulture IIRC) rewrote the color conversion scheme to use MMX while increasing its accuracy at the same time; remember, this is with a binary, not source. And of course you had to get the encoding settings right before encoding the whole thing, since the moment a VCD was public there were several groups all working to get the first decent quality small video file out there.
- bcaulf 14y ago"Encoding used to be an art form." It's gone downhill but there are still people keeping a high standard. YIFY is known for releasing high quality 720p h.264 Blu Ray movie rips that fit on one CD (700MB), and 1080p rips that are 1GB. Their stuff looks good, better than cable HDTV or Netflix to my eye.