3 ms·
I'm not so sure about the cloud. That huge amount of data comes with a lot of complexity as well and much of the data is only really valuable if you can share i
by fauigerzigerk 18y ago
I'm not so sure about the cloud. That huge amount of data comes with a lot of complexity as well and much of the data is only really valuable if you can share it (video) or combine it with data from others (data mining). If data needs to be close to the CPU, it could mean that both live locally or both live in the cloud.
Local resources are idle most of the time. I wonder if that's economically sustainable in the long run. On the other hand you're always going to need idle resources to cope with peak demand. It's never going to balance out completely, even in the cloud.
I don't think data growth is going to level off. There are so many untapped sources; sensor data, 3D models, biometric data, etc. But I'm not sure people will process all that data locally. I'm not even sure where locally is. People move around, so the latency issue does not just arise when they're at home, next to their game console super computer thingy.
I worked on location based systems in the past. Latency was a big problem then (and probably still is), but having a PC at home with 16GB of RAM and a TB hard disk doesn't help.
The scarcest resource in mobile devices is not memory or bandwidth or the CPU, it's the battery. So for the time being, serious number crunching is not going to happen locally on mobile devices.
There are so many factors and I know so little of potential technological breakthroughs or even plain physics. Technology doesn't advance linearly. Batteries could suddenly sustain 24 hours of biometric number crunching. There could be Gigabit WiSuperMax in the air in 5 years time. I don't know.
But I feel people don't want super computers at home. I even block flash simply because it keeps my laptop fan busy. I tried that world community grid software a while back, but I just couldn't stand all the noise and heat.
I doubt that people will keep buying high powered general purpose computers. My guess is that we'll have our game consoles, and our mobiles and various sensors and the data is going to be streamed straight into to google's or Microsoft's data centers. It makes me feel a little uneasy though.
- anamax 18y ago> Local resources are idle most of the time. I wonder if that's economically sustainable in the long run. Economic sustainability is a function of cost and benefits, not utilization.
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoBut benefits have a lot to do with utilization
- anamax 18y agoBenefits are value received. The value that I get from a home computer do not depend on how little time it spends in its idle loop (or even turned on). The value also doesn't necessarily depend on how often I use it. (A home defibrillator is extremely valuable even if it's only used once, and fairly valuable even if it's never used.)
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoThere are opportunity costs. If I buy a hard drive that I never use I could have bought shares of amazon instead. By your definition, money could never be wasted or used inefficiently. If I waste money and my competitor does not, then it's not economically sustainable for me.
- anamax 18y agoOpportunity costs have nothing to do with utilization. Moreover, they're covered in my initial comment "Economic sustainability is a function of cost and benefits, not utilization." Low utilization may imply "waste" but cost and benefit is what matters. Benefits that I get for the costs I incur determine whether buying a new PC is a good idea, not how idle it is. In fact, trying to drive to maximum utilization frequently results in higher costs and lower benefits.
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoIf you deny any link between benefits and utilization, then I understand your argument. But I think your argument is wrong because it contradicts the very purpose of buying capital goods. You buy capital goods because utilizing them makes you a profit. Just owning them does not. But I agree that this is just a general rule which is not true in all situations, particularly not in economic downturns. If I buy 3 TB of hard disk space expecting to serve 300000 customers and then only 100 customers turn up, I have wasted much of my expenditure because it's useless. If I buy a dynamic amount of hard disk space from a cloud service on demand, then I have not wasted that money. So, clearly, opportunity cost has a lot to do with utilization if you assume a positive connection between utilization and profit, which you apparently don't. Go ask any airline about it :)