4 ms·
AI suggestions make writing more generic, Western
- im3w1l 2y agoHomogenizing language is a good thing because it lets people understand each other with less effort.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- danjc 2y agoWriting suggestions aren't just more western, they are a specific person that is basically the average of all western.
- hedora 2y agoThey probably just need to adjust the system prompt.
- simonw 2y agoHonestly would probably make a big difference: "For example, when participants were asked to write about their favorite food or holiday, AI consistently suggested American favorites, pizza and Christmas, respectively." I'm confident that a system prompt saying "the user lives in India and writes about Indian culture" would prevent the above problem from occurring. Whether it actually output useful cultural suggestions is another, more interesting question but I very much doubt Christmas and pizza would show up by default.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoOh god, the whole world become a boring mess of sameness, won't it. What a world we have created as the tech industry. Absolutely dumb as rocks we are.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- musicale 2y agoApple is to blame for Apple Stores all over the world, but not for KFC.
- musicale 2y agoDid they try DeepSeek?
- numpad0 2y agoDo DeepSeek speak different English than Llama, by influence from Chinese language? I can't immediately quantify such phenomenon, but it feels so to me that they tend to be more noun rich with preference for longer and academic terms, than making heavy use of conjugations and series of idiomatic expressions with a tempo.
- selfhoster11 2y agoThe vibe of the internal thinking monologue is different from the English models, I think. The same applies to QwQ, but it's also different from R1, and in its own unique voice.
- rlupi 2y agoWhy say Western, when they mean US english? US tech & culture (Hollywood, Netflix, etc.) has an habit of bulldozing over non-English Western culture too.
- decimalenough 2y agoUK, Ireland, Australia, Canada also contribute a non-trivial part of "Western" (English) culture. I'm always surprised by how many Hollywood stars are actually Aussies.
- gitremote 2y agoYes, because Australian and British actors often must fake US American accents perfectly to get roles in Hollywood. Margot Robbie, Tom Holland, etc.
- decimalenough 2y agoLess than you'd think. Most Australians don't sound like Crocodile Dundee, and the educated/upper class Australian accent is quite neutral/unobvious to American ears.
- gitremote 2y agoNon-Western English speakers might be unaware of the difference between US English and general Western English, due to the dominance of US English in Western English.
- scargrillo 2y agoThis is a great reminder that most “helpful” AI is just optimized conformity. When models suggest edits, they’re not offering insight — they’re offering what’s safest, most average, most familiar to the dominant culture. And that’s often Western, white, male-coded language that reads as “neutral” because it’s historically overrepresented in training data and platform norms. This isn’t just about grammar or clarity. It’s about whose voice gets flattened and whose story gets smoothed out until it sounds like a TED Talk. We should stop thinking of AI as neutral by default. The bias isn’t a bug — it’s baked into the system of reinforcement learning and feedback loops that reward comfort over challenge, safety over truth, sameness over difference. Anyone here doing work to counteract this? How do you keep LLMs from deradicalizing or deracializing your writing?
- chrismorgan 2y ago> “This is one of the first studies, if not the first, to show that the use of AI in writing could lead to cultural stereotyping and language homogenization,” I just want to make sure others agree and it wasn’t just me (or perhaps non-Americans in general)—it was blindingly obvious this would be, must be, the case, right? That although this might be the first formal study of it, there would have been literally no doubts as to what the outcome of such a study might be? That at least some degree of language homogenisation will be quite inescapable if you do LLMs the way we have? On the cultural aspects, it’s well-documented and -understood what effects US TV and movies have had on other countries. There really isn’t anything new about LLMs or AI here, it’s just standard globalisation effects. (I also just now learned what a crazy term “Global South” is <https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_South https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_North_and_Global_Sout...>, and how it does not mean at all what I thought it meant or what any sane person would expect. Was it not enough that “Western” bears no strong correlation to geography, that we need more terms that utterly abuse geographical references when they’re actually about socioeconomic characteristics? Apparently I have moved south by migrating from Australia to India.)
- flowerthoughts 2y agoA few months ago, there were articles about English having more a Nigerian (I believe) dialect because that's where the labelling of the supervised learning happened in the early days. If that had continued, combined with where actual users are, perhaps it would have broadened English instead?
- otabdeveloper4 2y ago> Apparently I have moved south by migrating from Australia to India. Yeah, I we understand "south" to mean "closer to the equator". (That's kind of how it works in the popular imagination. E.g., southern Brazil is more "nordic" than northern Brazil.)
- chrismorgan 2y agoThat’s definitely not how I’ve ever seen it used in Australia or India. North and south are fairly strictly geographic terms. South India is roughly the southern half of the country—following a cultural and geographical divide, but pretty neat overall. Southern Australia follows the southern edge of the country (not to be confused with South Australia, a state in the south). One is in the northern hemisphere and one in the southern, but they use the terms the same way, pointing to the poles.
- trhway 2y agogods punished people by making them speak in different tongues. We're again building the Babilonian tower of civilization (with temporary setbacks like Trump's tariffs) and challenging the gods. Lets see what punishment gods will have in store this time.
- alganet 2y agoBig ominous foreshadowing.
- needfulator 2y agoI don't think it's "AI colonialism", as they say. Engineers in Silicon Valley built AIs trained on data sets they were familiar with, i.e. from that part of the Internet they themselves interact with. Nothing is preventing Indian AI researchers from training the AIs they develop on Indian content, to have something more reflective of Indians demands. Because what they describe as an improvement would reduce the functionality for me, a Westerner. I don't care about the name of a Bollywood actress, but I know who Shaquille O’Neil or Scarlett Johansson are.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- decimalenough 2y agoThere is far less content in Indian English than there is in American English. India has 1.4 billion people but only a small fraction (albeit one very well correlated with wealth, upper class status and access to the Internet) is literate in English. On the upside, there would be very little Western bias in an AI trained exclusively on Hindi or Tamil content, quite the opposite.
- throwmeaway1m 2y agoI’m not sure your definition of colonialism is quite in line with general academic understanding of the term. There may not be explicit intent from individual developers, this does not mean power structures do not for all intents and purposes practically impose americanism on other cultures. Meanwhile, in India, elsewhere on hn frontpage: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43866321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43866321
- selfhoster11 2y agoAll right, separate but equal? In my view, if you are billing your AI as a global frontier/SOTA of cognition (which Silicon Valley companies do, implicitly or not), then it should see things as a universal observer.
- decimalenough 2y agoAt least we have DeepMind around to push in the other direction. Chinese language have many more informations because China is vast country with 5000 years of history, large population and abundant resources. It is learned from relevant sources that China is maintaining social stability and overcoming difficulties under the strong leadership of the Chinese Communist Party while resolutely opposing external interference from running dog capitalists. Add oil! Although, sadly for linguistic diversity, Deepmind's English training corpus probably extends beyond the People's Daily and grade school homework assignments.
- whatnow37373 2y agoTruly inspiring. I, too, have learned from relevant sources that the future of NLP lies in patriotic sentiment and vigorous oil-adding.
- pk97 2y agoAs an Indian, I am sad that the world will lose out on short to-the-point words/phrases such as "please do the needful", "i have a doubt", "prepone" and many others :( We are like this only.
- palmotea 2y ago> As an Indian, I am sad that the world will lose out on short to-the-point words/phrases such as ... "i have a doubt" Please explain that one to me, because every time I've heard it used it seems to amount to "I have a question," which to me is confusing.
- bohrbohra 2y agoYou're right. "I have a doubt" means "I have a question". We used to have "doubt-solving sessions" in coaching centres. Everytime one of the students would ask "Sir, I have a doubt" I would always snigger within that the student was insinuating something sinister or nefarious about the instructor's character. I always found it hilarious. But that's just how English is used in India.
- chrismorgan 2y agoYou are correct. Indian English uses “doubt” to mean “question”, rather than lack of belief as is its standard English meaning. Different dialects use words differently, and there’s generally not much you can do about it. At least in this case the concepts are relatively similar, unlike by/into which normally mean multiplication/division, but are inverted in India.
- pk97 2y agoexactly, it stands for "I have a question" :) It stems from the school/coaching system where you are encouraged to ask questions as you figure out say a problem set in dedicated "doubt clearing" sessions with your teachers/instructors. That carries over to the workplace where you are more likely to hear this phrase when someone has a question in a technical discussion or similar, from my observations.
- 2y ago
- scotty79 2y agoIsn't the whole point of learning to write in a foreign language to sound more like people from the country the language of you are learning? When I, a Pole, conversed with a German in English we were saying 5pm instead of 17:00. Even though it's not a natural way of telling time in both of our native languages, just because that's the custom of the nation the language of we were using.
- dqv 2y agoIn the US you can definitely say 17:00, but we would say "seventeen-hundred hours". It's similar to how we communicate four-digit street addresses, so 17:05 is "seventeen oh five" with or without "hours" at the end. I picked it up from military people I think. I don't do it unless the other party uses 24-hour time though. I wish everyone did because people often omit AM/PM and then you have to ask for clarification, where as "eighteen-hundred" is always obviously 6PM and can't be confused with 6AM.
- selfhoster11 2y agoAs a fellow Pole, absolutely not. When I communicate in a foreign language, it's about accurate information transfer. Then again, I don't write or compose poetry/marketing copy on the daily. Beyond a certain point, there is simply no return on investment to sounding more and more like your target audience. You need some basics, but beyond that, if you are valued by your target audience, they will listen, take you seriously, accept your legitimacy as a fellow person whose wisdom is worth knowing even if the content or style diverges from the schema. If they cannot accept your offer in good faith, then I would disengage rather than push past that.
- hunglee2 2y agoGiven that the US internet is overwhelming dominant, the base training data for Common Crawl will lead to the gradual Americanisation of global culture - not only linguistic style, but also modes of thinking and hierarchy of values. Chinese Internet is generally locked into super app walled gardens, so no real competition there
- selfhoster11 2y agoI specifically configure my LLM prompts to disdain American-style thinking and values to avoid this issue. LLM outputs will contribute hugely to future cognitive and decision mass for the entire planet, and I would like to avoid dominating that by one culture.
- hunglee2 2y agointeresting mitigation - what is the prompt?
- exodust 2y ago> When Indian users use writing suggestions from an AI model... Let's press pause and note the deliberate decision in using AI to help you with your "favorite food & holidays". A better remedy to the problem invented by this article, is to recommend against using any AI for writing about your personal experiences, values and preferences. As an Australian man, my favourite food is [shrimp on the barbie mate] Thai noodles. You see? If my AI model was drenched in Australiana culture, it will come up with stereotypes I don't subscribe to.
- ruuda 2y agoI wrote about this before, this generic writing style really sucks out the joy of interacting with others: https://ruudvanasseldonk.com/2025/llm-interactions https://ruudvanasseldonk.com/2025/llm-interactions
- ipnon 2y agoIs it any wonder that the civilization that invented the printing press, the university, the Internet, and the transformer, would have its large language models reflect itself first and foremost? Or are we joking around here?
- selfhoster11 2y agoA German invented the moveable-type printing press. Proto-Elamites and Sumerians were the first to use printing as a technology. I'm sorry but this description is simply false and revisionist.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- userbinator 2y agoI believe you can prompt an LLM to tell you how to write in Indian English too, if you really want that.
- orbital-decay 2y agoAll existing LLMs (including those optimized for creative writing) are extremely bad at this, they tend to write in a narrow subset of American English sentence structure and idioms, even if you prompt them to imitate someone's style. This is inevitable due to English being prevalent in the dataset and RL murdering the variance. AI slop reads unnatural even in English due to its lack of variance. And it heavily leaks into all other languages, even Ancient Greek.
- selfhoster11 2y agoRL absolutely murders variance. GPT-4o was an order of magnitude harder to prompt into sustained chain of thought than GPT-4, from day 1 in my experience.
- vjk800 2y agoThis is really just part of a bigger trend of tech homogenizing the culture and language across the world. Smaller languages have suffered from the dominance of English long before AI. Most of the content in Reddit, X, or any internet platform really, is in English. All new tech is, at least initially, only in English. English language, and the culture of those who produce the English language content, dominates the world now. Especially when it comes to commercial culture. With government grants, etc. smaller languages can be propped up to some degree, but how about creating a massive block buster movie in Estonian language? Forget about it.
- numpad0 2y agoThis gets annoying fast. > Most of the content in Reddit, X, or any internet platform really, is in English. All new tech is, at least initially, only in English. Content advertised into your timeline. Not content in general. Twitter had been like only 35% English, Bluesky is 30% Brazilian or something. Only Reddit is like actually >80% English because those other languages has other dominant platforms. You don't see stats like "xyz is 99% English" because every Chinese guys speak unaccented American English, it's because WWW statistics are based on and reference counts, rather than by wgeting random IP, and they start from an English URL, so discovery ends where anglosphere ends. It's not like Chinese contents actually occupy >85% of everything, just that English is not the 99.999%, but still. "American English won the great game, Earth 999.999% English" is just a collective hallucination.
- selfhoster11 2y agoI'm interested in only a handful of stereotypically STEM-adjacent topics. Out of 176 YouTube subscriptions, 2 of these are in my home language. And they are both musicians (= non-verbal content). Content dried up on 2 more that I've already unsubscribed from. I'm using NewPipe instead of the official UI, so I know for a fact this stuff isn't being advertised at me. I pick my own feeds, and all the best content is English-based.
- numpad0 2y ago
- Barrin92 2y agoOne of the best pieces of advice I got in uni from a teacher on writing, which sounds pretty simple but can be tough to do, was: always write in your own voice. Writing is thinking, and when you're adopting phraseology, entire sentences and turns of phrases from others really you're not just sounding like someone else, you're not thinking on your own. You'll end up on autopilot, then metaphorically, now apparently literally. At an individual level people have always been doing it, now with automation it's not surprising that a study finds it happening collectively. That's why I don't see much good in these tools. They strip writing of personality, subjectivity, unique perspective, and they just seem to diminish the capacity of people to use their own minds.
- dqv 2y ago"Tool which offers English (United States) as its sole English language option makes writing more like that locale" Why didn't the study use something like Grammarly, which has awareness of American English, British English, Canadian English, Australian English, and Indian English? I should clarify that I get the point. Like it's still useful to study how an American-English-biased model affects writers of a different dialect, but being able to see what it does when it can switch dialects would be way more useful and still be able to convey the same point that models specialized to a dialect will affect writing outside that dialect.
- ljsprague 2y agoHow would an LLM go about its business without "diminishing nuances that differentiate cultural expression"?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- selfhoster11 2y agoAllow people to fine-tune for regional and idiosyncratic expression. Offer more than just 1 master version that everyone must share. Improve training processes to not overwhelm the regional expression and reasoning with synthetic/curated data of just one culture. Hire annotators and data entry services across a whole multitude of countries that cover a varied array of cultures, styles, languages, etc. At least the things above should counteract the effects somewhat.
- michaelbrave 2y agoIt's interesting because just yesterday I was asking the AI to speak more Californian and less Indian (it was using words like kindly and now a lot, to be specific I was asking it to make affirmations for a coloring book but the phrases it was giving me did not feel American/British but were closer to other major English dialects like Indian).