7 ms·
Legendary Bose Magic Carpet Suspension Is Finally Going Global
- franktankbank 2y agoInteresting, wonder how reliable it is and what its failure modes are like.
- genter 2y agoNormally, in semi active suspension, the failure mode is an overdamped vehicle, which is safer but also harsh and uncomfortable.
- smackeyacky 2y agoReliable? What a quaint idea for a modern car. Mercedes and BMW in particular have been designing cars that fail just after the initial lease period (think plastic water pumps, timing chains at the back of the engine, wet rubber timing belts, CVT transmissions). Some crazy, unfixable magnetic suspension that lasts 3 years and requires $5000 a corner shocks is par for the course these days.
- thrill 2y agoYeah, I'm adding Audi to the list. Car just totaled for a blown engine with no determining reason a few months out of warranty. Audi won't touch it. Not worth the engine replacement cost.
- throaway920181 2y ago> CVT transmissions Well, you can take money out of an ATM machine to pay for that. Just try to remember your PIN number.
- userbinator 2y agotiming chains at the back of the engine Smallblock Chevys have a timing chain at the front but it's basically never a failure point. I agree with your other points, however; the trend is to optimise for short-term efficiency and cost, resulting in complex and relatively fragile designs.
- brookst 2y agoThe flip side: is it beneficial to anyone to have cars junked at 200k miles with water pumps that have another 500k miles on them? Overengineering has costs, in both price and weight.
- jibe 2y agoNot sure it would make sense to design cars to fail right when they get them back from the lessee?
- make3 2y agoI indeed have zero faith in a video demo of a digital system with super evenly placed bumps placed in a linear fashion. It would be so easy to just code up the perfect reaction in advance, & it not be representative at all of the conditions in the streets where the machine actually has to detect and respond dynamically to the conditions of the road
- genter 2y ago> The original version replaced traditional dampers with linear electric motors that used sensor data to literally move the wheels up and down and cancel out bumps. ClearMotion adapted the control software and applied to active valve dampers with a magnetic fluid. So, in other words, ClearMotion is producing a technology that other OEM's have been doing for years. Just off the top of my head, Cadillac has their magnetic suspension (which uses a fluid that changes viscosity in the presence of a magnetic field. I guess this is the same as what TFA claims is brand new.) The Ford Raptor with their live valve by Fox has a solenoid valve that regulates the shim pack. (Funny enough, I've spent all morning doing a FEA analysis of their valve.) The latest Mercedes Gelandewagen also has solenoid valves in their dampers to switch between soft and hard damping. Citroen has been doing it since the 50's with a purely mechanical system. The basic idea is very simple: you want a computer to regulate the damper between soft and firm, as the road dictates. The implementation of this can become very complicated and there's a number of very different implementations. If I remember right, the Bose implementation required too much electricity to be practical. Most other implementations have some type of solenoid valve to control the pressure drop of the hydraulic fluid across an orifice. Again, the theory is simple, but mass producing a system that is cheap, reliable, yet can respond in milliseconds is difficult.
- Fade_Dance 2y agoExactly what I came here to post. Mag fluid suspension has been mainstream for a while. Cadillacs aren't exotic.
- neom 2y agoI would guess this feels quite a bit different, the clearmotion tech puts electrohydraulic actuators in every corner of the vehicle and is proactively pushing and pulling wheels. MagneRide isn't even active (maybe semi-active, not sure) - never mind predictive and proactive.
- serf 2y agoexcept that this demo isn't ClearMotion, and instead of actuators they are using magnetic fluid and valvework... much like every luxury brand has tried at least once or twice in the past 30 years.
- thih9 2y ago> Over 20 years ago, Why would we be interested in the technology from 1980s… oh. Also, this is Bose of active noise cancellation - very fitting, since this looks like anc for wheels. They did anc for car seats too and sold it to the same buyer: > As part of the deal, ClearMotion also acquired the technology for Bose Ride, a special "active" car seat for truckers that improves ride quality and reduces occupant fatigue. Bose used what it had learned from developing the active car suspension system to create Bose Ride, but it remains a niche product. https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/bose-sells-its-futuristic-car-suspension-system-to-clearmotion/ https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/bose-sells-its-futuristic...
- 8note 2y agonit: 20 years ago is ~2000s now, not 80s
- skrebbel 2y agothat was the joke
- crazygringo 2y ago> since this looks like anc for wheels I was wondering why the heck Bose got into this. Thanks, that was the missing link -- I never thought of suspensions as noise cancellation but of course they are!
- sfifs 2y agoAt one point, Bose was a few scientists who happened to have a consumer tech company.
- bunnie 2y agoI got a tour of Prof. Bose's factory as a student while taking his course on acoustics. Active suspension is basically a speaker voice coil but scaled up and pushing a car wheel instead of a cone. A lot of the physics and perhaps more critically, the manufacturing processes, were shared between speakers and suspension as they implemented it. I actually got to sit in the car as it drove over bumps, it was pretty magical. iirc you could flip a switch and set a suspension profile that made it emulate other cars road feel as well. Years later I built a toy model of it using an actual speaker to make a pushbutton switch that could emulate the feel of a broad range of other switches.
- mike-the-mikado 2y agoIf this technology becomes common place, what is the future of speed bumps? It seems as if speed bumps are a rather questionable approach to traffic calming, as larger vehicles (which should be a priority for calming) are less affected.
- selectodude 2y agoThey’re already too small for the idiot monster trucks everybody drives nowadays. Not sure this will change that.
- beau_g 2y agoSpeed bumps are much rougher in my idiot monster truck than they are on my Mercedes station wagon, idiot monster truck spring rates and damping are engineered to tow heavy loads/carry heavy payloads so especially when unloaded speed bumps are quite jarring compared to a passenger car.
- nikisweeting 2y agoJust hit them significantly faster, it'll do the same thing as going slow with a heavy load. There's a reason the faster you ride motocross the harsher you tune your spring and damping rates.
- serf 2y agowhat's the reason? it surely isn't ride smoothness, it's control. similar to a race car -- you don't compensate the speed with damping and spring rates in order to maximize a smooth ride , you do it to more quickly transfer the movement energy OUT of your car, into the ground and traction patch so that the car can remain dynamic for the next force. this does not equate to ride quality, most race cars (and bikes) are bone-shakers.
- nikisweeting 2y agoride smoothness in the medium frequency range = control. if you're bouncing all over then you're weighting and de-weighting constantly, which is terrible for control. high performance cars are mostly bone shakers at slow speeds when not in their ideal operating range. at high speeds they should level on top of it all, just watch a rally truck go over dunes or the video of an F1 wheel well stabilized to the frame of the car. sure you have low-frequency high-g-force weight transfer during acceleration/deceleration, and you have high frequency signal from the road texture, but medium frequency parking-lot-speedbump-style bouncing should not be happening at all or you're going to lose the race.
- Animats 2y agoBYD has had active suspension in their Yangwang U9 supercar for two years now. It's over the top.[1] It can sense and jump potholes. Drive with one wheel missing. Dance to music. Do tank turns. There's even a LIDAR watching the road surface for bumps. That's not just adjustable damping; that's a fully powered suspension. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIKAn8yDkpA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIKAn8yDkpA
- neom 2y agoObligatory wheelsboy review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASIUyfK6K4U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASIUyfK6K4U
- Etheryte 2y agoWhile cool as a shower thought, in reality, having a 1200HP car jump and go airborne while you're swerving to avoid a pothole is just about the last thing you want it to be doing. Traction control is pretty good these days, but not that good that you want to lose all traction at 120km/h (75mph, the speed shown in the video).
- literalAardvark 2y agoWhich is exactly why you want that suspension. Both this and the Bose linear actuator one lift just the wheel that needs lifting, just enough to clear the obstacle, keeping everything perfectly steady, it's incredible. The fact that it can also do silly jumps for marketing reasons is a different topic.
- Animats 2y agoRight. This is a demo. A more impressive demo is that it can do precise turns in place without skidding.[1] That's the U8, BYD's answer to Rivian. The U9 can do that too. Rivian did demo a turn in place, but they were spewing dirt all over.[2] Rivian took the feature out. Now, those are BYD's high end supercars, to show off the technology. The high-end volume vehicle, the U7, just came out.[3] That is under US$90K (depending on what tariffs are on this week) and competes with Tesla's higher end products. All the fancy torque and suspension control of the supercar, but at a lower price point. BYD isn't offering it in the US. Just the rest of the world. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhvjPwshME0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhvjPwshME0 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BkxjHkOvYY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7BkxjHkOvYY [3] https://electrek.co/2025/03/27/byd-launched-first-ultra-luxury-ev-sedan-at-under-90000/ https://electrek.co/2025/03/27/byd-launched-first-ultra-luxu...
- neom 2y agoVery cool that these folks appear to be betting that L4 is going to be things we sleep in or something, at least that's the vision I'm getting from their prod page on this tech, also neat they seem to have reduced stopping distance by a considerable amount (although no speed listed). https://clearmotion.com/cm1 https://clearmotion.com/cm1
- Zanni 2y agoMakes sense. I like to feel the road when I'm driving, but if the car is driving, I'd prefer the ride to be as smooth as possible.
- germinalphrase 2y agoPerfect for the daily 7 hour commute once we’re reduced to a handful of global megacities with vehemently enforced RTO.
- HPsquared 2y agoMercedes does this with hydraulic rams, it's called Active Body Control (or Magic Body Control for the version that scans the road in front too). That system uses hydraulic rams in series with the usual suspension springs and dampers, and can handle up to 5 Hz (i.e. it controls the lower frequency part of the spectrum so softer springs etc can be used, improving both ride and handling)
- dmix 2y agoWatching the video I wonder how much of it is combining that plus a car that’s higher off the ground. Mercedes cars will be more performance minded so it’s lower to the ground. Maybe SUVs could have the greater suspension range so it can handle larger bumps but I wonder how much any Sedan could. The most comfortable car I’ve ridden in suspension wise was a Mercedes SUV. So maybe they figured that out already.
- gehwartzen 2y agoAs I’ve grown older I’ve come to realize that what truly makes high end luxury cars is the suspension and the sound deadening. The other stuff is important but doesn’t really set the cars apart. Sitting in a little mobile room completely divorced from the sensory input of the outside world truly feels luxurious
- potamic 2y agoI'm in the same boat regarding sound deadening, so when I was in the market for a car this was my #1 priority. But outside of the luxury segment, they do not even talk about sound deadening or noise isolation. This idea simply does not exist. It was very disappointing because this is a fairly low tech, inexpensive feature that could easily find its way to mainstream cars. Sure it adds some extra weight, but the improvement in riding comfort easily outweighs the fuel consumption. It's like flying with noise cancellation headphones. You don't know what you're missing unless you try it once, and then you can never go back.
- bob1029 2y ago
- hinkley 2y agoDo you want traffic circles? Because this is how you get traffic circles. (I used to live in a neighborhood full of them and I liked them but very many people disagreed with me. If you make speed bumps not work then they will all be replaced with slaloms or circles.
- DecentShoes 2y agoI had to look up what a traffic circle is, but apparently it just means roundabout. And yes, I do want roundabouts, who wouldn't? Is there any serious argument against them? I've heard they aren't common in America.
- Clamchop 2y agoThey take up a lot of space and they can be inconvenient and potentially unsafe to pedestrians. Unsafe for the same reason that right turns on red are unsafe: drivers are looking to their left for traffic and not to their right. They were rare in the US before, I want to say, 15 or 20 years ago but I see them all the time now and new ones are always being installed. Good traffic devices, with the above tradeoffs in mind.
- ghaff 2y agoI think right turn on red is usually a reasonable trade off and designers can always put no right on red signs if they think warranted. Where roundabouts get bad is when they’re multi-lane and can get a lot of traffic. There’s one I se fairly regularly and I’m surprised there aren’t more accidents.
- fc417fc802 2y agoAs a counterpoint, they're only slightly larger than a typical intersection and can have nice landscaping in the center. It makes for a much nicer urban environment. Regarding pedestrian safety that seems like it should be easily solved by those flashing lights that they can trigger with a button. Or some other signal based solution.
- 2y ago
- fallinditch 2y agoThe Lexus LS400 was a great quality car. What's the closest equivalent these days? (A 10 year old Lexus?)
- serf 2y agoit was a great car. the 1UZ-FE was one of the few motors in a consumer-available car that had a flight-rated version AND a marine-rated version . It was one of the first 300+ WHP sedans. Bullet-proof. Great. If you don't mind old cars you could explore the rest of the lineup that touched the 1UZ/2UZ motor/3UZ; they're all pretty good. SC430,GS430,GS400,LS430,LS400. [0] As far as modern Toyota goes.. I couldn't make a recommendation. I like the newer Prius, but it's a different market and I wouldnt vouch for the reliability, although i've had good luck. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_UZ_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_UZ_engine
- SoftTalker 2y agoMore stuff to go wrong. Can someone please make an affordable simple car?
- wbl 2y agoLike the Honda Civic?
- SoftTalker 2y agoI'm thinking more like a 1980s Toyota Corolla. Or an original VW Beetle.
- criddell 2y agoSlate’s plan looks promising: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43792849 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43792849
- kfarr 2y agoI’ve always dreamed of this technology applied to buses, especially trolley buses which have plenty of capacity to supply a power-hungry electromagnetic suspension. If this could convert a bouncy and squeaky bus into a smooth light rail equivalent, wowsers
- dataviz1000 2y agoDan Ackroyd is the spokesperson for the project too -- circa 1979. https://vimeo.com/312218800 https://vimeo.com/312218800
- svilen_dobrev 2y agosigh. Somewhat like the flying car, and the fusion.. Similar title, 7 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17108828 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17108828 Still keep fingers crossed it would make it. btw, one possible side effect of mass-adoption of this will be that roads will be left to deteriorate and become worse - with much more potholes and what-not - as cars will not need it. Or such will be the excuse..
- zacka 2y agoClearMotion founder here! Wanted to share some insights that might answer questions from other commenters and clarify what we've developed. The ClearMotion1 system is a major leap above all tech currently on the market, with transmitted vibration reduced about 80% versus top market technologies. Here's a video comparing it on production NIO cars against luxury vehicles using semi-active (or slow active) systems others mentioned - sort of like comparing a microcontroller to a NVIDIA H100. http://bit.ly/44TDtgl http://bit.ly/44TDtgl This matters especially for autonomous vehicles, where the whole point is to give people back time, and preventing motion sickness while working/reading is essential. Our tech stack: - Electro-hydraulic actuators that both push/pull actuate and dampen within a few milliseconds, using electric motors (not solenoid valves or special fluids). We use integrated hydraulics as a mechanical gain lever - Predictive control software that anticipates vehicle, driver, and road dynamics - "Infinite preview" control using crowdsourced road data with <3cm localization precision - Software-enabled features including pre-crash posture mitigation and tire grip technology The combination creates a "software-defined" chassis, similar to how electric power steering enabled today's driver assist features. Our Bose acquisition was to acquire specific control software and engineering talent, but most of our IP and our production hardware/software was developed in house. There were a few questions about durability— our system has passed 5 years of testing across millions of miles - a requirement from all of our customers like NIO and Porsche. It’s also a reason why it’s so difficult to succeed as a startup in automotive, but once you’re in, you’re locked in long-term.
- DonHopkins 2y agoImpressive, but is it as stylish and smooth as the 1978 Royal Deluxe II? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnOwHu_wchg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnOwHu_wchg
- bombela 2y ago> This video contains content from NBC Universal, who has blocked it in your country on copyright grounds
- chiph 2y agoDidn't GM have a camera/software combo that would relax the MR dampener before bumps at one time? It didn't have active movement - just a regular shock but with fine control over fluid movement. I think you're saying you have a pump that moves hydraulic fluid in anticipation of a road defect/speedbump, and does it per-wheel and proportional to the correction needed. Which is fascinating. With regards to pre-crash posture, I'm not sure if this is to move the occupants into a more advantageous position for airbag deployment or to get more crash structure involved for a dissimilar vehicle crash (sedan vs. truck). Can you talk more about it? Is there going to be IIHS/Euro NCAP/C-NCAP testing?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sfjailbird 2y agoSo these systems depend, in part, on memorizing road data. I.e. another privacy issue in the making.
- nabla9 2y agoHydractive 3+ is now 20 years old. Bose is late in the game and reinventing the wheel. Citroen has been leading active suspension tech since 1954. Mercedes, BMW, others have adopted it later.