3 ms·
> the increase in autism Is largely illusory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bentinck,_5th_Duke_of_Portland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bentinck,_5
by ceejayoz 2y ago
> the increase in autism
Is largely illusory.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bentinck,_5th_Duke_of_Portland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Bentinck,_5th_Duke_of_Por...
"The duke was highly introverted and well known for his eccentricity; he did not want to meet people and never invited anyone to his home. He employed hundreds through his various construction projects, and though well paid, the employees were not allowed to speak to him or acknowledge him. The one worker who raised his hat to the duke was promptly dismissed. The tenants on his estates were aware of his wishes and knew they were required to ignore him if they passed by. His rooms had double letterboxes, one for in-coming and another for out-going mail. Only his valet was permitted to see him in person in his quarters—he would not even let the doctor in, while his tenants and workmen received all their instructions in writing."
"The underground chambers—all of which were painted pink—included a great hall 160 ft (49 m) long and 63 ft (19 m) wide, which was originally intended as a chapel, but which was instead used as a picture gallery and occasionally as a ballroom. The ballroom reportedly had a hydraulic lift that could carry 20 guests from the surface and a ceiling that was painted as a giant sunset. The duke never organised any dances in the ballroom."
We'd diagnose this guy in a heartbeat now, but then, he was "eccentric". If he'd been poor and not an aristocrat, he'd have been a "moron" or "retarded" or something along those lines.
It's deeply odd to see Kennedy saying it's a new phenomenon. His own aunt was lobotomized for "becoming increasingly irritable and difficult".
- bhouston 2y ago>> the increase in autism > Is largely illusory. Huh? First off autism rates are provable increasing in the US. It is multi-factor for sure that includes increased awareness and more access to autism tests, but... It is a proven fact that older fathers have a higher change of having offspring with autism [1] and it is also a fact that in the US (as like many places in the world) men are having their children later [2]. Together these two accepted scientific facts lead directly to increasing autism rates, no? Or do you disagree with this reasoning? The link I am positing but there isn't quite as much acceptance is that sperm degradation that leads to autism, isn't only caused by age but also influenced by plastics. [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/autism-rates-rising-more-prevalent-versus-more-screening-rcna67408 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/autism-rates-risi... [2] https://biox.stanford.edu/highlight/fathers-american-newborns-keep-getting-older https://biox.stanford.edu/highlight/fathers-american-newborn...
- ceejayoz 2y ago> First off autism rates are provable increasing in the US. Yes. That's what happens when you make a brand new label. (And then redefine it a few times; Asperger's used to be separate, now it's part of the spectrum. Or when we started realizing that, say, women are underdiagnosed with it and started working to address that.) Rates of female "hysteria" are at an all-time low, for similar reasons. > It is a proven fact that older fathers have a higher change of having offspring with autism… Which could be just because of biological changes from their age, or environmental exposures during that time, but also could have other explanations, like autistic people having a harder time on average finding long-term partners.
- d1sxeyes 2y agoAll solid points, but not well-aligned with your original argument that the increase in autism is largely illusory.
- ceejayoz 2y agoWhy? The rise in autism diagnoses is not the same thing as a rise in autism. We've had plenty of autistic people all along. We just called it different things. They're the "weird uncle" or "idiot savant" or the guy who went off to live in a silent monastery of eras past. Insane asylums. Or they wandered off at age three into a snowstorm in an era where baby gates weren't a thing.
- d1sxeyes 2y agoWell it sort of is, actually. Autism is quite literally what we define it to be: there’s no physiological or neurological test we can use to diagnose it, there’s no biomarker that defines autism. If we change how we diagnose autism, we change how we define it. The evidence by the way seems to indicate that there is a significant increase in diagnoses, and not all of that can be attributed to changing definitions.
- 2y ago