3 ms·
> Sales tax cannot be per-calculated, since it is charged on the total sale. Most of the developed world pre-calculates sales tax. If McDonalds charges you $1
by ceejayoz 2y ago
> Sales tax cannot be per-calculated, since it is charged on the total sale.
Most of the developed world pre-calculates sales tax.
If McDonalds charges you $10.32 in Australia, the government gets $0.84(8181812...) of it. Rounding isn't an issue because you don't write a check for each individual $0.84(8181812...), you pay them the aggregate amount on a regular basis.
- Eisenstein 2y agoHere is a list of 20 district sales taxes in California alone (out of ~150). Los Angeles County Measure H: 0.25%, 10-01-2017 to 03-31-2025 City of Orland Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2017 to 03-31-2025 Rio Dell City Transactions and Use Tax: 1.00%, 04-01-2015 to 12-31-2024 City of El Monte Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2009 to 03-31-2025 City of San Pablo Reduction Transactions and Use Tax: 0.25%, 10-01-2017 to 09-30-2022 Town of Truckee Trails Transactions and Use Tax: 0.25%, 10-01-2014 to 09-30-2024 City of La Habra Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2009 to 03-31-2025 City of Seal Beach Transactions and Use Tax: 1.00%, 04-01-2019 to 03-31-2025 City of Westminster Transactions and Use Tax: 1.00%, 04-01-2017 to 12-31-2022 City of Pismo Beach Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 10-01-2008 to 03-31-2025 Pacific Grove City Transactions and Use Tax: 1.00%, 10-01-2008 to 09-30-2022 Town of San Anselmo Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2014 to 03-31-2023 City of Sausalito 2014 Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2015 to 03-31-2023 Mariposa County Healthcare Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2005 to 03-31-2025 Mendocino County Mental Health Treatment Act Tax: 0.50%, 04-01-2018 to 03-31-2023 Mendocino Library Special Transactions and Use Tax: 0.125%, 04-01-2012 to 03-31-2023 City of Atwater Public Safety Transactions and Use Tax: 0.50%, 07-01-2013 to 03-31-2023 City of Capitola Transactions and Use Tax: 0.25%, 04-01-2005 to 03-31-2025 City of Campbell Vital City Services Transactions and Use Tax: 0.25%, 04-01-2009 to 03-31-2025 City of Davis Transactions and Use Tax: 1.00%, 10-01-2014 to 03-31-2025 * https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/cdtfa105.pdf https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/formspubs/cdtfa105.pdf
- ceejayoz 2y agoYes. This is silly. We should change it. (But it's largely an issue for online sales, not physical locations. The McDonalds in San Anselmo, barring The Big One, stays in San Anselmo.) See also: American healthcare, college, etc. "Our setup is absurdly complex in bad ways" is not an argument for keeping that setup, it's an argument for making fixes.
- bluGill 2y agoThere are pros and cons. this system means a town isn't limited as to income because someone else won't allow the tax they want to pay
- Eisenstein 2y agoI agree and never made the argument it should not be fixed. It is cause and effect, however.
- gamblor956 2y agoWhy is this silly? If you're selling something, sales tax (or in other parts of the world, VAT or GST) will be owed[1]. Different places will have different levels of commerce and budgetary requirements, and sales taxes are one of the ways they can fill their coffers. Allowing for local jurisdictions to set their own tax rates is part of the federal system of government; indeed in the U.S. it is arguable that a national sales tax rate a la Europe would be unconstitutional. And why should we eliminate sales taxes, etc. for online sales? Isn't the whole point of software that it makes it trivial to handle multiple sales taxes? [1] Sales tax, VAT, etc. are taxes on the buyer but are collected by the seller as a matter of administrative convenience. Use tax / reverse charge covers the situations where a non-local seller doesn't collect the tax, but compliance was so low in the first several decades of e-commerce that every government around the world decided to expand sales tax compliance for online sales to non-local sellers.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Why is this silly? Because it's an immense amount of paperwork, compliance, legal risk, etc. all to avoid just setting a more reasonable state/federal level of taxation. The US has a deeply weird attitude towards any changes to taxation. > And why should we eliminate sales taxes, etc. for online sales? No one's proposing that. Online sales just introduce the issue of not knowing the tax jurisdiction that's applicable for a brand-new shopper.
- gamblor956 2y ago
- Maken 2y agoAre those based on the location of the seller or the location of the buyer?
- Eisenstein 2y agoBuyer.