4 ms·
I have too seemingly opposing thoughts on this. One part of me says "Don't reinvent the wheel", but the other part of me suspects that forcing a new language t
by jlgreco 14y ago
I have too seemingly opposing thoughts on this.
One part of me says "Don't reinvent the wheel", but the other part of me suspects that forcing a new language to follow the syntactical conventions of another language that was designed with different considerations in mind is a bad idea.
The best example of a language that I think suffers from it's association with the syntax of another is C++. The features that it provides are all more or less fine, but cramming it into a syntax that was made for a much simpler language really wasn't a good idea.
(I understand why it was done from a historical perspective, and understand the few benefits it affords, but I think those are particular to that example)
On the other hand again, there really isn't a lack of syntaxes these days that a new language developer can look to for inspiration. Surely one of them should work fine most of the time.
- terhechte 14y agoThis specific one is just bad though. I mean "\" is really difficult to type on almost all non-us keyboards. It's not even really easy on US keyboards (the pinky has to go a long way). See how often it's in there. Even standard C syntax is a pain on some non-us keyboards. I.e. on a German keyboard, the [, [, {, }, are rather difficult to type. That's why I (being German) switched to an English layout around two years ago. Now I have trouble typing umlaut and thus writing good German, but at least my coding speed improved by probably 50% and my Hand hurts far less.
- jlgreco 14y agoYes, without doubt this specific one is bad.
- eru 14y agoYou might want to try the Neo layout. It's a modern layout that includes international characters, like German Umlauts. (I'm also German and switched to American Dvorak earlier. I only heard about Neo later, and am too lazy to switch now.)
- dkersten 14y agoI guess if LCtrl and their LMod3 were swapped (ie so that capslock is used as Ctrl for shortcut keys), I could see this being an interesting layout. It has all the common keys either on the home row or easily reached from the home row. I can't ever see myself switching from Colemak though, I like how the fingers roll across adjacent keys too much. (Plus since I don't type much German, I don't need quick access to üöäß, though an English-centric variant of Neo would be.. interesting, maybe using those keys for the most common programming symbols?)
- threedaymonk 14y agoThere are various keyboard layouts that are superficially English but which allow various diacritics via dead keys, such that, for example, you can type AltGr+" followed by u to get ü. (I just did exactly that.) I know of us altgr-intl on Linux (that is, xkb), but there are similar layouts on OS X and Windows.
- GregBuchholz 14y agoNow I'm interested to know which languages exist that don't rely heavily on backslashes. I guess I can't think of a language that doesn't use blackslashes for string escapes. Some other uses off the top of my head: * C -- line-continuations (important for macros). * Perl -- regex back-references. * Haskell -- anonymous functions. * Python -- line continuation. * Tcl -- line continuation. * Icon -- non-null test (unary), generator limitation (binary). * Prolog -- \+ for not provable. * J -- the prefix adverb and the grade-down verb (\:). * TeX -- Yes.
- rfurmani 14y agoTechnically, for Perl you can use $ for regex backreferences. I don't remember which one is preferred, but I remember it frowning upon one of them.
- btilly 14y agoWhat you use depends on where you use it. Inside of a match, \1 refers to what was matched by the first parens. After the match $1 refers to what was matched. In a substitution, \1 is special cased to mean $1, but that is frowned on. Thus: /\b(\w+)\W+\1\b/ means "match repeated word". And: /\b(\w+)\W+$1\b/ means "match word preceeded by the word matched on your last match. Moving on: s/Hello (\w+)/Goodbye $!/ means "Replace Hello followed by a word with Goodbye followed by the same word." And finally: s/Hello (\w+)/Goodbye \1/ is special cased to mean the same thing, but is frowned upon.
- rdtsc 14y ago> Now I'm interested to know which languages exist that don't rely heavily on backslashes. I posit that line continuations don't count, at least not in the "rely heavily" category. Then I am not sure how popular J and Icon are. So let' keep those away. Is the backlash really used that often in Prolog? I wouldn't say "heavily". So that leaves us with: * Perl * Haskell * Tex I think that's a more realistic "rely heavily" category.
- GregBuchholz 14y ago
- luchs 14y agoI solved that problem by binding capslock to Alt Gr and using a custom US layout with Alt Gr plus e-[;' bound to €ßüöä. This basically allows me to quickly switch to the German layout when necessary without losing much speed.
- arethuza 14y ago"Surely one of them should work fine most of the time." S-expressions? NB I once got paid to write Lisp, C and PostScript on the same project, if nothing else it taught me to be somewhat flexible about language syntax.