6 ms·
Authors destroy legal e-book lending site thanks to Authors Guild, publisher FUD
- ColinWright 14y agoFor those who are interested, there are other substantial discussions of this here on HN: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4360626 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4360626 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4361889 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4361889
- bennesvig 14y agoFear obscurity, not lending. I'm happy to see my book on BookLending or other lending sites. Paulo Coelho has interesting thoughts on piracy helping book sales. http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2012/feb/01/paulo-coelho-readers-pirate-books http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2012/feb/01/paulo-coelho-rea...
- graeme 14y agoI'm releasing a book, and considering pirating a similar work to help gain awareness.
- px1999 14y agoI've spoken to software devs who (kind of) liked their software appearing on filesharing sites - it was validation that they'd made something worth being cracked and pirated. Coelho's points are definitely interesting but it seems to hinge on the digital/physical separation of products and how we currently value physical stuff ("to download my books [then] buy a hard copy", songs on the radio / buying CDs)... I guess that the real test comes when you're saying "download my book for free, then if you like it, download my book for money".
- yock 14y agoThis type of reaction isn't uncommon these days. No matter what the outlet, be it a lobbying organization like the Authors Guild or a tech news site like TechCrunch, people read looking to have an emotional response. This was demonstrated, and measured, recently in a carefully designed hoax about fictitious screws from an iDevice[0]. People are more likely to believe what is told to them by family and friends than most any other source, and the power of the social network is that the bar for who counts as a friend has never been lower. This is the beginning, a shadow of what it will look like when the worst actors among us in society really learn how to yoke the social network herd. [0] http://day4.se/how-we-screwed-almost-the-whole-apple-community/ http://day4.se/how-we-screwed-almost-the-whole-apple-communi...
- majormajor 14y agoAnd that's the type of reaction extremetech is going for as well with their headline, photo, and all. I wonder if the author was actually as angry as he wants his readers to be.
- yock 14y agoI considered that, and I normally ignore ExtremeTech articles because I think they're usually blogspam. This article actualy seemed to backup its own point. Sure, sensation makes for a good read and no one (most especially myself) is immune to it, but it's hard to ignore the quotations and Twitter screenshots that backup the author's point.
- majormajor 14y agoI don't think the article's wrong, exactly (though I'm more sympathetic to the authors than the, er, author is), but it's definitely written in a decidedly editorialized way. I guess another way to say what I'm trying to say is: he didn't need to add any spin of his own (like the RIAA line) considering the quotes and screenshots.
- shardling 14y agoThe Authors Guild is not a 'lobbying organization.' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Authors_Guild
- res0nat0r 14y agoThe authors who were clued in to what this site was actually about were upset that it allowed their works to be lent to anyone in the world and not just "friends and family" which is what they believe the spirit of the Kindle Lending program via Amazon is about. If their works were able to be lent to anyone and everyone in the world they wanted higher prices for their books to be charged, just like what libraries have to pay since they can also lend to anyone off of the street.
- ender7 14y agoSure, but they signed the contract to specifically allow this behavior. If they don't like it, then they should complain to Amazon, or perhaps should read the terms a little more carefully. Either way, it's hard to see how any of this was LendInk's fault.
- forensic 14y agoThere's that word again.. "fault" The only truth is power. Legally the site was in the clear, and yet the authors had enough power to shut it down. Many of the authors understood that it was legal but still did not like it because it skirted the spirit of the contract which that lending is for family and friends. The strangest part of this story is that some outraged people were able to close a website they didn't have any claim to.
- tedunangst 14y agoDid they shut it down? I have yet to find a source that explains the mechanism of the shutdown. Everybody keeps repeating the fact that it's been killed, but how?
- sp332 14y agoThe ISP got cease and desist orders, plus some hatemail including threats of violence. So they took the site offline. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4360626 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4360626
- adrr 14y agoThe authors really need to go after libraries, these hubs of piracy really need to be shutdown. Libraries distribute books to complete strangers with no compensation to the authors.
- dorward 14y agoAuthors get compensated when I borrow books from my local library. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Lending_Right http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Lending_Right
- Avenger42 14y agoAuthors get compensated when their books are lent out through the Kindle Direct Publishing system too: 2.3 KDP Select Fund. We will establish a fund on a monthly basis and you will earn a share of that fund for each of your Digital Books included in the Kindle Owners’ Lending Library Program. https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?ie=UTF8&topicId=APILE934L348N#Select https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?ie=UTF8&topi...
- alanfalcon 14y agoLendInk wasn't about the Kindle Lending Library though: those are books that can be borrowed without ever being purchased first. These LendInk borrows were between a book buyer and a third party, fascilitated by, say, Amazon, but without additional financial compensation for authors. As an author I still think they're a good idea to allow, but then I understand technology unlike too many other authors.
- j_s 14y agoIf my understanding is correct, the KDP Select Fund is for the 'Kindle Owners’ Lending Library' program, where Amazon will loan one book per month to Amazon Prime members. LendInk facilitated lends under the 'Lending for Kindle' program, allowing a one-time lend between Kindle owners. https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A2JGI9S4FDM39Q https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A2JGI9S4...
- 14y ago
- mherdeg 14y agoThere were some great insights in the prior discussion at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4360626 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4360626. Something I was hoping to hear more discussion about: is there any evidence that anyone in the e-book community knowingly filed an incorrect DMCA takedown notice?
- nicholassmith 14y agoYou'd probably need to wade through the takedown notices, but given they were claiming it was acting in a manner to enable piracy rather than lending the assumption is the majority will have been filed incorrectly.
- rmc 14y agoSo the question is then, are any of them going to be prosecuted for perjury and lying under oath? I believe you must swear under penalty of perjury to send a DMCA notice.
- drivingmenuts 14y agoProbably not, thought they certainly deserve it. My guess is that the owner of LendInk has neither the time, nor the resources, to pursue all of the authors that filed false/ignorant DMCA notices, and more likely wants to wash his/her hands of the whole thing. It's just one of those tragedies that will never see any kind of justice. Welcome to the world. It's another day.
- rprasad 14y agoThey're not committing perjury. Perjury requires that someone know that what they are saying is factually incorrect at the time they are saying it. The authors in this matter are not technologically sophisticated enough to understand how either the Kindle Lending or LendInk work(ed). They actually believe that it is promoting piracy. Thus, they are not committing perjury in their DMCA notices.
- ilamont 14y ago
- objclxt 14y agoI'm afraid the author of this article doesn't really know much about the subject matter here: >"Does the Authors Guild care about writers? Absolutely — just as much as the RIAA cares about musicians." This really isn't true. The RIAA represents the recording industry - not musicians. The Authors Guild, along with the Writers Guild and other organisations, do represent authors, and they do care about them. The presidents of both the Authors Guild and the Writers Guild are writers. Both frequently go up against the studios themselves. There have been many, many conflicts between the guilds and publishers/studios. You can argue that what the Authors Guild is doing here is misguided, but to say the guild doesn't care about authors is just plain wrong. I speak from experience.
- tolos 14y agoI read a small amount of sarcasm in that statement -- but maybe that's just me.
- squarecat 14y agoTIL Many authors don't like to read.
- dougmccune 14y agoThe author argues against the quick-to-blame mob, and yet tries to make it sound like publishers were partly responsible for this ("thanks to ... publisher FUD") and yet nowhere is there any mention of a single publisher involved in this whole debacle (other than Amazon). Something happened to e-books! It must be the publishers! Get your pitchforks!
- camiller 14y agoSince the host was getting hundreds of take down notices I suspect that somewhere on the not disclosed list were in fact publishers. I'm willing to take that assumption on faith unless you have a copy of the list and there are no publishers on it?
- rmc 14y agoThe copyright companies lost the moral argument or high ground long ago.
- j_s 14y agoDid LendInk provide financial benefit to any author? My understanding is that it only acted as a clearinghouse for one-time loans.
- falcolas 14y agoNo, but Amazon did. Per one of the linked articles: "Just as with any other lend, the author gets her commission[...]" http://www.publetariat.com/think/congratulations-you-killed-lendink-and-denied-your-fellow-authors-their-lend-royalties http://www.publetariat.com/think/congratulations-you-killed-... So, yeah. By killing LendInk, they deprived authors of potential royalty income. EDIT: Per Amazon's terms and conditions, not linked from any of the articles, this isn't as clear cut. Some authors (members of the KDP program) can get money from lending out their books, but the 1x per purchase lend does not, as pointed out by j_s.
- j_s 14y agoWhat I'm asking is for documentation that authors get a commission on a one-time lend between Kindle users (the type of lend facilitated by LendInk). I have learned that KDP Select authors get a commission per lend but that may be limited to lends from Amazon to Amazon Prime members. Edit: Specifically, it sounds like LendInk facilitated "Lending for Kindle" loans https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A2JGI9S4FDM39Q https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/help?topicId=A2JGI9S4... > Will I receive royalties when customers choose to lend my book? > > Loans of digital books through the Kindle Book Lending program > are not purchases and thus are not eligible to receive royalty payments.
- sp332 14y agoLendInk was more of a matchmaker. All the actual lending happened on Amazon and Barnes & Noble websites.
- smackfu 14y agoI'm just shocked there were enough books with lending enabled to make this possible. I think about 5% of my library has that.
- bhousel 14y agoBelieve it or not, most Kindle books are lendable. I have a database of Kindle books that I built last year, but I know that now there are over a million titles. So, year old data: > db.books.find({'lendable': true}).count(); 543519 > db.books.count(); 846456
- smackfu 14y agoIt would be interesting to compare that to the sales list. See if popular books are lendable.
- rprasad 14y agoSelf-published books are lendable by default, and are subject to a lower royalty rate if lending is disabled. Most major publishing houses do not enable lending b/c they have negotiated separate contracts with Amazon that do not require it.
- atourgates 14y agoAuthors subsist increasingly on goodwill as pirating their products becomes easier and easier. I buy every book I read entirely because I want to support the author, not because there's any sort of barrier between me and pirating the book. Of course, I'm likely more technologically capable than the average reader, but for how long? It's not hard to imagine a future where piracy is an easy and attainable option for the vast majority of readers. A future where authors subsist almost entirely on the goodwill of their readers. And as a reader, this move seems like a straight up fuck you. When I buy a physical book (often at a price near that of an ebook) I can lend it to friends and family an infinite number of times, resell it for a good portion of the original price, or give it away to whomever I please. I have no such "rights" with a DRM protected ebook. But I do have the right with some DRM protected ebooks to temporarily lend it to someone else. And these authors just tried to make that more difficult. And really, what have they accomplished? They've shut down a single tool that let some readers use a publisher-sanctioned tool to lend DRM-protected ebooks. They haven't stopped anyone with the power of Google from learning how to remove the DRM from their ebooks or audiobooks and sharing them with however many friends, family members and strangers they want. They haven't stopped anyone with the power of Google from finding torrents of their ebooks or audiobooks. They did however manage to piss off a chunk of their customers. The ones who actually pay $12 for an ebook. If you subsist in part or in whole on the goodwill of your customers, it seems like a good idea to try and maintain that goodwill.
- MattSayar 14y agoThis is beautiful and succinct. It makes me wonder what part of this whole operation can even be considered a "success."
- res0nat0r 14y ago> When I buy a physical book (often at a price near that of an ebook) I can lend it to friends and family an infinite number of times, resell it for a good portion of the original price, or give it away to whomever I please. It would be awesome to know the average 'lending count' of physical books, but I can tell you it is for sure no where anything close to 'infinite', I doubt it is even approaching ten. Have you checked out the resale value of anything on Amazon that isn't considered collectible or a first edition? I hate seeing that I am only getting less than two bucks for a book I paid 24.95$ for just a few months ago. Same goes with selling back retail copies of most of my stuff at Half Price Books.
- tedunangst 14y agoCan someone explain how they destroyed LendInk? All the website says is "Currently offline Not due to DMCA complaints." So why is it offline? Shouldn't an article like this have a quote from the site operator?
- kodablah 14y agoAFAIK, many authors and publishers sent DMCA notices and other threatening letters to the company hosting LendInk's website. Out of fear of litigation, the hosting company shut down LendInk.
- tedunangst 14y agoI guess I don't understand why somebody would post "Not due to DMCA complaints" on their website if they took it down because of DMCA complaints.
- kodablah 14y agoFirstly, I see "This account has been suspended. Either the domain has been overused, or the reseller ran out of resources." on http://lendink.com http://lendink.com. Secondly, even if it did say that, it could somewhat be construed as true. The DMCA process wasn't necessarily followed since I don't think the hosting company gave the website owner the opportunity to refute them. Again, if I remember correctly, the website owner does not blame the host and did not see it as a fight worth fighting since there was little (or no) revenue involved. Edit: the last paragraph may be incorrect; the hosting company may have given him an out. Regardless, he decided it was not worth the effort.
- icebraining 14y agoI see the same as tedunangst: "Currently offline / Not due to DMCA complaints."
- camiller 14y agoYeah, when he first took over LendInk he was an Amazon affiliate. So if a user ended up buying a book that they had borrowed but didn't finish he made a little coin. Once Amazon severed it's affiliate links in California he lost that. Even at it's peak he still didn't make that much money.
- anigbrowl 14y agoAfter reading the article twice, I'm unable to see how the authors 'took the site down,' other than by griping about it.
- jeremyarussell 14y agoA big question to everyone that says Lendink was violating the spirit of the lending feature. Does it say anywhere in the terms over at amazon that I wouldn't be allowed to lend to people online? Case and point, I use facebook like just about everyone else does. More or less for keeping in touch with family and actual friends. What's to stop me from posting my lending links in a status update? And how is that any different than lendink? Would starting a facebook group for reading lovers and posting a link there be out of question?
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoOf course it doesn't say it in black and white. That's why people use the phrase "in the spirit". The trouble with LendInk is in how the metaphor of a book changes once it's online. With a physical book, you have to learn that your friend has it, either by seeing it on their bookshelf or hearing them talk about it. Then you ask for the book. So it will happen every once-in-a-while; depending on how many reading friends you have, you might lend out a particular book 0-5 times before the book falls apart. But LendInk is advertising what books are available, and it only needs to find one owner, somewhere, anywhere, who's willing to lend it to you. You don't even have to know them, because there will be some owners who will gleefully lend anything to anyone. So instead of having to individually learn about the 100 books your friend owns, or the 1000 books that your ten friends own, you just need to show up on LendInk, ask for a book, and get it sooner or later. The books on LendInk are too available.
- ricardonunez 14y agoI discovered a lot of good authors thanks to friends that lend me their books. A good author wants to put their books in more readers. If they wrote good book one of those free readers will become a fan and buy other books from the author. It happens to me when I read a good book. They will loose more than win with this move.