10 ms·
Flying car closes in on FAA OK
- axefrog 14y agoI think it would be more apt to call this a driveable compact plane. It clearly looks a lot more like a plane than it does a car, it just happens to be compact with folding wings and four wheels on the base.
- dclowd9901 14y agoI,too, wonder how one gets off calling this a car. You even have to launch it from an airport. That old joke about "where are the flying cars? Have you ever heard of airplanes" misses the essential dream: To go into your garage, hop in your car and lift off and go wherever. That's the flying car. Sadly, unless we make some strides in the direction of gravitational manipulation or fusion drives, I'm not sure that'll ever be a reality.
- kemiller 14y agoI do agree that that's the true vision of the flying car, but I think there's still room for something that is more car-like than the vehicle in the article. Something that functions more or less like a car for short trips but could replace freeway travel with air travel. And which requires considerably less training/certification than an aircraft. Still not an easy problem. Closest is probably the doomed Moller Skycar. Once we have self-driving land-based cars (and widespread mainstream acceptance of them), a lot will open up since we could relieve the burden of human control.
- whileonebegin 14y agoI don't see how a flying car makes any sense. Instead of accidents on the ground (which are fatal enough), now you'll have them falling out of the sky. Granted, I was just in an accident a few weeks ago, and it dramatically changed my view on driving altogether. Crashes aren't just something that happens "to someone else". People are very irresponsible, reckless, and impatient when it comes to moving vehicles.
- kemiller 14y agoThat's why you need advanced auto-pilot before this is feasible. And bear in mind that there's a lot more room for collision avoidance in the air. You'd probably have to have something like special lanes in the air to minimize the number of directions that another vehicle could approach, and to keep them out of the commercial airspace. You'd need a special license to go "off-road".
- mikeash 14y agoMaking an airplane easy enough to fly that most people could conceivably pilot one, with a similar amount of training as currently required to learn to drive, is the interesting and important thing here. It also happens to be something that this airplane does nothing to address. Once you have an airplane that's as easy to fly as a car is to drive, you can do all of what you're talking about, and there's no reason to combine it with something that can drive it on a highway. It's not that big of a hassle to switch vehicles at the airport.
- repiret 14y agoAre they actually making this airplane easier to fly? As far as I can tell, it will have the same flight controls as any other small single-engine plane. More degrees of freedom in the air means more to do to keep the plane going where you want. As far as licensing, you still need (in the US) to get a Light Sport certificate, which is most certainly a higher bar than a drivers license. I agree that the Light Sport standards lower the bar for pilot and airplane certification, and that the result is great for general aviation. But lets not pretend that this airplane plays a big role there.
- mikeash 14y agoAs I said in the previous message, "It also happens to be something that this airplane does nothing to address." In short, the one thing about the "flying car" concept that's interesting in the real world is making the things easier to fly. This "flying car" misses that one thing.
- FixThisPOS 14y agoThey DO call this a "roadable aircraft." They have never called this a flying car.
- hammersend 14y agoWe already have flying cars. We just call them "helicopters".
- alecdibble 14y agoIt's kind of hard to drive helicopters down the highway.
- mikeash 14y agoNot more difficult than flying it anywhere else. Just make sure to watch out for wires.
- alecdibble 14y agoI didn't know flying and driving were synonyms these days.
- mikeash 14y agoThe only difference is the altitude, and helicopters can go as low as you dare.
- alecdibble 14y agoI assumed driving meant moving on land with a (most likely) combustion-powered platform that was connected to the land with wheels. No wheels and no ground contact sounds like hovering to me.
- nateabele 14y agoBetter headline: "Beat the TSA for under $300K".
- jnorthrop 14y agoIf anyone is curious to see some picture of the vehicle they are here: http://www.terrafugia.com/photogallery.html http://www.terrafugia.com/photogallery.html It looks a little fragile to perform well as a car. I imagine a significant pot hole might be enough to damage the skin. I understand the need to be light and aerodynamic so that it is flight-worthy, but this looks more like a toy then a real solution. It reminds me of those cars that can also perform as a boat -- they do neither well, their remarkable feature is that they do both.
- tamersalama 14y agoGood point - if as car it goes into a fender-bender. Who'd deem it airworthy?
- joshuahedlund 14y agoThis sounds cool but I'm not familiar with it. Why is it called a "flying car"? Is it the price point - is $279K significantly cheaper than most private airplanes? Or is there something in the construction that makes it more "carlike" than most private airplanes?
- alecdibble 14y agoIt's street legal [1] and supposedly fits into your average sized garage[2]. You can't really drive a Cessna down your local neighborhood. 1: http://www.terrafugia.com/images/photogallery/March10_2012%20243-FrontDriving8x10WM.jpg http://www.terrafugia.com/images/photogallery/March10_2012%2... 2: http://www.terrafugia.com/images/photogallery/LeavingGarageWM8x10.jpg http://www.terrafugia.com/images/photogallery/LeavingGarageW...
- piotrSikora 14y ago> is $279K significantly cheaper than most private airplanes? No, it's not. You can buy lower-end models of Cessna and Cirrus at similar price... and Cessna Skycatcher costs only half of that ($149,900).
- mikeash 14y agoAnd this is if you buy new. There's a huge market for used light aircraft out there, as they last for decades. You can buy a nice light airplane for less than 1/3rd of what these guys are charging, and something one could consider entirely decent for less than 1/5th.
- piotrSikora 14y agoObviously! However, I felt that used aircraft vs new flying car wouldn't be a fair price comparison.
- mikeash 14y agoI can understand that, but I think the two markets are different enough to be worth pointing out. People who buy used cars are often buying something a few years old. By the time a car is ten years old, it's being traded around for a tiny fraction of its original cost, and maybe even headed off to be junked/recycled. Maintenance costs are starting to skyrocket, and because of all that, people tend to trade up frequently. A used airplane is probably decades old. It's probably selling for a similar price to what it originally went for when it was new. Maintenance costs are high, but they were high when the thing was new, so that's not particularly remarkable. I'd wager that the majority of light aircraft flying in the US today would qualify for "antique" license plates if they were cars. It's a substantially different market, where the equipment lasts longer and buying used is much more common.
- amurmann 14y agoKnowing nothing about aviation, I find air planes with one engine very scary. Even when I am not traveling in it, since I don't want one to fall on me either. So I am glad we probably won't see millions of these "flying cars" being sold. If I imagine to have one of these fall off the sky as often as I see broken down cars on the side of the freeway...
- rdtsc 14y agoIt is all fun can games until a teenager drives their car into the side of this and the $300K flying car needs to be replaced.
- retr0rocket 14y agoas opposed to the 500k cars that exist now?? your point is?
- blhack 14y agoHow is that different than some person driving into the side of a lamborghini?
- baggachipz 14y agoWhat's funny to me is that when cruising in the air, it gets ~25 mpg; on the ground, 35 mpg. http://www.terrafugia.com/aircraft.html http://www.terrafugia.com/aircraft.html
- aacook 14y agoI'm guessing that's because you're going 105-115 mph instead of 50 mph... essentially twice as fast. Surprising to see max speed is 115 mph, for some reason I thought it would be much higher.
- baggachipz 14y agoA lot of US interstates have a speed limit of 80; in that case it's only marginally faster speed-wise. But, going between two points on a straight line helps too. I'm more amused, though, that it's less efficient when the wheels aren't touching the ground. I guess I always just assumed that air travel was more efficient than a vehicle that touches the ground, creating lots of relative drag.
- volci 14y agoYou travel a [generally] significantly shorter distance when flying, and at a notably higher rate of speed (though normal cruise speed will likely be lower than max rated) So a drop in mpg is completely understandable Also, there is a lot more causing drag (the wings at least) when it is flying vs when it is on the ground
- wes-exp 14y agoAlso, planes need to continually lift your weight against gravity. There is vertical force that needs to be produced in addition to the normal horizontal travel.
- tocomment 14y agoI thought the principal of lift means the aircraft is sort of resting on the air (in a manner of speaking) and doesn't need to produce vertical force. Much like a boat doesn't need to produce vertical force to stay above the water. I may be completely wrong, the concept of lift never made sense to me. It always seemed like free energy.
- brk 14y agoHrm... This seems a little like the worst of both worlds. It's horrible as a car (in the sense of something you'd drive to work everyday), and for the money it's not the most cost effective airplane either. Many people seem to think "flying car" == "I can just launch and avoid all the rush hour traffic, and then land in my driveway". The reality of course is far different, you have to drive this to/from an airport. I'm curious what problem this is intended to solve.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoThe plane's need for a runway makes this impractical (unless you start tacking extra lanes on interstates), but for VTOL "cars" it'd make sense to build smaller-scale landing pads that feed into highway on-ramps.
- lotharbot 14y ago> "This seems a little like the worst of both worlds." We (staff of the Museum of Flight) said the same thing about Moulton Taylor's Aerocar [0]. It doesn't do either thing very well, and that's a big reason there hasn't been a hugely successful product in the space yet. That said, it does solve a specific problem: it cuts significant time off for those who regularly make trips in the hundreds of miles, particularly between semi-remote locations. Imagine you lived in central Kansas, and had radio transmitters, oil fields, or clients spread all across the state. You could fly from small airport to small airport [1] in considerably less time than it would take to drive, and then have a car available to drive out to your destination. One of the advantages this variant has over other past attempts is that it's classified under the (new) "Light Sport Aircraft" category [2]. It's much easier to get a LSA license than a normal pilots license, among other things. [0] http://www.museumofflight.org/aircraft/taylor-aerocar-iii http://www.museumofflight.org/aircraft/taylor-aerocar-iii [1] http://www.filmkansas.com/pages/airports http://www.filmkansas.com/pages/airports - map of KS airports [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-sport_aircraft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light-sport_aircraft
- MartinCron 14y agoThe "Light Sport Aircraft" designation might very well be a big deal. I'm hoping that this is just the first of many light sport aircraft that make flying more practical for more people.
- volci 14y agoTerrafugia (and others) have been making fantastic technological inroads across industries: good to see the FAA is taking solid note
- mikeash 14y agoI seriously don't understand the appeal of this. For the money they're charging, you could buy a great normal plane, a great normal car to use to drive to the airport, another great normal car to keep at the other airport you use most often, and have enough money left over to rent cars at other airports you visit for the rest of your life.
- kirubakaran 14y agoThat is the price now. Competition and mass production will drive that down (if not for this particular manufacturer / model, for others in the same category).
- mikeash 14y agoPeople still have to buy it now for that to happen, so wondering about the appeal is still completely pertinent. Also, when was the last time an airplane, or even a general type of airplane, started out expensive and then got cheaper as time went on?
- repiret 14y agoCompetition and mass production hasn't brought the price of any Part 23 (not kit) plane below 6 figures. There's less variety of engines than airplanes, so the engines are produced in greater volume, but even after years of mass production their prices are still high - a new 150-200 HP engine will set you back more than a nice luxury sedan.
- FixThisPOS 14y agoThink about it. First off, look at the price of a Cirrus. Not much (if any) cheaper, although it's a fully certified plane (not a light-sport). This plane offers several important advantages. First, no hangar fees. You land and drive home. It runs on AUTOMOTIVE GAS. This is a huge advantage. Finally: weather avoidance. If the weather turns bad, you land and continue your trip on the ground. When it clears up, you go to the nearest airport and take to the air again. This is probably the greatest thing about a roadworthy plane. The critical part of all this is SAVING OUR AIRPORTS. We have been robbed of thousands of airports over the last few decades by corruption, greed, and stupidity. It goes all the way up from the people who move next door to an airport and then start bitching about it (ahem Santa Monica) to the politicians who pander to them while taking handouts from developers; to those developers who goad all of them on so they can move in for the land grab. Stand up for your local airport. They are an irreplaceable part of our national transportation infrastructure. Without them, advances like the Terrafugia and electric planes will die because there will be no market. Take a flying lesson! That's a unique opportunity that the rest of the world has squandered. Just ask Europe, where user fees have essentially destroyed general aviation. And the Obama administration has been trying to do the same thing here year after year after year.
- joeguilmette 14y agoThis is more for pilots who want a more mobile aircraft than normal folk who want a car that flies. Owning a Cessna means you have to pay for a tiedown or a hangar at an airport. With this, you can hangar it in your garage. The added expense doesn't really make sense, but it certainly makes it more convenient. The same with premium laptops, people like myself don't mind paying an extra $1000 for a MacBook knowing its an easier, smoother experience. Likewise, a wealthy pilot might prefer this to a Cessna because it makes things simpler.
- Kilimanjaro 14y agoThe first 100 units will be delivered to the cartel of sinaloa, the cartel of jalisco is on the waiting list for another 100 units. I am buying stock.
- Kilimanjaro 14y agoMy dream of a flying car is a small harrier in the shape of a porsche. Vertical take off and landing should be priority number one.