3 ms·
Under any occasion, it was inappropriate to arrest a judge like this. We’re honestly at the point where I’d be comfortable with armed militias defending state
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
Under any occasion, it was inappropriate to arrest a judge like this.
We’re honestly at the point where I’d be comfortable with armed militias defending state and local institutions from federal police. If only to force someone to think twice about something like this. (To be clear, I’m not happy we’re here. But we are.)
- dylan604 2y agowhy do you think the people willing to be a part of the armed militias you mention are NOT on the same way of thinking as what ICE is attempting to do. that's just how the militia types tend to lean, so I don't think this would have the effect you're looking for
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> that's just how the militia types tend to lean So far. I don’t think you’d have trouble recruiting an educated, well-regulated militia from folks who believe in the rule of law.
- totalkikedeath 2y ago[dead]
- exe34 2y agoyou'd be declared an illegal immigrant and removed to hotel salvador pretty quickly at this point. The orangefuhrer has already said he's coming after the "homegrown" next.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- goatlover 2y agoAt what point will Democratic state governors and legislatures have enough of autocratic takeover? States have their own National Guard.
- dylan604 2y agoWhile I'm not familiar with all 50 governors, I'm wondering if there might not be some Republican governors that think things have gone too far as well. Being a Republican does not mean you are in favor of autocracy. It just looks like that right now because nobody is sticking their necks out, but I'm holding onto hope that if it does get to that point, further resistance might come out.
- selimthegrim 2y agoYou might want a State Guard, which might be a little harder to federalize than the National Guard
- johnnyanmac 2y agowe'll see if/when the lawsuits lauched against the administration is ignored by the administration. But no one wants a civil war. No one would win here except maybe China/Russia.
- dylan604 2y agoYou discount the people that want to watch the world burn. The tree of...fed with blood...blah blah blah. "Burn it down, start over" is often touted as the fastest/best approach for wholesale changes when the friction to making change is too great. Economically, China would probably be the biggest beneficiary to a US civil war, especially one that ended with 2 Americas with neither the strength of the former union. Russia would just love to see the chaos and reap whatever gains they could get as well.
- kcatskcolbdi 2y agoand something tells me the side that spent decades demonizing firearm ownership probably can't win an arms race against their ideological opponents.
- dylan604 2y agodidn't think of that salient detail
- sophacles 2y agoWhat a strange set of ideas presented in such a small sentence fragment. * Very few people demonize gun ownership. They just want some laws preventing criminals from owning guns. * Guns are very easy to obtain, the "arms race" is a trip to the local sporting goods store. Sure, the weapon may not be super tacti-cool with a bunch of skulls and shit, but I'm pretty sure that even without all the virtue signalling decals it does the primary job just fine.
- dylan604 2y agoDo you think those that have been opposed to current gun laws would be nearly as proficient at the use of their newly acquired weapon as opposed to those that have been collecting them for years? This just made up militia will be woefully untrained to handle anything. At least those that have their meeting in the woods practice to whatever extent they do, but that would be so much more than this recent trip to the sporting goods store. Whether you want to quibble over the words demonize, there are a lot of people that do not interpret the constitution to mean that just any ol' body can own a gun to the extent we allow today. The well regulated militia is part of that amendment, and gets left out quite conveniently. The local police departments are closer to the idea of a well regulated militia. The national guard are even closer of a match to me. The guys that run around in the woods believe they are fulfilling that role, but nobody really thinks they are well regulated other than whatever rules they choose to operate. Personally, I do not think that what we have today with the NRA and what not is what the framers had in mind. So you complain about demonizing being wrong and clearly on one end of the spectrum. I think that the NRA refusing any limits on guns is clearly the other end of that spectrum
- Teever 2y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/liberalgunowners/ https://old.reddit.com/r/liberalgunowners/ is a thing. Lots of people with a variety of political stripes own guns and are just less vocal about it.
- mindslight 2y agoWe've got National Guards under the command of state governors for a reason. Just sayin'.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> We've got National Guards under the command of state governors for a reason. Yes, but that reason is not for rebellion against the federal government, which is why their equipment and training is governed by the federal government and the President can by fiat order them into federal service at which point he is the C-in-C, not the government. Most states do also have their own non-federal reserve military force in additionto their National Guard, but those tend to be tiny and not organized for independent operations (e.g., the ~900 strength California State [not National] Guard.)
- mindslight 2y agoIf the federal government is no longer beholden to the law because the king executive refuses to follow or enforce inconvenient laws, would it be appropriate to consider it a rebellion? It seems more like basic law enforcement to me. I was under the impression that state governors could refuse to federalize their National Guards. A quick read on Wikipedia points to the Constitution saying it would take Congress for the federal government to take command unilaterally. That could be a sticking point by the time it gets to the point where there is enough support for state governors to be deploying their state National Guards to keep the peace versus the lawless federal executive.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> I was under the impression that state governors could refuse to federalize their National Guards. They cannot, under the Constitution. Of course, at the point the National Guard is being mobilized to prevent actions of the federal government, we are deep into a constitutional crisis and a short distance from a (possibly very brief) active civil war. > A quick read on Wikipedia points to the Constitution saying it would take Congress for the federal government to take command unilaterally. Congress has already done so , setting rules which require only a Presidential determination to invoke [0], and Presidents have used the authority so granted specifically to deal with very much the same state rebellion scenario you suggest, notably Eisenhower in 1957 when the Arkansas National Guard was deployed to prevent the implementation of a federal court order integrating Central High School in Little Rock: Eisenhower did the one-two punch of federalizing the entire Arkansas National Guard, ordered them away, and also deployed the Army (101st Airborne) to enforce the order. [1] [0] in the Insurrection Act; the specific relevant provision is at 10 USC § 252: “Whenever the President considers that unlawful obstructions, combinations, or assemblages, or rebellion against the authority of the United States, make it impracticable to enforce the laws of the United States in any State by the ordinary course of judicial proceedings, he may call into Federal service such of the militia of any State, and use such of the armed forces, as he considers necessary to enforce those laws or to suppress the rebellion.” (emphasis added) [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Rock_Nine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Rock_Nine
- esbranson 2y ago[flagged]
- lolinder 2y agoParty composition changes over time, and the people who made up the KKK switched parties starting when JFK backed the civil rights movement. It's the right wing militias that are the spiritual successors to the KKK, not the Democratic party. As much as I wish we had a Republican party that was an actual successor to Lincoln's, that's not how political parties work. https://economics.princeton.edu/working-papers/why-did-the-democrats-lose-the-south-bringing-new-data-to-an-old-debate/ https://economics.princeton.edu/working-papers/why-did-the-d...
- esbranson 2y ago[flagged]
- lolinder 2y agoI said the process started with JFK. Trump moved the needle a lot in the last 8 years, too, so it clearly wasn't finished then either and probably still hasn't finished, because parties are messy dynamic things that change all the time. I never saw myself voting Democrat until 2016, yet here we are three elections later and it's looking like I'd better settle in.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> > Party composition changes over time, and the people who made up the KKK switched parties starting when JFK backed the civil rights movement. > George "segregation forever" Wallace got a number of votes at the 1976 Democratic National Convention 1.89% of the votes, yes. "Starting when" doesn't mean "immediately completed on" (the mainly civil rights-related phase of the unusually long overlapping realignment period that started with the New Deal, as well as the realignment period itself, completed around the mid-1990s; if you wanted to stake a specific endpoint marker for it, immediately after the 1994 midterm elections is probably the best point.) > and controlled that Party well into the 1980s. George Wallace obviously never "controlled" the Democratic Party, and certainly not into the 1980s. (Now the state party in Alabama, sure, but the state party and the national party are not the same thing.) > As much as we don't want it to be, it's the same Democratic Party. It's not, and you can tell it is not by seeing which of the major parties people waving confederate flags and openly preaching white supremacy demonstrate for and advocate for and turn out for on election day. That's how political realignments work.
- gosub100 2y agoWhy don't you organize one?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Why don't you organize one? I live in Wyoming. Our courts aren’t being attacked. I’d absolutely be open to lending material support to anyone looking to lawfully organise something like this in their community, however.
- ty6853 2y agoThis is basically what Ammon Bundy did, and most of the US hates him for it. The federal government tried many times to jail him but ultimately he was found innocent everytime. Finally they managed to get him by a friendly judge who had a husband high up in the BLM, awarding an ungodly high lawsuit when he helped an innocent mother get her baby back by summonsing his protest-militia to protest a hospital that conspired to have the baby taken by child services. Seriously, listen to some videos of Ammon Bundy actually speak (he is pro immigration rights as well, despite the 'far-right' label). Not what you hear from the media or others or under the influence of a political agenda. Most of what he says is 99% in line with your thought process here.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> most of the US hates him for it Invisible enemies are hard to rally against.
- dmoy 2y agoIt is illegal in all 50 states to organize a militia.
- ty6853 2y agoI know what study you are reading and the case it uses to argue that is highly flawed.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoThe charge seems colorable to me, and I think most people would agree the judge was obstructing justice if you strip out the polarizing nature of ICE detentions. If you take the charges at face value, Law enforcement was there to perform an arrest and the judge acted outside their official capacity to obstruct.
- southernplaces7 2y agoYes except that the very same armed types, after years of being derided by Democrat and progressive types as ignorant rednecks, are the least likely (for now at least) to defend a judge being targeted for protecting immigrants by the Trump administration. I know of no armed militia types that are of the opposing political persuasion, being armed is just a bit too kitsch and crude for them it seems. Maybe they reconsider their views of armed resistance in these years.
- senderista 2y agoI guess you weren't there for the CHOP, where there were masked antifa wandering around with AR-15s and intimidating business owners.
- djeastm 2y agoMaybe those groups are better at disguising themselves.