4 ms·
The CPU emulator part got me thinking, because Burroughs B5000 never was bare metal anyway, rather it was also one of the first bytecode based OSes, so it isn't
by pjmlp 2y ago
The CPU emulator part got me thinking, because Burroughs B5000 never was bare metal anyway, rather it was also one of the first bytecode based OSes, so it isn't really emulation when running on the Libra systems.
That would like saying Java/Android and .NET applications, or IBM i, are running under an emulator, even though technically a dynamic compiler is a form of emulation.
- skissane 2y agoI think there is a big difference: the original hardware, the “emulator” was in the CPU microcode - so very close to bare metal, and was narrowly targeted to only do what it needed to do. Compare that to a software emulator running under a commodity general-purpose operating system-it is a lot further from the bare metal, once you consider all the layers in-between (the OS kernel, libc, etc), the trusted computing base is a lot larger: its size has grown dramatically, being general-purpose includes lots of features the emulator doesn’t need or use - so from a security viewpoint, this is in some respects a step backwards - even though made necessary by economics, and simultaneously has some practical security benefits - although the general purpose OS may be theoretically worse from a security perspective, it receives huge amounts of attention, which helps keep it secure; a rarely used proprietary platform, whatever its theoretical advantages, doesn’t receive the same attention, making it more likely vulnerabilities may lurk undiscovered