5 ms·
Quora was founded by facebookers. People who actually have the worst fucking view online about what should be private and what should be public. People who hav
by samstave 14y ago
Quora was founded by facebookers. People who actually have the worst fucking view online about what should be private and what should be public.
People who have no digital-cultural compass because the only reference point they have is from working at Facebook, thus they think that "this is how it was thought of and done at Facebook - and Facebook is the most overly hyped company in history, so I must be a fucking genius!"
No thanks.
Done with quora forever.
- sek 14y agoI was thinking the same thing. Only Facebook makes such disrespectful moves... and then i remembered where the Quora founders came from. I hope they fail, Facebook is a horrible example and everybody should realize that.
- wpietri 14y agoI get your perspective, but I think Facebook is basically correct in the long term. Privacy is basically a historical accident belonging to the few hundred years in the west where transportation tech got ahead of information technology. An excellent read on the topic is David Brin's "The Transparent Hand". He basically makes the argument that we face one of two futures: either all of us know everybody's business or a small elite controls the flow of information. Basically, our choice is a surveillance democracy vs a surveillance state. I think he's right that there's no way to put the genie back in the bottle. That's not to say that Quora's moves aren't fucking annoying, but I do think just refusing to participate won't make a long-term difference in how things turn out.
- genwin 14y agoMore likely it'll be the small elite (who stay private) maximizing profits using the info that the vast majority made public. Those who make their "private" info public will likely on average pay higher interest & insurance rates, have smaller salaries after taking longer to find jobs, etc.
- wpietri 14y agoHonestly, that's one of the better outcomes. Imagine an oligarchy where the elite knows your genetic profile, your social activity, your daily habits, and your deviations from normal behavior. They may know before you do when you're starting to get restive, and will certainly be able to defuse or destroy any resistance. A fun novel relating to this is Daniel Suarez's "Kill Decision".
- genwin 14y agoThanks for the recommend! The book 1984 also paints a world like that.
- antidoh 14y ago> Privacy is basically a historical accident belonging to the few hundred years in the west where transportation tech got ahead of information technology. I don't think privacy should be dictated by whatever is possible with technology, it should be explicitly decided by people. Whichever way they decide.
- wpietri 14y agoSure, but the way it was historically decided by most people was a position of little or no privacy. In a small town, everybody knows everybody's business. It's only urbanization, which only works because of good transportation, that made that untenable. So those of us who like privacy finally had some. But information technology is making it possible for people to keep track of basically everybody they care to again. So we're going to go right back to what most people like, which is life as soap opera.
- mercutio2 14y agoI'm fairly confident you mean "The Transparent Society", which happens to be one of my all time favorites. While its true Brin advocates giving up the illusion of privacy and (especially poignantly) that we should stop screwing around pretending identity keys are secrets, he does so in a framework that we should each individually own and control our identities, a position which seems to me antithetical to the noxious "we own your identity and can screw with you at will" approach Facebook has taken. I hate that Facebook captured the social space.
- wpietri 14y agoAh yes, thanks for the correction. I agree with you about not liking Facebook's capture of the medium. But I think the main way people are fighting that now is by pretending that they can go back to the age of privacy. I wish we could get past that.
- mercutio2 14y agoYes, I agree completely that even very technical people often have a surprising blind spot, thinking either we can put the database/facial recognition/cheap cameras genie back in the bottle, or alternately that leaving no digital trace is a Good Idea for the mainstream. One good thing Facebook has done is demonstrate that most people (arguably with a lot of unethical shifting of visibility preferences) are happy to live portions of their life in public. These people are not sheep, they're happy sharing portions of their identities. If only we had more nuanced, robust, personally controlled identity infrastructure. Much harder to achieve with Facebook owning a rudimentary, simplistic but very large subset of the social graph.