3 ms·
It's a very nice slogan that 'Israel has every right to defend themselves' from the rocket attacks, but they have no legal rights to take actions outside of the
by brl 18y ago
It's a very nice slogan that 'Israel has every right to defend themselves' from the rocket attacks, but they have no legal rights to take actions outside of the constraints of International Humanitarian Law.
Reprisals against civilians and indiscriminate attacks are clearly and explicitly prohibited by both the Fourth Geneva Convention and Protocol I. (Although, I believe Protocol I cannot be enforced against Israel since they have not ratified it).
Israel DOES NOT have the right to attack civilians as revenge or to deter or prevent future attacks. This is a war crime under international law (GC IV Art. 33, Art. 53).
Israel DOES NOT have the right to indiscriminately shell Gaza under the pretext of defending itself from terrorists no matter how carefully civilian casualties are minimized. Again, this is a war crime (Protocol I, Art. 51), you go to The Hague for this (Nuremburg Principle VI).
- rms 18y agoLook, I really don't want to argue about this on a forum, because we're not resolving anything and mostly people just make themselves angry. But you are so confident in your misconceptions that I feel obligated to say something. You are severely misunderstanding Israel's military strategy? Do you seriously think they're going around targeting civilians for revenge?
- brl 18y agoThere is no possible legal justification so it doesn't matter what their motives are.