5 ms·
The forced login stuff really enraged me. This is the rant I posted to Quora on the topic in hopes of getting them to change their minds: For a long time I've
by wpietri 14y ago
The forced login stuff really enraged me. This is the rant I posted to Quora on the topic in hopes of getting them to change their minds:
For a long time I've been meaning to write personal stuff about my mom's death last year from a brain tumor. The question "Death and Dying: What does it feels like when doctor says you'll just live X days / months?" popped up in my feed. So I answered it. In detail. Crying as I went. At some point I realized I was hyperventilating from the sobs, but I knew if I stopped I wouldn't finish. So I wrote and wrote and clicked "Add Answer".
Since I was sharing it with the world, I decided to man up and share it with my loved ones. I copied the link and posted it to Facebook, so that my friends and family could read it. Like you'd do with any other link in the world.
And then began the fucking tech support circus. Within an hour, somebody said:
I'd like to read this but I'm unable to without giving them my FB login info. Am I missing something?
I immediately checked, and I wasn't bothered when I clicked through, even when signed out of Quora. No idea what was going on. I thought it might be some referrer sniffing plus cookies; I suggested they copy-paste the link. Another friend made other suggestions. But that didn't solve it for everybody; another person just now commented:
I wanted to read, but I got this thing saying I need to approve an app called Quora - an app which "may post on my behalf" - which seems like a rather large presumption for an app to take. Or am I misunderstanding something which is actually quite benign? Sorry to interject a facebook question into this thread, but I do want to read what you wrote....
And they're right. It's a fucking giant presumption to ask for that just so my friends can read something I wrote and wanted to share with them. So I just gave up and copy-pasted the text into the little Facebook comment box, arguing meanwhile with Facebook about what the goddamn enter key means. (It means new line, motherfuckers.)
The end result: what I was hoping would be a solemn remembrance of my dead mom is now cluttered up with people trying to defend themselves against Quora's quest for better user numbers at their next fucking board meeting.
So thanks, Quora, for strip-mining my personal tragedy to up your AARRR metrics. I hope it was worth it, because you've lost a lot of my trust.
Edited to add links:
The rant on Quora: http://www.quora.com/rage-against-quora/Rage-forcing-Facebook-signup-on-inbound-links-from-Facebook http://www.quora.com/rage-against-quora/Rage-forcing-Faceboo...
And the answer I wrote: http://www.quora.com/Death-and-Dying-1/What-does-it-feels-like-when-doctor-says-youll-just-live-X-days-months/answer/William-Pietri http://www.quora.com/Death-and-Dying-1/What-does-it-feels-li...
- samstave 14y agoQuora was founded by facebookers. People who actually have the worst fucking view online about what should be private and what should be public. People who have no digital-cultural compass because the only reference point they have is from working at Facebook, thus they think that "this is how it was thought of and done at Facebook - and Facebook is the most overly hyped company in history, so I must be a fucking genius!" No thanks. Done with quora forever.
- sek 14y agoI was thinking the same thing. Only Facebook makes such disrespectful moves... and then i remembered where the Quora founders came from. I hope they fail, Facebook is a horrible example and everybody should realize that.
- wpietri 14y agoI get your perspective, but I think Facebook is basically correct in the long term. Privacy is basically a historical accident belonging to the few hundred years in the west where transportation tech got ahead of information technology. An excellent read on the topic is David Brin's "The Transparent Hand". He basically makes the argument that we face one of two futures: either all of us know everybody's business or a small elite controls the flow of information. Basically, our choice is a surveillance democracy vs a surveillance state. I think he's right that there's no way to put the genie back in the bottle. That's not to say that Quora's moves aren't fucking annoying, but I do think just refusing to participate won't make a long-term difference in how things turn out.
- genwin 14y agoMore likely it'll be the small elite (who stay private) maximizing profits using the info that the vast majority made public. Those who make their "private" info public will likely on average pay higher interest & insurance rates, have smaller salaries after taking longer to find jobs, etc.
- wpietri 14y ago