4 ms·
> "verify it rigorously (which if you cannot do, you should absolutely never touch an LLM!)" 100% this.
by simonw 2y ago
> "verify it rigorously (which if you cannot do, you should absolutely never touch an LLM!)"
100% this.
- williamstein 2y agoTotally. And yet rigorous proof is very difficult. Having done some mathematics involving nontrivial proofs, I respect even more how difficult rigor is.
- pdimitar 2y agoAh, I absolutely don't verify code in the mathematical sense of the word. More like utilize strong static typing (or hints / linters in weaker typed languages) and write a lot of tests. Nothing is truly 100% safe or free of bugs. What I meant with my comment up-thread was that I have enough experience to have a fairly quick and critical eye of code, and that has saved my skin many times.
- only-one1701 2y agoI like writing code more than reading it, personally.
- simonw 2y agoYeah, I think that's pretty common. It took me 15+ years of my own career before I got over my aversion to spending significant amounts of time reading through code that I didn't write myself.
- pdimitar 2y agoWe all do. But more often than not we have to learn to do surgical incisions in order to do our task for the day. It's what truly distinguishes a professional.
- th0ma5 2y agoYou have an automation bias. "Surely this thing knows more than me it must be right." and there is no reason to believe that, but you will.
- simonw 2y agoHow did you get there from me agreeing 100% with someone who said that you should be ready to verify everything an LLM does for you and if you're not willing to do that you shouldn't use them at all? Do you ever read my comments, or do you just imagine what I might have said and reply to that?
- th0ma5 2y agoThere's simply no way to verify everything that comes out of these things. Otherwise why use it? You also can't possibly truly know if you know more about a topic since by definition the models know more than you. This is automation bias. Do you not know the problems with even verifying or watching machines? This is a core part of the discussion of self driving vehicles. I guess I assumed you knew stuff about the field of AI!
- simonw 2y ago"You also can't possibly truly know if you know more about a topic since by definition the models know more than you" Where does that idea that "by definition the models know more than you" come from?
- th0ma5 2y agoIt's a good question because I also hastily wrote that. You'll come to defer to the model on average when it comes to otherwise coin flip judgements you have make when you yourself are unsure. The model may not have any more information but you don't have any indication that it wouldn't and even suspect that it secretly does and this bias makes you trust the model and accept things that are ultimately bad in possibly ways that you'll not discover for a very long time because it is deep within a specific context.