6 ms·
New study of birds shows citizen science can be trusted
- PostOnce 2y agoCitizen science, also known as science, has no incentive to falsify results to advance their career since they're already happily employed in an unrelated field.
- etrautmann 2y agoThis cynicism isn’t helpful. You’re right that there are issues with incentives in science but most scientists are attempting to produce quality work.
- gus_massa 2y agoYou mean like the Bigfoot video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVo6Vj0_Xbo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xVo6Vj0_Xbo ? People cheat, even in single games. If there is an online game to find birds IRL, there is an achievement to find a dodo, someone will find it. I've also see a lot of dubious or even wrong results in preprints and journal articles, so the only conclusion is that there are morons and liars everywhere. Trust but verify.
- genewitch 2y agoI have a finite amount of time on earth, I want to see the story in games but i no longer have the patience to learn every mechanic in every game. For idle games, speed up time. For survivors-likes I might hack up the meta currency a bit to get the game loop to plane out earlier (gold in vampire survivors, e.g.), for FPS unlimited ammo is usually enough. I've never cheated in an online game, going all the way back to warcraft and StarCraft on dialup. Never cheated at cards, either. My point is, I am an ethical and moral person and I take umbrage with the link to other forms of cheating. I have "finished" a lot of games, though. If I actually want the challenge I get the game on a console.
- xhkkffbf 2y agoSad but true. For instance, there are subprofessional tiers for many sports like cycling. They generally don't have drug testing because of cost and the presumption that no one would cheat for a mere hobby. But occasionally people get caught because of mistakes.
- tbrownaw 2y ago> no incentive to falsify results to advance their career There still personal ideology, teh lulz, basic cluelessness, and just being nuts.
- tbrownaw 2y agoWell, define "trust". This example is using what sounds like crowdsource apps as a measurement instrument. Which is going to have different limitations and different sources of interference than other measurement instruments, but of course it can work if what you're using it for is able to handle this.
- awesome_dude 2y agoYeah - it seems a stretch to go from "These two systems accurately showed a known behaviour" to "All citizen science systems can predict everything all the time"
- janwandersun 2y ago[dead]
- malfist 2y agoDidn't the majority of science used to be done by "citizen" scientists?
- huntr2asterisk 2y ago[dead]
- jppope 2y agoyes, and a lot of humanity's most important work
- neom 2y agoMy wife is prof at a decent uni in the states teaching big stuff™ and I got into a conversation about this with her recently, where we landed was "will academia ever trust plebs like me?" and after an hr or so of back and forth it was evident to me on average: it will not. I'm still thinking about what I think about that, but it was certainly my resolve, at least within my wifes institution (will remain unnamed).
- zdragnar 2y agoAcademia is a walled garden protected by paper degrees and the cost of tuition and time. Anyone who can achieve results without suffering the same tribulations to join the ranks of professors is a threat at best, a charlatan at worst, and to be dismissed regardless.
- thelaxiankey 2y agouh... maybe in your field. personally i've never seen good physics on Vixra or good biology anywhere except in biorxiv or journals.
- odyssey7 2y agoEver heard of an engineering firm?
- thelaxiankey 2y agoI mean, for like, some ML research, sure. For certain, even most, aspects of electrical engineering, absolutely. But for biology? Absolutely not. And even in more computer-adjacent fields, this is still ridiculously reductive. Geoff Hinton is an academic through-and-through, and he changed the world even for computer scientists. What about someone like Don Knuth? I mean, even google's pagerank started as an academic project. Engineering firms do great research too, but this is not the only way.
- odyssey7 2y ago
- sieabahlpark 2y ago[dead]
- odyssey7 2y agoIf professional science has gotten to be more about trust than reproducibility, then professional science cannot be trusted.
- drivingmenuts 2y agoFor certain values of "citizen science". When you get to the perpetual motion proponents and the anti-vaxxers, that might be a problem there.
- etrautmann 2y agoThis entire thread is replies is extremely disappointing. Obviously there are issues with credentialism but the widespread cynicism and rejection of the scientific enterprise throws the baby out with the bathwater. The scientific method itself is about continuously identifying what’s wrong and iteratively improving our knowledge. That inherently involves making some wrong turns and mistakes and spending money on some things that don’t pan out, but I’m surprised to see so many voices here arguing for less science.
- sandspar 2y ago"I guess you want less science" is exactly the kind of thinking that people dislike. "Science" used to be a magic word. Then people realized that science is done by scientists who are, you know, human, and hence subject to the same biases as all other humans. There's no monolithic "Science". It's just a concept. It doesn't exist. There's only scientists, and over the last five years, many of those scientists burnt their reputations.
- steve_adams_86 2y agoI’ve been working on a citizen science project recently. I realized I don’t really care if no one uses or trusts the data. I want to do it, I want to learn, and I think the outcome will be useful at the very least to increase awareness. Maybe that’s good enough? I think academia is walled off in part for good reason, but I have a feeling more people should participate in citizen science projects too. Even if you aren’t doing anything ground breaking, you still might be inching things in the right direction. It’s a great way to care about things, teach your kids, explore new skills and techniques with equipment, etc. I wish I started sooner.
- anothereng 2y agoThe pursuit of truth shouldnt be restricted to specific institutions. Go ahead
- sohkamyung 2y agoI use iNaturalist to log my observations and I think one benefit of such platforms is the large number of eyeballs available: casual observers see things not captured in more formal scientific field work. This happened to me: I saw an unusual bee while walking in a nature reserve. I posted it on iNaturalist and it got identified as a seldom seen bee. A bee researcher contacted me to get the location for a field study, resulting in a paper that documented the bee's natural behaviour. Other iNat observers have spotted moths and insects that haven't been seen for decades, for example. In this way, citizen scientist are helping scientist to find out more about nature.