3 ms·
I tried tagging my files for a while. I quit. Part of it was that tagging is done via an add-on, of course, and it added an additional step to creating a file.
by egypturnash 14y ago
I tried tagging my files for a while. I quit. Part of it was that tagging is done via an add-on, of course, and it added an additional step to creating a file.
But I also feel like there are a lot of problems that need to be solved about streamlining the process of tagging files, dealing with typos, and auto-creating maps of the tag structure.
And even if we did move to a wholly tag-based userland, your non-technical relative/coworker would STILL find ways to lose their documents.
Maybe tagging will be a better way. But I think "files" in "folders" have survived for the entire history of file systems for a good reason - they're conceptually simple for our brains to manipulate. There's enough of an aura of physicality to them that we can leverage the part of our brain that's good at storing maps. Honestly I think the way to move forwards is more along the lines of Raskin[1] - interfaces designed to make things MORE spatial - than into tags, which are incredibly ethereal to our brains.
Files and folders are, I think, a local maxima of efficiency. Tags may be more efficient in the long run, but there's a painful trough of uselessness to trudge through before we can get there.
(Other problems I see with tags:
- importing existing filesystems, without losing the existing hierarchies - do YOU want to go back and manually tag every file you've ever made and are still holding on to?
- can't control the importance of information. Sure, that project you just finished gets drawn huge in your tag cloud. But it's done, you want to move on, you don't even want to think about it right now because you're in the middle of the next one.
- suggesting tags as you type is not good enough, there needs to be a lot more work put into associating tags, so that if I'm saving a file with, say, the tag for my current comics project, I'm instantly presented with the associated tags of "web final images", "book file images", "fan art", "model sheets", and various subtags of those.
)
[1]: http://www.raskinformac.com/features.php http://www.raskinformac.com/features.php - and now I kinda want to try that out again, it's been a while.
- FixThisPOSSite 14y agoNot to mention that the assertions in this proposal are ridiculous: "In reality, the number of items you can store in a folder is limited while computer folders have unlimited capacity" So what? Who on earth is troubled by this? Weak attempt to create a problem where none exists. "Another glitch is the possibility to store folders in folders which is not possible in real live." Also wrong. It's quite possible to store folders in folders in real life. And you can put folders in boxes, which are nothing but a different-shaped folder. Again, this is a lame attempt to shore up a weak argument with sham "problems."