4 ms·
Income taxes are progressive while tariffs are regressive, so those under $150k are likely to be worse off.
by andsoitis 2y ago
Income taxes are progressive while tariffs are regressive, so those under $150k are likely to be worse off.
- Workaccount2 2y agoHe's not particularly intelligent.
- SoftTalker 2y agoAbout 3/4 of households make under $150k/year. Having no income tax will be hugely popular with them. It would kill the argument that Trump is only interested tax breaks for the rich.
- Workaccount2 2y agoIt would also make it politically untenable to get rid of tariffs and reinstate income tax.
- yurishimo 2y agoYea, this is the thing. Can you imagine transitioning over to a 0 income tax situation and then adding all of that infrastructure back? You know DOGE is going to nuke the servers that do it and rm -rf the repositories so if it's ever returned to law, everything will need to be done from scratch (likely making it untenable). If you're an IT professional in the US Government, I would argue you have an obligation as a concerned citizen to make some local backups of the code powering the systems you work on every day and keep them somewhere safe...
- tzs 2y agoOr it would make it politically quite tenable to get rid of tariffs and greatly raise income taxes on people making over $150k.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThey already do pay the vast majority of income taxes.
- sorcerer-mar 2y agoThe main takeaway from this fact being astonishment at just how much the top 1% really earns!
- tzs 2y agoTrue, they pay around 75-80% of income taxes. I suppose the good news for them then is that if tariffs fail to replace the 20-25% of income tax that would be lost by eliminating income tax on people making under $150k and it has to come from raising taxes on the folks making over $150k it would only be a 25-33% tax increase on them.
- int_19h 2y agoIt's a good start, now let's raise capital gains taxes to where they rightly out to be (i.e. more than sweat-of-the-brow income, not less).
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoThat's because they make the vast majority of the income. People really don't comprehend how much money the top 0.01% makes.
- bigbadfeline 2y agoI don't see the numbers though. Tariffs are a compete non-starter as far as government revenue goes, "income from tariffs" on the "countries that have been robbing us" is mere theatrics (those countries only accepted what was given/pushed to them)... Ergo, borrowing remains the only option, with lots and lots of inflation. I'm not sure how popular that will be.
- ty6853 2y agoOn first glance that's the case, in practice they clamp down hardest on middle and professional classes. The rich borrow against gains or pay long term capital gains, or just "re-invest" (no profit) into durable assets for their business that hold value longer than they'll be alive. The scam of income tax is that it's progressive on paper but not in practice.
- grunder_advice 2y agoYou are not wrong, but that situation won't change if you moved to another taxation scheme. The poor are too poor to have much to take from them. So they go after those who are a rung or two above to tax. The dynamic does not change irrespective of taxation system.
- debug-desperado 2y ago"The scam of income tax is that it's progressive on paper but not in practice." Perfectly put. It's always bothered me that the tax brackets don't continue on in a logarithmic fashion, e.g. new brackets at 1.5 million, 15 million, 150 million, etc.
- mindslight 2y agoFocusing on brackets for earned income is a distraction. Those only apply to relatively rare sports stars, actors, etc. The real cheats are things like tax rates being lower for capital gains, and that people receiving rental/royalty income can subtract all of their expenses (whereas wage earners cannot).
- atmavatar 2y agoArguably a bigger cheat is that if you have enough wealth tied up in stocks, you can realize capital gains for the sake of taking out loans to live off of without having to realize the gains for the sake of taxes. Then, you can pass those investments onto your inheritors with a stepped-up cost basis so they don't have to pay tax on the gains, either.
- Whoppertime 2y agoHow are tariffs regressive? Income taxes are obviously progressive. If you earn $100,000 you are going to be paying a higher percentage of your earnings compared to someone making $10,000 or $50,000. It's not intuitive that someone who makes $100,000 is going to be paying less in tariffs than someone making $50,000 though. How does that work?
- StackRanker3000 2y agoThey’re regressive in the sense that people with lower income spend more of it on consumption than people with higher income or wealth, who can save or invest at a higher rate.