42 ms·

After Chimera Linux’s pessimistic view on RISC-V application processors, I’m not holding my breath https://chimera-linux.org/news/2025/03/dropping-riscv.html h

by jitl 2y ago

After Chimera Linux’s pessimistic view on RISC-V application processors, I’m not holding my breath https://chimera-linux.org/news/2025/03/dropping-riscv.html https://chimera-linux.org/news/2025/03/dropping-riscv.html Note they eventually received a donation of CPU time that allows them to continue RISC-V support but it’s still a grim situation.

galangalalgol 2y ago
This release adds the cray style variable length vector instructions. Compiling with avx512 and running without it will crash, but this just uses whatever length the chip supports with the same instruction. Also means you don't have to wait on llvm to update every time they grow the vector size.
brucehoult 1y ago
Yes, they got access to a $2500 RISC-V machine that's been out for a year but isn't currently available because the same manufacturer has much updated machines coming out soon. $2500 is more than a Raspberry Pi but not expensive for any organisation that is paying even one salary to one employee. I also note they recently got an Ampere Altra arm64 machine, which I believe start at around $4000. Anyway, they blogged saying they were dropping RISC-V on March 12, got access to a RISC-V machine a couple of days later, mucked around a bit with build systems (including building a new Linux kernel that didn't advertise the pre-ratification V extension, which is a checkbox in `make menuconfig`) and then on March 20 -- 8 days after the initial post -- blogged that they had successfully completed a build of their distro on the donated RISC-V machine. I don't know how long that complete build of all their packages took (Chimera Linux repo contains 11057 packages), but it can't have been more than 3 or 4 days, maybe less, which seems very reasonable. I'm not sure what is "grim" here. It's a very new ISA -- first ratified only in July 2019, and with very significant additions in November 2021 and more very important things (for RVA23, which will be the baseline for Android and also for Ubuntu 26.04 LTS) right up to 2024. Machines are only going to get faster and cheaper from this point on, but a $2500 64 core 128 GB RAM machine from January 2024 that can build a complete distro in a couple of days isn't bad at all.

by jitl 2y ago

galangalalgol 2y ago

This release adds the cray style variable length vector instructions. Compiling with avx512 and running without it will crash, but this just uses whatever length the chip supports with the same instruction. Also means you don't have to wait on llvm to update every time they grow the vector size.

brucehoult 1y ago

Yes, they got access to a $2500 RISC-V machine that's been out for a year but isn't currently available because the same manufacturer has much updated machines coming out soon. $2500 is more than a Raspberry Pi but not expensive for any organisation that is paying even one salary to one employee. I also note they recently got an Ampere Altra arm64 machine, which I believe start at around $4000. Anyway, they blogged saying they were dropping RISC-V on March 12, got access to a RISC-V machine a couple of days later, mucked around a bit with build systems (including building a new Linux kernel that didn't advertise the pre-ratification V extension, which is a checkbox in `make menuconfig`) and then on March 20 -- 8 days after the initial post -- blogged that they had successfully completed a build of their distro on the donated RISC-V machine. I don't know how long that complete build of all their packages took (Chimera Linux repo contains 11057 packages), but it can't have been more than 3 or 4 days, maybe less, which seems very reasonable. I'm not sure what is "grim" here. It's a very new ISA -- first ratified only in July 2019, and with very significant additions in November 2021 and more very important things (for RVA23, which will be the baseline for Android and also for Ubuntu 26.04 LTS) right up to 2024. Machines are only going to get faster and cheaper from this point on, but a $2500 64 core 128 GB RAM machine from January 2024 that can build a complete distro in a couple of days isn't bad at all.