7 ms·
Learning projects like this is about to get a lot less accessible due to the extreme tariffs and elimination of the de minimis exemption. Take that BOM and mult
by Aurornis 2y ago
Learning projects like this is about to get a lot less accessible due to the extreme tariffs and elimination of the de minimis exemption. Take that BOM and multiply it by 2X or 3X depending on the source and how many different shipments arrived.
I can’t tell you how depressing it is to go from having access to cheap learning materials for introducing kids (and adults) to electronics, and now it’s being taxed away in the name of improving the US competitiveness or something. Total footgun.
- jillyboel 2y agoFor Americans, that is.
- godelski 2y agoDoesn't change the fact that the advice is still beneficial. At worst you still have a good history of the effect of these tariffs. I'd call the tariffs the second death of hardware though. The first was when we killed all the parts stores. That was a slower death, coupled with the loss of right to repair. But we've been making big strides in that domain, so I hope we can undo that death. If we can also undo the dumb tariffs too then ironically we might have a chance to bring back hardware which somewhat seems inline with what that party (claims to/pretends to) wants.
- macintux 2y agoA new Radio Shack dealer just opened in a rural area, with an emphasis on radio (it's near an off-roading park), and your comment reminded me what terrible timing this is for them. Such a cruel twist. https://tekshack.com https://tekshack.com
- robocat 2y ago> we killed all the parts stores We ran out of people buying from parts stores - hobby electronics became less popular. Eras of hobbies: Mechanical Chemical Electronic Computer hardware Computer software [What's now?]
- godelski 2y agoI'm not aware of the chemical hobby era. And as I watched it happen, the electronic hobby era died at the same time as the mechanical. Most of the mechanical one was cars. It happened as it became harder to repair things. The barrier to entry increased, the availability of parts decreased with decreasing demand. It is a negative feedback loop.
- robocat 2y agoMechanical: I was thinking more Meccano and home built steam engines - cars came later. Chemical: I was thinking chemistry sets and the age when Chemistry was geeky cool (Du Pont, Uncle Tungsten). My grand father was a structural engineer, my father studied chemical engineering, I studied electronic engineering (but got a job programming). So perhaps I was thinking more of the frontier of engineering shifting rather than technical hobbies. It would be interesting to look at geeky hobby adverts in a magazine over time and see how the advert focus shifted.
- godelski 2y ago> I was thinking chemistry sets I don't think those chemistry sets were ever widely popular. We see them and look back thinking how cool and dangerous, but every one I'm aware of was insanely expensive. Same with the atomic kit. On the other hand, most mechanical things were relatively cheap. Cars were worked on since cars existed. People also worked on everything in their homes. There was the tradesman who takes a specific skill like being able to fix a washing machine, but a lot of these people had hobbies of building and making. So we have a direct connection to the death of the repairman and death of the handyman. These were quite popular things even up through the 90's. You'll even see this in shows and movies. Plus, you forgot the most popular hobby of them all: woodworking. Still alive, but nowhere near as popular as a few decades ago.
- helpfulContrib 2y ago> Learning projects like this is about to get a lot less accessible due to the extreme tariffs and elimination of the de minimis exemption. Only for Americans, though. Plenty of kids in third world countries can benefit from the technology involved in this project - and will. That is a net gain for the world, in spite of what America is doing to itself.
- GardenLetter27 2y agoYeah, it's already been like this in a lot of Europe where there is no De Minimis exemption. E.g. in Sweden, PostNord has a government granted monopoly and charge about $20 per imported package, which adds up fast. It really sucks, free trade and competition is what we need.
- relaxing 2y agoWhy didn’t someone just set up domestic manufacturing for those hobbyist parts?
- Zigurd 2y agoComparative advantage
- yapyap 2y agoIs this sarcastic? It does read like it. I’ll take it on face value: Cause domestic manufacturing for hobbyist parts is not economically viable
- idiotsecant 2y agoI wonder how that additional cost breaks down. Is it mostly cost of labor? Supply chain access? Environmental controls and compliance? Other overheads not present in China? Is economically viable production possible in the US?
- Aurornis 2y agoFor hobby parts? It’s not viable because you’d be setting up a manufacturing operation to serve a small number of people. The fixed costs would be so high you’d never get it back. Contrast that with someone setting up an operation to serve the entire world, a market 1000 times larger than many localities.
- michaelt 2y agoIf you're smart enough to design and build a LIDAR, you're smart enough to make $200,000 a year working for the big adtech companies. You'd need an enormous hobbyist robotics market to be able to sustain a business making and selling $60 LIDARs with that wage bill.
- lmz 2y agoLocal warehousing / distribution centers? The US is not short of space.
- mlsu 2y agoI’ve been jokingly calling my electronics hobby of the past few years “getting my EE degree.” Putting together PCBs, reading and replicating schematics, designing my own hardware. It’s been really fun and has paid dividends for my career (firmware). If the US is interested in bringing knowledge of manufacturing back this is a very very bad way to do it. How many undergrad projects are now impossible because the BOM has quadrupled? How many future mechanical/electrical engineers are not going to get into hardware because of this? It’s all going to be gone. I’ve spent roughly $1200 last year having PCBs and ordering sensors etc. that goes to $4000 with these executive orders. It’s insanity, pure insanity.
- A4ET8a8uTh0_v2 2y agoThere is a small part of that wonders if it is by design given how much it exposes a person to the inner workings of the things they use daily, but then I bring myself back to reality. I sincerely doubt now there is a real long term plan at work here. At best it is all situational and reactive ( tactical, maybe, but not strategic thinking at work ).
- KumaBear 2y agoThere is no plan it’s instincts. Complete devoid of actual thoughts.
- godelski 2y agoBoth can be true. There was incentive to prevent people from building, repairing, and modifying things. It need not be malicious with the intent to prevent people from getting into the field. Instead it only need be naïve and selfish. Sony suing because people put Linux on their PS3. Remember these people will also try to sue white hat hackers who submit vulnerability reports. It's not a long term plan to destroy, instead it's an extremely short sighted and naïve plan to build a wall and protect. You'll find that naïve shortsightedness often is indistinguishable from malicious foresight, when looked back upon. So remember how to stop it: think of the little things, the compounding effects. There's always costs and trades being made, there's no free lunch. As the world gets more advanced it gets more complex. The more complex it gets the more those little subtle things matter