3 ms·
Huh, TIL the Constitution doesn’t require Congressional districts. A state could technically switch to a model like this for assigning representatives at large.
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
Huh, TIL the Constitution doesn’t require Congressional districts. A state could technically switch to a model like this for assigning representatives at large.
- rqtwteye 2y agoThe two main parties in the US are way too happy with the status for any change to happen. If there is one thing they hate more than each other it's another party.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> two main parties in the US are way too happy with the status for any change to happen California could make this change by referendum.
- googlryas 2y agoYes but Ds and Rs will come out in force to rally their base against it. That's what happened in Colorado this past election.
- int_19h 2y agoMany states could, but why would they if other states retain a system that disproportionally skews sits towards one party?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> why would they if other states retain a system that disproportionally skews sits towards one party? Because your constituents are better represented. California strikes me as a potent place to do this because I could see a constitutional amendment passing at the ballot box.
- int_19h 2y agoBut they aren't better represented unless everyone else does the same. Suppose California were to do it, resulting in a proportional allocation of seats in the House for its delegation. If this causes the House to swing from Democratic majority to Republican majority, the net effect is the opposite of what most Californians wanted. Don't get me wrong, I get the point that it is a more fair and equitable way of doing things, and in principle, I agree. But if you play fair at a table where everybody else cheats, you lose. My state (WA) also has referendums, and if such a proposal would come up, I would absolutely vote against it - unless it was some kind of interstate compact where another similarly-sized red state were to implement the same reform at the same time.
- Taikonerd 2y agoI’ve had this exact thought: that Texas and California should have some sort of compact to do it at the same time. That would be a boon for Texas Democrats (of whom there are many) and California Republicans (ditto).
- dragonwriter 2y ago> California could make this change by referendum. No, it could not, because Article I, Section 3 (emphasis added): "The times, places and manner of holding elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in each state by the legislature thereof; but the Congress may at any time by law make or alter such regulations, except as to the places of choosing Senators." (the last part of that about choosing Senators has its effect eliminated by the 17th Amendment, but that isn't important here.) And Congress has exercised its authority in U.S. Code Title 2, Section 2c (emphasis added): "In each State entitled in the Ninety-first Congress or in any subsequent Congress thereafter to more than one Representative under an apportionment made pursuant to the provisions of section 2a(a) of this title, there shall be established by law a number of districts equal to the number of Representatives to which such State is so entitled, and Representatives shall be elected only from districts so established, no district to elect more than one Representative (except that a State which is entitled to more than one Representative and which has in all previous elections elected its Representatives at Large may elect its Representatives at Large to the Ninety-first Congress)."
- whatshisface 2y agoI don't think that is actually true. It is in part redistricting that lead to the ascendancy of extremism, by putting all of the strategic emphasis on the primaries in uncontested constituencies.
- dragonwriter 2y ago"Redistricting" isn't a new recent thing, it is a process done by state legislatures to state and federal legislative district every decade that has been used for both personal and partisan advantage since the founding; the word "gerrymander" was coined in criticism of a particular instance in 1812.
- whatshisface 2y agoI think there is a primary-related problem going on right now that could change historically held positions on the value to financial backers interests of uncontested general elections.
- smitty1e 2y ago1. The original 1787 apportionment would result in a House of Representatives of ~30k members[1]. 2. That's obviously unwieldy, and so we haven't had a bump in seats since ... 1910. 3. 'Factions' were viewed dimly by the Founders. I would argue in favor of two immediate changes: - Term limits for everything, including shorter max civil service careers. Capitol Hill, like any compost heap, benefits from regular turning. - A "bidder bunch" rule, whereby if Congress can't manage its key function--that of producing a budget--then none of these goofs (even the ones I admire) get to run for their seat when next up. There are copious talented alternative people to put on ballots. Do your job or face corporate punishment, say I. [1] https://thirty-thousand.org/ https://thirty-thousand.org/
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> A "bidder bunch" rule, whereby if Congress can't manage its key function--that of producing a budget--then none of these goofs (even the ones I admire) get to run for their seat when next up This creates an obvious and huge perverse incentive to throw a wrench into the works any time you want a do-over.
- smitty1e 2y agoAnd copious peer pressure not to be That Guy.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> copious peer pressure not to be That Guy How? You don’t think you could find Democrats, today, who wouldn’t roll the dice on a new Congress? The proposal essentially gives a narrow minority the ability to call no confidence.
- smitty1e 2y ago...and self-immolate. You don't work that hard to get elected and then piss it away.
- paul7986 2y agoWe need another one whose motto is "Country Over Party," and is backed by locked down solid ethics that always follows right vs. wrong with right (not politically right or left) guiding everything this entity stands for and is guided by. Present day it's neither party standing for right vs. wrong it's the b.s. Right (politically) vs. Left(politically) or Left vs. Right! Gross, there's neither party today cares about right vs. wrong or integrity just divide the country further!!!
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> locked down solid ethics that always follows right vs. wrong with right (not politically right or left) guiding everything this entity stands for and is guided by As in? People can legitimately disagree about what is right and wrong, or what even falls on a moral continuum. Nailing down a moment’s broad truth is among the most revered roles in any society.
- paul7986 2y agoCan they ... poll a group of people (right and lefties) and ask... If vandalizing a Telsa and vandalizing the US Capitol are both wrong and my focus is only the act of vandalism in asking this question. Overall, both acts are clear cut wrong! Those who refuse to say both are wrong their brains are driven now by political emotional mind control babble where they've thrown out knowing and standing for right over wrong.
- lostdog 2y agoWhat are your feelings on vandalizing shipments of tea?
- paul7986 2y agoNot driven by feelings or political emotional babble as it's hard to believe anything when it comes to politics. Im all about clear cut right from wrong and clear cut facts, as well that was a wrong act! It was something that led to the revolutionary war, which is a clear cut fact! I guess you showed that your mind is driven/controlled by political emotional babble & narratives made up by the right (tho maybe your left or an independent who leans right) & it's media (right or left .. all make up narratives) you consume. But I don't want to jump to conclusions.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThere was a time when senators were not elected by popular vote. The constitution leaves a lot of this up to the states and just by convention they mostly do the same thing.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoThe nexus of stupidity in our Republic has less often been the Senate; I’m unkeen to mess with it. The House is a mess. So is SCOTUS. My proposal for the latter is redefining the Supreme Court as one drawn by lot from appellate judges for each case. This not only solves the appointment lottery. It also incentivises expanding the judiciary, which we need to do, and removes the modern perversion which is the Supreme Court just not bothering with controversial cases. Most importantly, the edits to SCOTUS can be done by the Congress. The edits to the House can be done by the states. (EDIT: Nah.) Senate requires a Constitutional amendment; that window isn’t open at this time.
- lostdog 2y agoHere are my proposals: The Senate is elected similar to a parliament from other countries. Country-wide votes for parties, with proportional representation. It would balance out the regionality of the House. The Supreme Court justices serve terms of 12-16 years. Each presidential candidate must select 2 supreme court picks at least 4 weeks before the election, and whoever wins has their picks placed on the court. (After their term, supreme court justices retire to the DC circuit).
- brendoelfrendo 2y agoThis is something that was defined in the Constitution, however. Article 1, Section 3 called for the selection of Senators by state legislatures. This is superseded by the 17th Amendment, and calls for Senators to be elected by the people of their states. This is important to understand, because the 17th Amendment is an on-again-off-again political issue; Republicans have, in recent history, held most state legislatures, so repealing the 17th Amendment would basically guarantee that the Republican Party would control at least one house of Congress for the foreseeable future, and give the party greater control over who is selected to the office.
- dragonwriter 2y ago> Huh, TIL the Constitution doesn’t require Congressional districts. True, but... > A state could technically switch to a model like this for assigning representatives at large. No, it can't because Congress itself is given the overriding power in the Constitution to regulate the "time, place, and manner" of elections to the House, and has exercised it to prohibit at-large districts (many times, with lax enforcement, but the most recent mandate, adopted in 1967, has not had the compliance problems the earlier ones often did.) The 1967 mandate was adopted under the dual specter of a some states failing to resolve districting controversies and potentially facing judicially-imposed at-large districts and several states having used at-large districts for non-federal elections to effectively disenfranchise Black voters and concerns that the same might be done to Congressional delegations as a way of blunting the impacts of new rules like the Voting Rights Act. Additional detail at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43739929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43739929
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoAppreciated as always!
- nabla9 2y agoThere is a federal law. There has been numerous proposals in the Congress to get rid of it, but they don't get ratified because two parties like the status quo. People will have to make it an issue.
- wqaatwt 2y agoOr just use a sane system like STV with multi member districts.
- 986aignan 2y agoYou might need some kind of MMP part if you want it to be truly proportional. If the voters can only rank about ten candidates before it gets unwieldy, that would give an effective 9% absolute threshold. A party that gains 8% support everywhere would get no candidates elected. Here's a paper by Markus Schulze proposing such a method: https://aso.icann.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/schulze4.pdf https://aso.icann.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/schulze4.pd... He uses some very large districts, but it should work for smaller districts too.
- wqaatwt 2y agoYes, STV is non perfect but IMHO it’s worth it to not have party lists. Also one of the main criticism of people opposed to proportional system is the lack of direct representation. STV solves that and even is superior to FPTP in that way because you are more likely to find a MP who is more sympathetic towards your cause/views if there are e.g. 3-5 members in your district. Of course I’m not talking about the system proposed in the paper your linked, but rather about how MMP works in Germany. You get both part list and FPTP style party appointed candidates.