5 ms·
> Let the reader decide. There is no "the" reader. There's a statistical cloud of readers with highly variant preferences. You guys need to understand that th
by dang 2y ago
> Let the reader decide.
There is no "the" reader. There's a statistical cloud of readers with highly variant preferences.
You guys need to understand that the community is divided about these questions. I don't mean divided politically on partisan lines (though that as well), I mean divided around what sorts of topics are the best fit for the site.
There are those who feel like each letter to each government agency is a major new story that obviously deserves frontpage time; and there are those who feel like HN is overrun with this sort of thing already. Ditto for every major topic including, as you say, AI: some feel like there's too much, some feel like there's not enough.
There's no HN user, including me, who's satisfied with the balance of stories on the front page. The more passionate you (I don't mean you personally, but all of us) are about a particular topic, the more it feels like the topic is being unfairly and outrageously suppressed, whether by user flags or the mods or both.
This is ultimately all coming from the fundamentals of how HN works—from its initial conditions, if you like—and those aren't likely to change. Feelings about it do uptick during times of political intensity, such as now, but the underlying phenomenon is consistent and has been for many years.
Edit: here's me making a similar point from 5 years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22644521 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22644521, in case anyone was thinking this is a new phenomenon...
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoFlagging does not remove stories. It does not always result in killng them to "[dead]" status. It may not even demote stories off page 1. Flagging is not a effective solution to the submission of stories that anyone believes are inappropriate for HN, i.e., it does not stop further submissions on similar topics. They still get submitted. If anything, flagging may be a means of stopping discussion. If it works. Meanwhile "[flagged]" status was removed from this story. Discussion continues.
- dang 2y agoI think I agree with every one of these sentences! Were you in disagreement with something I wrote? The tug-of-war between upvotes and flags is always happening on HN and is a core part of how the software and the community function.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoNo disagreement. Not asking for anything to change. Just trying to understand the flagging phenomenon. Given that there is no way to downvote a story the way that one can downvote a comment, perhaps some people use flagging as a way to "downvote" stories.