6 ms·
'Cosmic radio' detector could discover dark matter within 15 years
- josefritzishere 2y agoIncreasingly theorists disagree that dark matter exists, as most of it's "proof" is already reductive. Can we discover things that dont exist? Reductively, yes.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ck2 2y ago"15 years" seems like an oddly specific number? https://m.xkcd.com/678/ https://m.xkcd.com/678/ But invention of gravity-wave detectors (laser interferometers) have been the most exciting thing and can't wait for them to build the space version, so maybe go for it? Won't be funded in US this decade though, they are even cancelling space-telescopes ready to launch, sigh
- chriskanan 2y agoFrom an outsider's perspective who has studied the history of science, it does feel a bit like the majority of the cosmology community refuses to consider alternative explanations that may also be consistent with observations but don't assume dark matter. For example, this relativistic MOND-inspired theory is supposedly consistent with observations from CMB and gravitational lensing: https://physics.aps.org/articles/v14/143 https://physics.aps.org/articles/v14/143 There is also Jonathan Oppenheim's body of work on stochastic spacetime which supposedly accounts for these observations without needing dark matter (and it also doesn't need dark energy): https://www.theguardian.com/science/2024/mar/09/controversial-new-theory-of-gravity-rules-out-need-for-dark-matter https://www.theguardian.com/science/2024/mar/09/controversia... It feels like the community is stuck in dogma, and is in need of a paradigm shift. I'd like to see more effort and funding towards testing alternative theories. I'd also argue strongly for more investment in space telescopes that could further our understanding, especially given how much JWST has already provided evidence against the standard model of cosmology. About $6 to $11B have been spent trying to detect dark matter over the past 30 years or so, and nothing has turned up. Investing in testing alternatives and efforts to gather data that would help refine hypotheses seems like money well-spent to me.
- pavel_lishin 2y ago> The AQ is designed so its frequency can be transmitted into space, a frequency that would match with the axion. When it identifies and 'tunes in' to that frequency, it will emit very small amounts of light. AQ operates at the highest terahertz frequencies, which many researchers believe to be the most promising place to look for axions. Can someone explain this using an analogy that makes sense?
- pyinstallwoes 2y agoSympathetic resonance. Two guitars in a room, pluck the A string of one, the other A string will vibrate. “Spooky action at a distance”
- slow_typist 2y agoIf that is what they wanted to say they did a very bad job. And spooky action at a distance is a term related to quantum entanglement, which has probably nothing to do with the phenomenon they tried to describe here.
- evanb 2y agoYou're right; this is nothing to do with spooky action at a distance. But sympathetic response, or resonance, is how this device would work---just like a radio. Axions couple to electromagnetism; by listening in on different frequencies we can see if there is any "cosmic signal being broadcast" (meaning: axions suffusing the galaxy); the frequency of the signal corresponds to the mass of the axion. In that sense, the search for resonances is a classic approach in particle physics; various particles were discovered by finding increased signals at particular collision energies. What's different here is that it isn't a resonance in a collision cross-section but an axion --> electromagnetism conversion.
- staplung 2y agoAny chance this could lead to a resonance cascade? I saw some documentary where that happened at a remote corporate facility in the desert somewhere...Dark Table maybe. I was surprised to see such heavy use of a crowbar at a place doing advanced physics. ;-)
- bryanrasmussen 2y agohow long would it go without finding dark matter before physicists would get worried?
- evanb 2y agoThere are appealing theoretical reasons to think an axion exists [strong-cp]; there are appealing theoretical reasons to think an axion does not exist [chiral]. What this device can do is explore. They may come up empty because dark matter is not axions; they may come up empty because dark matter is axions but the physical parameters are surprising. But people agree that if axions comprise any sizeable fraction of dark matter then its parameters should be between this and that, and this device can find it there. [strong-cp] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_CP_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strong_CP_problem [chiral] https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.02024 https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.02024
- justlikereddit 2y agoThey'll just do what they've done for the past twenty years. Adjust the theory to make it darker, lighter and more nebulous. The end station of dark matter is that "we know it's real because computer models but due to a fluke there's no dark matter in the solar system so we can't detect it".
- dventimi 2y agoI can't agree with this. No scientist says, "we know it's real because computer models but due to a fluke there's no dark matter in the solar system so we can't detect it." No scientist says, "we know it's real..." about anything. What scientists say is something like, "so far this theory has not been ruled out by evidence." So far, the theory of Dark Matter has not yet been ruled out by numerous attempts to do so along multiple independents lines of observational evidence: - galaxy rotation curves - galaxy cluster dynamics - gravitational lensing - the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation - large-scale structure - Baryon Acoustic Oscillations - X-ray emission in galaxy clusters - galaxy cluster collisions - mass-to-light ratios That's a tall order for any competing theories. They're welcome to try, of course, but so far none have succeeded.
- fn-mote 2y agoWhat is the proposed cost of this exploration? Is this more big dollar physics? Will the device see anything if the conjecture is wrong? I have gotten skeptical of these “could be amazing” researches - I suspect success in academia is PR and funding as much as actual good ideas and it’s hard for an outsider to know the difference (or care?).
- sightbroke 2y ago> I suspect success in academia is PR and funding as much as actual good ideas... That is kind of just how the job works unfortunately. Unless the way research funding changes (I don't know how) you need money to do research and to get that money you need to be good at selling an idea.
- resource0x 2y agoDark matter is a pseudo-scientific variant of the "God of the gaps". Rather of acknowledging an obvious (default) assumption that the laws of Universe (including all "constants") depend on local conditions, the community prefers spending inordinate amounts of money on nebulous ideas.
- vihren 2y agoWe do have a pretty substansive evidence that dark matter exists: from the cosmic background radiation, gravitational lensing, galaxy formation simulations, galaxy rotation curves, etc. Why is it so hard for people to believe that there are some particles that are not interacting with electromagnetism that we haven't detected directly yet? It's not even a precedent, the neutrino is just like that. I guess the name "dark" matter was a mistake because it implies something weird, when in fact it just means whatever this is, doesn't have electric (or chromo) charge.
- dventimi 2y agoI agree with you. "Dark Matter" (and "Dark Energy") are colorful (colorless?) names that I think helped these theories diffuse into the popular consciousness at a time when popular interest in science was at a high-water mark (remember when "chaos theory" was fashionable?). As I mentioned in another comment recently (it feels like a "Dark Matter" or "Dark Energy" headline trends on HN almost every day), this coded these theories as "exotic" or "weird" as you say, and invited speculation about Dark Matter and even an urge to overturn it among laypeople who equated "exotic" with "tendentious." But, as you suggest, personally I don't regard Dark Matter as all that exotic. We already know about some species of "dark matter": the neutrino is one, and before that there was the neutron. Oh, well. I suppose there will be another episode on HN in a day or so.
- notfed 2y agoHad we named it "invisible matter", perhaps not as much controversy would surround it.
- fasteddie31003 2y agoAm I wrong to assume that science that is harder to prove will have less impact on human wellbeing? Electricity is easy to run experiments on and prove, meaning humans can manipulate it for our benefits easy. However, the Higgs Boson was extremely difficult to prove and I see no way that it could ever benefit humanity's wellbeing. Now how could humans improve our wellbeing by manipulating dark matter?
- sightbroke 2y agoI hope I am not wrong in imagining you may consider grouping quantum mechanics (QM) with research that has no way to ever benefit "humanity's well-being". (Even if I'd argue like art pure science & maths benefit humanity's well-being for it's own sake). This is relevant since accelerators like which was used for the Higgs Boson discovery are also used in general QM research: https://www.energy.gov/science/doe-explainsquantum-mechanics https://www.energy.gov/science/doe-explainsquantum-mechanics > Quantum mechanics led to the development of things like lasers, light-emitting diodes, transistors, medical imaging, electron microscopes, and a host of other modern devices. Additionally, it's ironic that you mentioned the Higgs-Boson, while perhaps many years before it's discovery and maybe not research CERN was anticipating in doing it did come up with the first webserver: https://home.cern/science/computing/birth-web/short-history-web https://home.cern/science/computing/birth-web/short-history-...
- DerekL 2y ago*well-being
- dventimi 2y agoYou're not "wrong" per se as you're entitled to your views, but a fairly common alternative view goes something like this. Yes, while we sometimes do pursue scientific inquiry for its practical application to the betterment of humanity, we also recognize the value of scientific inquiry simply for expanding the endowment of human knowledge about the world. That is an "innate good". Moreover, if history is any guide, it's sometimes or even often difficult to predict what practical applications will or won't emerge from any given scientific endeavor. In the case of Dark Matter, it may not be exactly the case that we will ever directly manipulate it in any scientific application. However, it may be the case that by grappling with Dark Matter we will refine and deepen our understanding of the fundamental laws of nature, and that will unlock future practical applications. Then there is the topic of "human capital": training people to be scientists trains cadres of people with strong skills in science, math, engineering, and computer science, which is an investment in that human capital. Often, they're well-equipped to go on to fruitful careers outside of their initial field of inquiry, producing innovations that benefit humanity. Finally, if it's a matter of cost, many people feel that the societal cost (e.g. federal expenditures on science) are puny compared to other things which I need not name here. Consequently, "basic science" which includes fundamental physics and the study of Dark Matter, is always a great investment for society. Or something like that...that's my understanding of how that argument goes. Make of it what you will.
- BugsJustFindMe 2y agoA headline using the word "could" implies "but probably won't". Report on things when they happen. Don't speculate.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoWell, what's actually happening is, some people have proposed an experimental apparatus that is actually buildable. That's something that might be worth reporting.
- rzz3 2y agoI’ve always felt like (as neither a mathematician nor a physicist) that “dark matter” is simply just something that suddenly makes a math problem work to model the universe-—and that in reality, that math problem just doesn’t work. Is my theory even _possible_ here, or am I missing something. Really fundamental?
- Hikikomori 2y agoWell you have things like the bullet cluster that can't be explained by math being wrong.
- naasking 2y agoOf course they can. The whole reason you think they can't is just more math.
- luma 2y agoDark matter is a proposition put forward to explain observations. It’s not a result of pretty math, it’s the result of a lot of different observations which don’t align with the current math unless you stick something like dark matter into it.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoThere are pretty math pathways to dark matter, though, and they tend to be more compelling reasons to believe there is something that fits the notion of a particle that we can't detect (or is very difficult to detect). Specifically, bariogenesis calculations, given the current standard model, actually require dark matter--it's the label we've arrived at--as a result. Observations led to the hypothesis, calculations led to more evidence.
- jvanderbot 2y agoSo yes. It is a missing term that balances our models of physics against observations. The implications of that term and hypothesis as to its physical reality are what we are trying to figure out right?
- westurner 2y agoFrom https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42376759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42376759 : > FWIU this Superfluid Quantum Gravity rejects dark matter and/or negative mass in favor of supervaucuous supervacuum, but I don't think it attempts to predict other phases and interactions like Dark fluid theory? From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42371946 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42371946 : > Dark fluid: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_fluid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_fluid : >> Dark fluid goes beyond dark matter and dark energy in that it predicts a continuous range of attractive and repulsive qualities under various matter density cases. Indeed, special cases of various other gravitational theories are reproduced by dark fluid, e.g. inflation, quintessence, k-essence, f(R), Generalized Einstein-Aether f(K), MOND, TeVeS, BSTV, etc. Dark fluid theory also suggests new models, such as a certain f(K+R) model that suggests interesting corrections to MOND that depend on redshift and density