3 ms·
That's a pretty reductionist view. Even maximally pro-IP laws usually have significant carve-outs for derivative works or other scenarios; see for example the U
by lxgr 2y ago
That's a pretty reductionist view. Even maximally pro-IP laws usually have significant carve-outs for derivative works or other scenarios; see for example the US's extensive "fair use" doctrine.
- cratermoon 2y agoYou're begging the question: it's not established the LLM models are derivative or fair use under those laws. Also, the de facto state of fair use in the US is not what I would call "extensive".
- andybak 2y agoDo I have to repeat "copyright violation isn't theft" on every post for eternity?
- delichon 2y agoIf I make copies of Project Hail Mary and sell them at half price, do you think it's obvious that should be legal? I think Andy Weir would have a decent moral as well as legal case for theft.