3 ms·
There are a couple of these concepts --- TOFU (key continuity) is one, PAKEs are another, pinning a third --- that sort of float around and captivate people bec
by tptacek 2y ago
There are a couple of these concepts --- TOFU (key continuity) is one, PAKEs are another, pinning a third --- that sort of float around and captivate people because they seem easy to reason about, but are (with the exception of Magic Wormhole) not all that useful in the real world. It'd be interesting to flesh out the complete list of them.
The thing to think in comparing SSH to TLS is how frequent counterparty introductions are. New counterparties in SSH are relatively rare. Key continuity still needlessly exposes you to an grave attack in SSH, but really all cryptographic protocol attacks are rare compared to the simpler, more effective stuff like phishing, so it doesn't matter. New counterparties in TLS happen all the time; continuity doesn't make any sense there.
- hedora 2y agoThere are ~ 200 entries in my password manager. Maybe 25 are important. Pinning their certs would meaningfully reduce the transport layer attack surface for those accounts.
- tptacek 2y agoYes, these ideas bubble around because they all seem reasonable on their face. I was a major fan of pinning!