3 ms·
"A naturopathic "doctor" does not even attempt to use science, at least not consistently. Naturopathic medicine is feel-good mumbo jumbo. Some of it works (your
by Alex3917 18y ago
"A naturopathic "doctor" does not even attempt to use science, at least not consistently. Naturopathic medicine is feel-good mumbo jumbo. Some of it works (your guacamole example), some of it is utterly wrong (homeopathy) but still used. Naturopathic medicine does not, even in principle, attempt to use science-based medicine."
First of all, naturopathy and homeopathy have nothing in common except for that they sound kind of similar. Kind of like java and javascript.
Second, naturopathic medicine is science based. Of the four naturopathic schools in the country, two rely almost entirely on the same set of peer reviewed literature that traditional medicine relies on. The only difference is they are primarily interested in the effect of plants, not specific chemicals from plants.
Also, you may well be right on the stats, I haven't studied them closely.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoAccording to wikipedia, homeopathy and acupuncture are taught at all six accredited naturopathic schools in North America. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturopathy#Modalities http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturopathy#Modalities Incidentally, the effect of plants is the result of the interaction of the chemicals inside the plants with the chemicals in the body. Willow bark reduces pain because it has aspirin in it. If, as you say, naturopaths are just practicing scientific medicine but using plants rather than chemicals, all they are doing is adding a new source of errors to traditional medicine. Rather than giving a patient 200mg of aspirin, you give them a plant which is likely to have about 200mg of aspirin in it (more or less).
- Alex3917 18y ago"If, as you say, naturopaths are just practicing scientific medicine but using plants rather than chemicals, all they are doing is adding a new source of errors to traditional medicine." The theory is that when plants have powerful drugs in them, they usually also have other mechanisms to prevent those drugs from being toxic. The idea being that eating the whole plant is often less harmful than taking a massive dose of one specific chemical. For example, people die every year by OD'ing on Red Bull or caffeine pills, but hardly anyone ever dies by drinking too much green tea. Why? Green tea has lots of acid and other stuff that'll make you throw up long before you can drink enough to kill yourself. There are many other things that traditional doctors won't tell you take because they are illegal. For example, coca tea is far less likely to have nasty side effects than the altitude pills your doctor prescribes you, but your doctor isn't allowed to prescribe you coca tea because it's illegal. And of course most doctors also accept bribes from the pharmaceutical industry. Every few months we see huge articles in the NY Times to this effect. Think of how many times your traditional doctor has advised you to take a plant-- probably never. Because plants aren't patentable and the pharma industry isn't there giving your doctor free trips to hawaii if he tells you to smoke weed for your bone cancer instead of taking some dangerous chemical compound. Of course the dosages are a lot more variable than if you just got a pill, but that's why you go back to your naturopathic doctor every week or so instead of just taking a fixed dosage and going back if it gets worse. The whole idea is that the medicine is based around what makes you feel better, not what works for the average person as compared to a placebo.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoIs there conclusive evidence that in general, it is better to eat the whole plant rather than just a controlled dose of the active chemical? As for the illegality of various drugs (coca tea, pot), I agree our legal system is fucked up. Not sure how naturopathy helps here, unless naturopaths routinely break the law. "Of course the dosages are a lot more variable than if you just got a pill, but that's why you go back to your naturopathic doctor every week or so..." How does that help? More frequent control does not reduce the noise in the inputs. The naturopathic shaman doesn't know what he gave you. He has no way to know if he should give you two plants vs one, or if the plant he gave you just has an abnormally low dose of the chemical. "The whole idea is that the medicine is based around what makes you feel better, not what works for the average person as compared to a placebo." And that's why it is unscientific. All you know is how you felt before, and how you feel now. You can't know the cause of your change in feeling, except in a randomized trial.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Is there conclusive evidence that in general, it is better to eat the whole plant rather than just a controlled dose of the active chemical?" It's different for every problem. If you want to take aspirin then it's better just to take aspirin because the compound alone causes less stomach irritation. However if you want to take resveretrol then it's (probably) better to take the pill with a glass of red wine. The problem is that allopathic doctors are will NEVER prescribe taking the whole plant, even if peer reviewed research has shown it to be clearly better than a synthetic alternative. "The naturopathic shaman doesn't know what he gave you." Yes, they do. They look up what could be causing your health problems in peer reviewed journals and then try different things. With the depression example, there are five or six different underlying things that can cause a serotonin imbalance that creates depression. With allopathic medicine they just give you SSRIs, which fix the serotonin problem without ever fixing what's causing it. With naturopathic doctors they will actually do blood tests and thyroid tests to see if you have too much or too little of something. Even though thyroid problems are extremely common, allopathic doctors will almost never do a thyroid test unless you explicitly ask for one. "And that's why it is unscientific. All you know is how you felt before, and how you feel now. You can't know the cause of your change in feeling, except in a randomized trial." Except they are starting with drugs that have been clinically proven in randomized trials. They are just going back and adjusting the dosage afterward, unlike allopathic doctors who will just keep you on the dose that has been shown to be most effective for the "average" person. In many ways this is even better than the process used by allopathic medicine.
- maximilian 18y agoBut does a naturopath actually give you some willow bark to chew on? From my experience, it is just a plant derived active ingredient. Kinda like the difference between "Natural Flavors" and "Artificial Flavors" in foods. The active chemical is identical, but one comes from a plant, and one was derived in a lab. In the end it doesn't matter too much because they both end up pretty much as identical chemicals in a test tube. I mostly know of "naturopaths" who are into the homeopathic "mumbo jumbo" so I'm surprised to find out that naturopathic schools attempt to follow the journals. I kinda think that there are good "doctors" (be it traditional or not) who are up on their science and listen past the 30 seconds they meet you. And then there are regular doctors who don't listen enough and misdiagnose on a regular basis and naturopaths who are into a lot of hand-wavy "medicine" that wouldn't hold much salt if properly tested, but because of the placebo effect find themselves still employed and even convinced of their skills.
- Alex3917 18y ago"I kinda think that there are good "doctors" (be it traditional or not) who are up on their science and listen past the 30 seconds they meet you." The best naturopathic doctors are only doing what an allopathic doctor would do if they were more competent. As it stands, the vast majority of allopathic doctors can't name a single medical journal article published in the last year-- not surprising considering how low job satisfaction among doctors is. Certainly not all naturopathic doctors are good, most are basically quacks. But the best naturopathic doctors, the ones who are super intelligent and intrinsically motivated, tend to be better than the allopathic alternative only because they don't have this huge bureaucracy telling them how to do their jobs and killing their intrinsic motivation to do a good job.