3 ms·
> Roman elites made themselves wealthy through service to the empire, but they were expected to use that wealth to serve the public Roman elites made their big
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Roman elites made themselves wealthy through service to the empire, but they were expected to use that wealth to serve the public
Roman elites made their big bucks through governorships (corruption) and campaign (conquest).
> There is no expectation, for example, that a billionaire should provide welfare or build a stadium out of his own pocket and provide free entertainment to the masses
Philanthropy is absolutely an expectation, though I agree the noblesse oblige8 has decayed.
> rich in many countries are no longer paying much in the way of taxes*
Relatively, yes. In aggregate, the rich pay the lion’s share of taxes in the West.
> It's a recipe for revolution
To the extent we are, it’s towards an imperial transition where the elites take a greater share.
- roenxi 2y ago> Philanthropy is absolutely an expectation, though I agree the noblesse oblige8 has decayed. Arguably nobless oblige has been embedded in the legal system. The expectation is there and expressed in the tax code. The philosophical process was the elites sat down, codified their obligations and called it "our taxes". Ironically, big chunks of beloch's post is pointing out that billionaires have a huge amount of social responsibility under the modern system. They are expected to provide welfare and build stadiums. Just not administer the process.
- redczar 2y agoThey aren’t building the stadiums when those stadiums are paid for with public money that they contribute relatively less to.
- graemep 2y ago> Relatively, yes. In aggregate, the rich pay the lion’s share of taxes in the West. Depends on your definition of rich, your definition of "lion's share" and where in the west. In the UK 18% of government revenue comes from national insurance - which is an income tax only on earned income, and charged at a higher rate on people in lower tax bands. Another 17% is from VAT. Yes, rich people will buy more stuff subject to VAT, but a much lower proportion of their incomes, and it falls a lot as incomes go up. I would guess it pretty much plateaus for the super-rich. About 4% comes from council tax, which is per household with an adjustment for the value of the property you live in, and a that adjustment if far from proportionate and there is a maximum level that is far below the typical value of the residences of the rich. There is a penalty for owning multiple houses for personal use. Again, would plateau at some point. About another 5% comes from fuel and tobacco alcohol duties. Rich people might have bigger cars, but they are also more likely to have EVs, and they do not drink more alcohol AFAIK and are less likely to smoke. Only 23% comes from income tax which is the only clearly progressive tax - and that becomes less clear when you leave for exemptions and the greater ability of the rich to avoid it. It would take a detailed analysis to figure this out. Sources: https://ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-key-questions/where-does-government-get-its-money https://ifs.org.uk/taxlab/taxlab-key-questions/where-does-go... https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-8513/ https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-...
- 9dev 2y ago> Yes, rich people will buy more stuff subject to VAT, but a much lower proportion of their incomes, and it falls a lot as incomes go up. Doubt. Rich people usually have holding corporations or trust funds that can buy their yacht, and employ a wide range of tax evasion techniques carried out by an army of specialist lawyers and accountants to minimise tax impact to the absolute minimum. They play a different game than you or me, but on the same playing field.
- graemep 2y agoI think you agree with me? To clarify, rich people will spend more on the things subject to VAT than the rest of us. They will spend a lot more on entertainment, maintaining houses, cars and fuel, luxury consumables etc. However, a much higher proportion of their spending will be able to escape VAT because they can evade VAT (and income tax) to a much grater extent.
- 9dev 2y agoYes, I think so too. I guess I just didn't get the tax evasion aspect in relation to VAT.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Depends on your definition of rich, your definition of "lion's share" and where in the west Not really, it just requires pointing out that the rates you’re using to compare the modern West and Ancient Rome are much, much higher in every case for the latter. > In the UK I’ll admit I don’t know British figures well, so you may have a point. (As a small country, it has e.g. non-dom issues the EU, China and America do not.) In the U.S., about half of taxes are paid by the top 1%. That’s not commensurate with our power or privilege. But it’s also not nothing.
- redczar 2y agoRelatively, yes. In aggregate, the rich pay the lion’s share of taxes in the West. Your comment defeats the point you are trying to make. When talking about paying fair share or paying enough in taxes it’s the relative part that matters; not the aggregate.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoOP didn’t say fair, they said the rich “don’t pay much.” In America, the rich pay like half the Treasury’s till. It should be more. But that’s a separate question.
- redczar 2y agoThe meaning of “don’t pay much” in common usage on this topic means relativley speaking.