7 ms·
Entrepreneurs Tell The White House To Focus On Innovation, Not IP Enforcement
- ScottBurson 14y agoI am very impressed with this letter. It summarizes the main points succinctly and forcefully without demonizing ("MAFIAA") or taking on fringe positions ("intellectual property is theft").
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThis letter needs more distinguished signatories. The people who signed it are accomplished in their domains but relatively unknown outside their niches.
- priestc 14y agoI don't know, twitter, reddit, foursquare... those are all big names
- michaelpinto 14y agofrom my years of experience working on policy issues i can tell you this: letters like this never really do anything, sadly what works is lobbying. lobbying requires both organization and money. the people who have a stake in IP enforcement not only have money, but represent well established industries that provide an base of existing jobs. so unless entrepreneurs can get their act together -- or unless you can get the grassroots excited about giving money this really isn't going to go anywhere.
- unimpressive 14y ago> letters like this never really do anything, sadly what works is lobbying. I'd really like to see tech companies get off their moral high horse and buy my politicians. Their current handlers are about to destroy the 21st century.
- wmeredith 14y agoDonate to companies like the ACLU and EFF. They're basically doing just what you're asking for.
- electic 14y agoI think it is a great article. I really think that all copyrights and patents do is stifle innovation and sadly, they increase the costs for everyone....including right owners themselves. It makes me cringe to see how much money Google and Apple have to spend to duke it out in court. I am sure they feel this way, but it seems like an ever escalating black hole where only the lawyers benefit.
- briandear 14y agoIf I spend $1 million to develop something innovative and the guy next to me stole that innovation; he effectively stole $1 million from me. That's a huge disincentive to spending another million to innovate. Copyrights and patents don't stifle innovation, they protect the creators and the resources they expended. To drive innovation, people need to innovate, not steal. If I can't copy the iPhone, then that drives me to create something even better, not just an iPhone with a few little tweaks. For those that disagree, I challenge you to open source all of the code you're working on for your companies. Then, I'll set up an exact clone of your application (including using your logo) and start making money from your work. That would encourage you to innovate right? Cool, innovate, then I'll use the new code you made, along with the new logo and continue making money from your work. How is THAT fair? If you bake amazing cookies and sell them in a shop, should that cookie recipe be given away to a competitor? Intellectual property is a critical piece of developing a competitive advantage. Take away that competitive advantage and we might as well be the Soviet Union. If you create something, you should have the right to profit from it. If you look at the innovation in China, especially in software, it's very flat because the protections there are almost non-existent. You build something there and it's copied almost instantly, so the incentive to innovate is much, much lower. Be careful what you wish for.
- shawnee_ 14y agoYou are missing the point. The point is that innovation drives advancements technology, and litigation stifles innovation. Money that companies spend litigating products which will likely be outdated / deprecated in a couple years is not money well spent. So what if Samsung and Apple both make use of a light-weight rectangular touchscreen? Consumers benefit more when there are competing interests than when there is a monopoly. Consumers benefit when there are two separate branches iterating outward and improving something very basic.
- briandear 14y agoIt's a good letter, but I would have appreciated a mention of lowering corporate taxes. With a 35% corporate tax rate, that does encourage innovation -- innovation in tax avoidance. Think of the innovation that could happen if companies had a 15% corporate tax rate.. that would mean 20% available capital to companies. If I suddenly had access to 20% more capital, I would hire more people and build more things. A 35% corporate tax rate is the highest in the industrialized world and it's as big a detriment to company growth as any IP battle.
- March_Hare 14y agoThe corporate tax rate is progressive, barely. Making it more progressive is also and option. 75.000 - 10.000.000 is taxed at 34%, adding some granularity would help. source: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/11 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/11
- biot 14y agoI'm not an accountant, but aren't the salaries paid to people you hire expenses thus not subject to corporate tax? In other words, if you make $1M a year and spend $1M a year on salaries, you pay $0 in taxes. If you instead spend $800K on salaries and have no other expenses, you pay tax on the $200K in profit. Besides which, the point of the letter was to argue a single point: innovation over enforcement. Why stuff it up with topics like taxes, healthcare, or any other unrelated topic that would only serve to dilute the core message?
- rayiner 14y agoYou're right. Taxes are in income net of salaries and expenses. If the tax rate was 15% versus 35%, the correct statement is not that it'd free up 20% of revenue for expansion, but rather that it would increase profits, presumably creating greater incentives for expansion. The way taxes are structured, lower taxes is a second-order incentives issue, not a first-order availability of funds for expansion issue.
- mgkimsal 14y ago
- blhack 14y agoAnd the white house promptly ignores it. Guys, it took a near shutdown of the internet to get congress to back off on SOPA/PIPA. I don't think a mere letter is going to sway anybody that matters.
- snowwrestler 14y agoWhat do these entrepreneurs all have in common? They own, operate, or invest in server-side Internet services. Such innovative products do not need IP enforcement because their core IP assets are protected by the client/server barrier, or they depend on network effects to protect first-mover advantage. Innovations which must be shipped in whole to the client--like new music, new movies, new games, packaged software, client device software, pharmaceuticals--are not so blessed. For example: most video game companies ship their entire IP directly to the customer. What keeps from making a copy of Skyrim and selling it on my website for half the price of the original? The legal enforcement of IP protections. I think it is really easy to fall into a bubble where "innovation" comes to mean "the latest hosted social web service". There's a lot more to innovation than that. Which was more innovative--The Dark Knight, or Triggit? I would say TDK, which was a major cultural event in the U.S. Or how about Gardasil vs. I Can Haz Cheezeburger? One will prevent thousands of cases of uterine cancer, the other hosts user-generated cat pictures.
- smashing 14y agoTo be fair to "I Can Haz Cheezeburger", which admittedly is hard to do on forum like this, it brings entertainment to millions of all ages and hurts no one. Where are the negative side effects in that?
- ori_b 14y agoWhere was the argument that "I Can Haz Cheezeburger" is harmful? The argument is that they don't benefit from new copyright legislation, and any new legislation is likely to be a burden to them because they'd likely have to police their users more intensively. The list of signatures is from companies like these. On the other hand, industries that rely on shipping an easily duplicable product with high up-front costs for development are likely to benefit from strong copyright enforcement. They are not on this list, in spite of being arguably more innovative. Neither result is surprising, but saying "Entrepreneurs" and "innovators" are generally in support of less copyright legislation is disingenuous.
- 14y ago
- georgemcbay 14y agoFollowup: White House tells Entrepreneurs to Focus on Donating to their Reelection Campaigns. (Note: This is not a dig on the current White House occupants who I voted for and will vote for again, just politics in general).
- drumdance 14y agoWhere's Peter Thiel when you really need him?
- Professoroak 14y agoIt's a nice idea, but the White House won't do shit unless they think it will help them get reelected.
- propercoil 14y agoyeah no one there gives a crap about entrepreneurs. if you still think they care bout anything else than money then i got a bridge i want to sell ya