3 ms·
> What's the policy response to supply contraction causing people to lose their jobs? What does that tend to do to exchange rates? You’re acting like the Asian
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> What's the policy response to supply contraction causing people to lose their jobs? What does that tend to do to exchange rates?
You’re acting like the Asian financial crisis or like Argentina haven’t existed.
> If they are offering discounts to other buyers, then won't those buyers then take the advantage and re-export to the US?
Across-the-board tariffs.
> when you could just pay the 10% tariff and get the same amount of less money for less effort?
Stability. Again, you’re acting like Smoot-Hawley didn’t happen.
> To 'dump' Treasuries somebody else has to buy them - so no fewer Treasuries
Nobody…said as much. In this case, look at Russia in the late 90s.
> where's the problem?
People buy the treasuries on the secondary market and then have less demand on the primary. That lowers their price which raises yields. That, in turn, makes the policy remedy you suggested at the top—for unemployment—more difficult as it requires monetising the debt.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoTo elaborate on your last point, high yields are macroeconomically detrimental on several fronts. On one hand, They provide a safe haven for Capital which diminishes investment and growth. On the other end, servicing that higher debt interest means more taxes and again lower growth.
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoYup. Basically supply contraction puts people out of work, which requires lowering rates by selling bonds, but exporters under duress are also dumping their bonds, which means you need to print more money than you otherwise would to push rates down. Those dollars create inflationary pressure whose solution is raising rates. But you can’t because of the supply disruption. Basically, Trump and Musk have engineered stagflation.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoOne thing I really struggle to understand is the economic arguments for large national debts, which seem to be a mainstay of modern nations. Is it as simple as countries really cant help themselves? It seems so clear to me that the economically superior position is lower deficit spending, extremely low treasury yields, high investment, and high growth. Am I severely underestimating the effectiveness of government spending at stimulating growth? It seems that large deficit spending should be reserved emergency stimulus for correction, not a feature of healthy growing economy, and their use during "good times" diminish capacity for use in the "bad times"