3 ms·
This is a good, involved, and deep article on robotics in warfare. Some of the memes, like "cost to go to war" are quite frankly old chestnuts -- true for hundr
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
This is a good, involved, and deep article on robotics in warfare. Some of the memes, like "cost to go to war" are quite frankly old chestnuts -- true for hundreds of years and just repeated here. (I'm reminded of one' historian's view of the American Civil War -- the north would have won anyway because, compared to other civil wars, the north really was never completely committed)
I began reading the article due to the cute title iamelgringo gave it -- here's a plug for re-editing titles for the HN audience.
What concerns me is what wasn't mentioned: the goal of warfare is to make the other side stop fighting. We will certainly develop and create expensive drones and such for the elimination of enemy combatants. As the Air Force lieutenant general forecasts in the article, that "given the growth trends, it is not unreasonable to postulate future conflicts involving tens of thousands [of drones]"
But that's assuming we fight wars the way we want to fight them, instead of the wars we end up with. In the article, the example is given of a little ground bot made for recon. Soldiers quickly learned that you could strap a claymore on the front of the bot and use it as sort of an intelligent roaming land mine. Cost of such a new kind of bot? About $5K.
To make the other side stop fighting, you don't necessarily have to engage his military or command centers. I can see non-state actors evolving cheap bots to attack civilians and instill fear. Instead of a smart bomb, I guess you'd call it a smart terrorist bomb -- perhaps hundreds of RC airplanes with intelligent chips and biological weapons as payloads, or RC cars loaded with C-4 that wait in storm drains for days or weeks on end to launch a coordinated attack.
Bots are coming in war, like it or not. But what concerns me isn't the big Matrix-type bots: it's the power of small, cheap, smart bots that about anybody can assemble in bulk.