3 ms·
To me, $6 billion seems really cheap for a project that seems pretty vital to the city's long term health, safety and security. Compare this to the ~$10 billio
by hkmurakami 14y ago
To me, $6 billion seems really cheap for a project that seems pretty vital to the city's long term health, safety and security.
Compare this to the ~$10 billion for the California High Speed Rail project, which doesn't seem nearly as important as this NYC project.
- tsunamifury 14y agoThe importance of a project has little correlation with how expensive it is to execute.
- RickHull 14y ago> The importance of a project has little correlation with how expensive it is to execute. Right, but it should be the primary factor on whether to undertake it or not.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoThis is not really true since cheap, highly important projects tend to get done pretty early on. That means the marginal project we are now embarking on does tend to have a relatively high cost-importance correlation.
- rayiner 14y agoEconomically linking the SF Bay and LA metropolises could have tremendous importance over the next 100 years (which is the time scale a project like this should be evaluate on).
- rdl 14y agoI think you mean more like $100-150b for Cal-HSR.
- rwhitman 14y agoHaving lived the last 2 years in NYC and the previous 7 in CA I can say that high speed rail is the more valuable project. The water here is fine, and no one is suffering because there isn't a 3rd tunnel. But the transportation situation in California is archaic and frustrating. Have you ever been trapped in traffic on the grapevine for 4 hours trying to get to/from LA? Or shelled out $300 for an hour flight to SFO? Its maddening. I drink water out of the tap here in NYC and it tastes great. California rail is a crisis, the water supply to NYC is not.
- ry0ohki 14y agoHow much will train tickets cost? Taking the high speed rail from DC to NYC costs about the same as flying.
- angersock 14y agoPerhaps, but consider what happens if something does go wrong with the water supply--this is not something that can be patched overnight. A rail system is well and good, but you can at least take a car or bus if you need to. If your water infrastructure stops working, there aren't many other games in town.