5 ms·
Surgeons in England to adopt checklists - expect to halve death rate
- a-priori 18y agoAs a member of the general public, I do find it hard to believe this sort of thing isn't done already. As a victim of a minor surgical mishap myself (general anaesthesia applied when it shouldn't have been), I can definitely believe "incidents" happen all the time.
- m0nty 18y ago"I do find it hard to believe this sort of thing isn't done already." I showed a similar article to my wife (has worked in healthcare for 20+ years) and she said "Oh yes, we do that all the time. Everything has a check-list." So if it makes a difference, I guess it is either mandated for higher-level staff (surgeons and consultants who are often a law unto themselves) or rigidly enforced at all levels. Also, the study might show bias because people will do the lists if they know it's being assessed for an experiment, but might ignore it on a day-to-day basis.
- dcurtis 18y agoAny doctor who reads the study and sees the 50% reduction in death rate in surgeries and 90% reduction in accidental deaths in the ICU would be negligent to ignore checklists. If this surgery checklist and the ICU checklist were to be implemented in every hospital, they would save more lives than all new medications introduced in the last five years, combined. Ignoring results like that is just asinine.
- Alex3917 18y ago"Any doctor who reads the study and sees the 50% reduction in death rate in surgeries and 90% reduction in accidental deaths in the ICU would be negligent to ignore checklists." Unless the government has made it illegal.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoAlthough I've only had non-trivial procedures done on me once or twice, I've never seen a checklist used. As for ignoring checklists on a day to day basis, this could be solved by making them a required part of a patient's medical record. That way, doctors are constantly being assessed on the basis of completing a checklist. You could even publish stats on it. "No checklist, no payment" would also be a good way to enforce it.
- rgrieselhuber 18y agoSeems like such a no-brainer for hospitals everywhere.
- gravitycop 18y agoHere's the checklist: http://www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/tools_resources/SSSL_Checklist_finalJun08.pdf http://www.who.int/patientsafety/safesurgery/tools_resources... [PDF]
- andreyf 18y agoBefore the patient leaves operating room, make sure that instrument, sponge and needle counts are correct. And I always thought that was a joke... guess not.
- iamelgringo 18y agoThat's what OR nurses generally do, count sponges, needles and instruments. They also have to be willing to nose to nose with a crabby surgeon and tell him to re-open the patient and try to find the missing sponge when the count is off
- dcurtis 18y agoFinally. The idea for a checklist in clinical settings was originally conceived by Peter Pronovost at Johns Hopkins. Last year, Gawande wrote an awesome essay for the New Yorker about the ICU checklists that were attempted in the US (saving hundreds of lives) but eventually cancelled by regulatory authorities-- "If you're changing the way things are done, you need to perform controlled FDA-approved studies." http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/12/10/071210fa_fact_gawande http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2007/12/10/071210fa_fact_... Also, you should read his book Better, which is just page after page of interesting stuff; Atul Gawande is the Malcom Gladwell of medicine, but I think his stuff is far more engaging.
- Alex3917 18y agoThis combined with How Doctors Think made me realize that our doctors in the US are really no better than witch doctors. In fact in some ways going to a shaman is probably better. They are less likely to cure you, but they are also vastly less likely to kill you by accident. A pretty good tradeoff, considering that medical accidents are the leading cause of death in the US. http://www.ourcivilisation.com/medicine/usamed/deaths.htm http://www.ourcivilisation.com/medicine/usamed/deaths.htm http://www.ourcivilisation.com/medicine/usamed.htm http://www.ourcivilisation.com/medicine/usamed.htm And this isn't even counting the fact that none of our antibiotics are working anymore because our medical system sees fit to use over 70% of our total antibiotics produced each year in animal feed.
- andreyf 18y agomedical accidents are the leading cause of death in the US I thought it was obesity? Or smoking? Or drinking and driving? none of our antibiotics are working anymore I don't know, they worked great both when I had lyme disease and when I had bronchitis...
- Alex3917 18y ago"I thought it was obesity? Or smoking? Or drinking and driving?" Obesity isn't as dangerous as was previously thought, not that many people smoke anymore, and the dangers of driving after a drink or two are vastly overstated. "I don't know, they worked great both when I had lyme disease and when I had bronchitis..." Probably not penicillin.
- tome 18y agoAlthough it might not mean much to those outside the UK, this applies to "England and Wales", not just "England".
- delano 18y agoOf course, we love the Welsh! Also, it was a world-wide study that's been implemented in many places. Canada too: http://www.cbc.ca/health/story/2009/01/14/surgery-check-list.html http://www.cbc.ca/health/story/2009/01/14/surgery-check-list...
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- gaius 18y agoWelsh for checklist is "look you, boyo!" :-)
- gravitycop 18y agoThere are three columns on the checklist. Here is the first column: SIGN IN □ PATIENT HAS CONFIRMED • IDENTITY • SITE • PROCEDURE • CONSENT □ SITE MARKED/NOT APPLICABLE □ ANAESTHESIA SAFETY CHECK COMPLETED □ PULSE OXIMETER ON PATIENT AND FUNCTIONING DOES PATIENT HAVE A: KNOWN ALLERGY? □ NO □ YES DIFFICULT AIRWAY/ASPIRATION RISK? □ NO □ YES, AND EQUIPMENT/ASSISTANCE AVAILABLE RISK OF >500ML BLOOD LOSS (7ML/KG IN CHILDREN)? □ NO □ YES, AND ADEQUATE INTRAVENOUS ACCESS AND FLUIDS PLANNED
- gravitycop 18y agoHere is the second column: TIME OUT □ CONFIRM ALL TEAM MEMBERS HAVE INTRODUCED THEMSELVES BY NAME AND ROLE □ SURGEON, ANAESTHESIA PROFESSIONAL AND NURSE VERBALLY CONFIRM • PATIENT • SITE • PROCEDURE ANTICIPATED CRITICAL EVENTS □ SURGEON REVIEWS: WHAT ARE THE CRITICAL OR UNEXPECTED STEPS, OPERATIVE DURATION, ANTICIPATED BLOOD LOSS? □ ANAESTHESIA TEAM REVIEWS: ARE THERE ANY PATIENT-SPECIFIC CONCERNS? □ NURSING TEAM REVIEWS: HAS STERILITY (INCLUDING INDICATOR RESULTS) BEEN CONFIRMED? ARE THERE EQUIPMENT ISSUES OR ANY CONCERNS? HAS ANTIBIOTIC PROPHYLAXIS BEEN GIVEN WITHIN THE LAST 60 MINUTES? □ YES □ NOT APPLICABLE IS ESSENTIAL IMAGING DISPLAYED? □ YES □ NOT APPLICABLE
- danw 18y agoSounds a bit like Scrum (the agile methodology). The Surgeon/Anaesthesia/Nursing teams reviewing what has been/needs to be done out loud to each other is similar to a daily stand up and the initial sprint planning meeting in a scrum team. Saying things out loud to each other makes a social bargain that they will/have been done.
- prakash 18y agoCharlie Munger talks about this in his book, Poor Charlie's Almanac.
- jsdalton 18y agoDoes anyone here use checklists in a similar manner for application development?
- abstractbill 18y agoI don't, but people won't die if my software doesn't work.
- yellowbkpk 18y agoI don't, but people may die if my software doesn't work. Our managers do...
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- tjic 18y agoGiven that the death rate used to be 100%, I find it really exciting that the death rate will now be halved. Downside: all the zombies.
- yan 18y agoEver since I started taking flying lessons, I have been tempted to use checklists for everything else in life.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- gravitycop 18y agothough this was not statistically significant That modifier is dangling. Here is a rephrasing: but richer countries saw a smaller decline (though this difference in decline rates was not statistically significant) in deaths of about a third."
- clevercode 18y agoYou are correct, I should have read more carefully.
- Jem 18y agoI had v. minor "surgery" before Christmas and I got asked that many questions I started to think they were taking the piss. Based on that, it surprises me that they don't already have this checklist thing in place!
- kcy 18y agoI'm a med student and a programmer. I think there are a lot of similarities between these two disciplines. The body is an incredibly complex system that you or a pathological process can perturb in a variety of ways, just like any other system. The results of those perturbations may be evident immediately or may take a long time to present themselves. The results are output in the form of physical signs and symptoms. The way this particular system works is that there are more potential pathologies than there are physical signs and symptoms, so sometimes you end up with collisions in the pathology to sign/symptom mapping. In these cases you can use instruments like labs, radiological tests, and sometimes invasive methods like surgery to further investigate. These tests are imperfect and are themselves perturbations to the system. If you can come to a final diagnosis of the underlying pathology using the tools at your disposal (history, physical exam, labs, tests, and procedures) you can then engage in a therapy. The more precise your diagnosis, the more precise your therapy can be. Again, therapies are also perturbations to the system. Ideally these perturbations move the system back into its normal functioning state though they may also cause undesired results that must then be diagnosed and treated. This entire process takes place within the context of a social interaction that can itself help or hinder. Both doctors and patients have their own social idiosyncrasies that may or may not match up well with each other. I believe that most physicians operate by generating a gigantic hash table. Essentially they know several patterns of physical signs/symptoms that act as the key. The value is whatever knowledge they have of that disease process. As medical knowledge progresses some physicians update their hash table keys/values with new information, most don't. Almost all physicians update their hash table (i.e. learn) using information gathered in the process of seeing their own patients and recognizing the difference between the predicted outcome and the actual outcome. This is often a subjective process. I think it is because of this approach that most physicians find it hard to believe that medical diagnosis and treatment can be highly systematized and is at least partially such an obvious idea even needs a study to support its use.
- daniel-cussen 18y agoIn other news: schools to start using Dvorak in 2045.